StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Cause and effect on the Dred Scott Supreme Court Decision - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper postulates that the ramifications of the Supreme Court ruling on the Dred Scott case was wide reaching and ultimately affected economic, social and political aspects of the USA. Moreover this paper will provide some general background information on the overall causes and effect of the case…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Cause and effect on the Dred Scott Supreme Court Decision
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Cause and effect on the Dred Scott Supreme Court Decision"

Download file to see previous pages

The reasoning behind the Supreme Court decision on the Dred Scott Case is complex. The ultimate conclusion was that African Americans (Born abroad or in the USA) by nature of their heritage and race were not Citizens nor could they become Citizens and ultimately, were not protected by the Constitution. As such it was the case that slaves could not sue in court by nature of their citizenship rights, Moreover it was also decided that the American Congress didn’t have the ability to prohibit slavery and as such they could not be confiscated without some sort of due-process.

The background of the case is stored. According to Watson.org (1998) Scott was a slave, born in Virginia around the turn of the 19th century and was owned by Dr. John Emerson (An Army doctor who frequently traveled). At some time during Emerson’s travels he brought Scott to several free-states for a period exceeding seven years. After the Death of Emerson, Scott claimed ill treatment by Emerson’s wife (Eliza) who denied his right to purchaser his freedom. Scot brought forward a case stating that he was free by virtue of his living in Free States and by his willingness to purchase his freedom.

From the perspective of economic causes and effects of the Supreme Court decision on the Dred Scot case there are a number of factors at play. . dollars were living in the USA around this time. This factor would weigh heavily on the decision makers. Ultimately as an effect, if the court ruling had gone another direction it would open the door to probably an endless supply of slaves bringing cases There were a number of social causes and effects pertaining to this court ruling. Even though there was a strong abolitionist movement it remained the case that blacks were regarded as beneath all whites.

According to PBS (2011) it was the case that under the interpretation of the Constitution by Chief Justice Roger Taney (A slavery supporter) it was believed that blacks had no rights that white men were obliged to respect. Moreover because blacks had no rights and were as such beneath white men than blacks may be enslaved for the benefit of whites and can be treated as a piece of property. Building on this previous point, it was also argued that even though the Declaration of Independence stated that “All men are created equal” it was argued that the African race was never intended to be included as they had played no part in framing the declaration.

As a result of this court decision, it is likely that this drove a greater wedge between abolitionists and slavery supporters insofar as the poorly argued rhetoric of this decision would have enraged most abolitionists. Moreover, the attempt by abolitionists to impose federal rulings on slavery supporters would have likely enraged this group as well. Without question, there were a number of political causes and effects that would have played a significant role in this court case and decision.

Although it may seem like an over simplification, states that had abolished slavery were developing economies that could be described as being more

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Cause and effect on the Dred Scott Supreme Court Decision Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1412341-cause-and-effect-on-the-dred-scott-supreme-court
(Cause and Effect on the Dred Scott Supreme Court Decision Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1412341-cause-and-effect-on-the-dred-scott-supreme-court.
“Cause and Effect on the Dred Scott Supreme Court Decision Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1412341-cause-and-effect-on-the-dred-scott-supreme-court.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Cause and effect on the Dred Scott Supreme Court Decision

Dred Scott v.s. Sanford 1856

Name and Number Date dred scott v.... Sanford, 1856 Creating unrest, controversy, and fueling the debate over the legalization and expansion of slavery throughout the United States dred scott v.... dred scott v.... Sanford was a case in which dred scott a slave born in Virginia between 1795 and 1800 sues an heir of the estate which owned him for freedom for himself, his wife, and children (Library of Congress n.... hellip; The initial decision dismissing the case along with the subsequent rulings and reversals sparked continuing disruption and fear in the north and the south....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Manifest Destiny and the Civil War

Within this context, the case known as the dred scott Case began with a lawsuit initiated by Dred Scott, a slave, against the widow of Dr Emerson, the slave owner.... the dred scott decision determined whether the Federal Government would take ultimate power over States in the question of slavery, or not.... By 1787, slavery was recognized in the Constitution (General History of the United Sates supreme court, accessed 2011).... Van Zandt, 1847: General History of the United Sates supreme court, accessed 2011))....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Whitney v California, Illinois v Gates, Dred Scott v Sandford

In the ruling from the United States supreme court, the court determined that the government could not reprimand inflammatory speeches unless it can be proved that the intent was to incite and the speech itself also has the potential to incite as alleged.... The case was taken to the supreme court after it was ruled that the search was against the law and that the decision of the judge to issue a warrant on anonymous tip was unlawful (Carmen and Walker 51a).... In the ruling of the court, the judges in a vote that resulted into 9-0 arrived into a determination that it did not violate the provision necessitating Whitney's conviction (Whitney 49)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

United States Supreme Court and the Constitution

McCloskey points out that the government as well as society was at first adamantly opposed to the supreme court.... He points out that Americans had a predisposition on how the supreme court would function; … McCloskeys' thesis is that the decisions of the United States supreme court lean congruently with popular American opinion.... Some historians have put forth the administrative argument that Chief Justice John Marshall was the first Chief Justice of the United States supreme court, albeit belies the historical facts....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Major Landmark Decisions

Paul Finkelman in dred scott v.... The Enabling Act of 1820 represented a win, win, situation for most of the parties directly involved; Missouri entered the union as they had petitioned, with no conditions or restrictions on their status, and the anti-slavery proponents were reasonably assured that slavery would not encroach on the neighboring territories....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Marbury vs Madison and the Power of Judicial Review

This should not be taken that the supreme court overpowers the other two branches.... The power of the supreme court to make pronouncements as regards existing laws is not an absolute power.... Madison is considered a very important landmark case in the history of the Unite States supreme court.... supreme court was able to declare and exercise its power of judicial review.... However, the court is able to exercise the power to uphold or deny the congressional and executive actions in passing upon the issue of constitutionality....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Cause and Effect of the Dread's Scott Decision

The paper "cause and effect of the Dread's Scott Decision" states that Frederick Douglass, a prominent African-American abolitionist who thought the decision unconstitutional and the Chief Justice's reasoning inapposite to the founders' vision political conflict could not be avoided.... With Dred Scott, the supreme court under Taney sought to permit the unhindered expansion of slavery into the territories.... Set against the economic, social and political background of the mid-19th century, the decision was a landmark for initiating the struggle which ended in the abolition of slavery, the end of industries which relied on black labor, and the era of political struggles which aimed to put the black man at equal terms with white American citizens in the spirit of “equality, liberty and brotherhood” in the motto of the French Revolution, “Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Scott v. Sanford

Therefore he (Dred Scott Case: The supreme court decision, n.... Dred scott case: the supreme court decision.... the dred scott decision.... supreme court where it was heard and decided upon by Chief Justice Roger B.... The fact of the case is that dred scott, an African-American slave from the slave state of Missouri had an opportunity to live in certain free states of… Army surgeon Dr.... The fact of the case is that dred scott, an African-American slave from the slave state of Missouri had an opportunity to live in certain free states of America thanks in part to his owner/master U....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us