StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Partition after Civil Wars - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This research paper "Partition after Civil Wars" shows that the author has attempted to explore the question of whether the partition could result in the permanent solution for the ethnic conflicts and wars. By questioning the argument of maintaining multi-cultural and multi-ethnic communities…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.5% of users find it useful
Partition after Civil Wars
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Partition after Civil Wars"

?The Holy Land Divided: Defending Partition as a solution to ethnic wars Research Question The has attempted to explore the question of whether the partition could result into the permanent solution for the ethnic conflicts and wars. By questioning the argument of maintaining multi-cultural and multi-ethnic communities, author has suggested that civil and ethnic conflicts make it difficult for the nations and States to rebuild the same type of society. As such partition can offer a viable alternative to avoid the future ethnic wars. Theoretical Argument The overall theoretical arguments are based on the assumption that it is often difficult to reconstruct a multi-ethnic society after the conflict between different ethnic groups in a given country. The resulting settlements of the issue after the bloody civil wars can often result into further bloodshed. Breakout of the State as a result of the ethnic issues therefore can put different ethnicities against each other and make the overall experiment worse because of the ease with which methods like ethnic cleansing can be adapted. What is also significant to understand that author has critically argued that in order to avoid ethnic civil wars, it is important that partition should be considered as one of the viable policy alternative. This argument is based on the assumptions that the ethnic conflicts have almost similar dynamics thus making it difficult to put back the multi-ethnic state in same state as before the war. Independent and Dependent Variables A closer analysis of the article would suggest that author has attempted to create link between the ethnic conflicts and civil wars with the partition. As such the dependent variable is the partition of the geographical areas whereas the achievement of peace and lack of conflict as a result of the ethnic conflict as an independent variable. Author therefore argued that by adapting partition as a viable policy alternative ethnic conflicts can be averted in societies which are plagued by the ethnic and multi-cultural violence and conflicts. Method of Analysis Author has adapted multiple methods of analysis by blending quantitative as well as qualitative analysis. Major method of analysis adapted by the author is case studies as well as the survey methodology. Case studies are often based upon an in-depth analysis of certain events, groups or individuals and as such can provide a comprehensive overview of subjects under review. Author has provided comprehensive details of the different ethnic conflicts which took place and the results of their settlement. Author has also used survey of the existing literature to present a theoretical analysis of the overall context of the ethnic conflicts and their solutions. Survey of existing literature also offers a valid theoretical platform based on which author can actually build the theoretical foundations for the research undertaken. By citing various examples from history author has actually been successful in providing a comprehensive overview of how the different negotiating settlements failed due to non-partition based solutions to the problem of ethnic conflicts. Conclusion This article is comprehensive in the sense that it has offered a very comprehensive overview of the historical accounts of the different ethical and cultural conflicts. The overall theoretical foundations are set to discuss various approaches forwarded to resolve the multi-ethnic conflicts and how they failed to achieve the desired results. Author has adapted case study approach under which an overview of the different conflicts and their settlements. The overall conclusion of the article is that the partition can be one of the feasible policy alternatives to solve the ethnic conflicts and avoid civil wars. Are you convinced? Why? Though partition can be one of the key policy alternatives however, to get an overall acceptability of the same may remain one of the key challenges to such policy alternatives. In case such as Palestine and Israel where a separate State has been created for both the parties however, the region still remains one of the most volatile regions in the world. Further the creation of Israel has not been accepted by Palestinian people or other Arab States and the overall probability of conflict still remain high. What is also significant to note that the author’s approach is based upon a historical analysis of the facts and the failure of the different settlements done in order to avoid the conflicts? Partition has been presented as a viable alternative to avoid such conflicts however; partition may not be the only solution to avoid the multi-ethnic conflicts in societies which are already divided on different lines. What is in line? Is partition a solution to civil war Research Question The underlying research questions discussed in this article are based upon the notion of whether Partition can actually result into permanent settlement for the civil wars and ethnic conflicts. Though the authors agree that partition can be a viable solution however, this may not provide a permanent solution to end civil wars because of different factors outlined in the article. Author therefore question that partition may not be long term solution because civil wars often recur and conflicts re-emerge again. Authors have further argued that the statistical weaknesses in the previous empirical studies and suggested that based on the quantitative analysis of the data, partition may not have a pacifying affect on the ethnically divided nations engaged in civil war. Theoretical Argument Authors provide the argument against the use of partition as a viable policy alternative to achieve the pacifying affect in a society which is in conflict based on the ethnic grounds. The authors argued that the conditions under which partition can provide any tangible results can be limited and therefore may not provide the desired results. What is also significant to note that the authors have outlined the different issues with the empirical studies conducted in the past and suggested that the empirical studies in favor of partitions may have their inherent limitations and therefore may not provide the correct results. Authors have further outlined that factors such as forced relocations increase the overall risks of the partition and may render it as ineffective policy option. Independent and Dependent Variables The dependent variable in this study is again the resulting peace and lack of conflict which may or may not be a direct result of the partition. Authors have kept partition as an independent variable and the ethnic and cultural conflicts and civil wars dependent variables which can be subdued if territorial partition is exercised as a policy option. Methods of Analysis This article has also been written by using a mix of qualitative as well as quantitative analysis techniques. What is critically more important about this article is that the authors have taken an approach wherein they have also discussed the inherent weaknesses of the different statistical techniques used in the previous empirical studies. Authors have taken the case study approach wherein past events have been surveyed in order to explore the dynamics behind their occurrence and how they were settled by the respective parties to the conflict. Further, authors have also used some statistical techniques such as regression and correlation analysis to evaluate the link between the post-partition state of affairs with the partition. The overall aim was to understand whether partition could actually result into peace after the conflict and civil war. Authors have also used coding as a method to code and define different events such as partition, civil war etc in a postwar scenario in order to measure the effects of same on the peace in the region as a result of the partition. Conclusion It has been argued in the article that peace is a nonlinear variable and does not occur in a predictable fashion. As such the recurrence of war after the conflicts is a real chance because of the differences which arise as a result of the changes which take place due to partition. The resulting hate and increasing gap between different groups arising as a result of the partition become so deep that the recurrence of civil war becomes a real possibility in the region. authors argue that the empirically there is no strong link which can suggest that the postwar stability can be achieved as a result of partition and it can only widen the gap between the different groups and make it difficult for them to reconcile their differences. Though authors agree that the empirically the question of whether partition can serve as a viable policy alternative to achieve peace is not settled but a closer analysis of facts would suggest that partition may not be a viable solution. Are you convinced? Why? Arguments presented in this article are convincing in the sense that they are backed up by empirical data. Authors have presented a set of well written arguments outlining different factors which can potentially derail the peace process and can effectively end the peace in the post partition era. Authors therefore have been able to present a very coherent set of arguments in terms of suggesting that partition may not be a viable solution to end the civil and ethnic conflicts in any given society. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Partition after Civil Wars Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/family-consumer-science/1415081-partition-after-civil-wars
(Partition After Civil Wars Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/family-consumer-science/1415081-partition-after-civil-wars.
“Partition After Civil Wars Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/family-consumer-science/1415081-partition-after-civil-wars.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Partition after Civil Wars

Civil Liberties, Habeas Corpus, and the War on Terror

Presidents, in times of wars and emergencies, have extraordinary authority accompanied with possession of executive powers that result in asserted violations of rights of the constitution and other known legal rights.... Many courts, in their habeas corpus jurisdiction, have handled issues regarding separation of powers during wars.... civil Liberties, Habeas Corpus, and the War on Terror Name Institution Date Abstract Since the 9/11 terror attack, the US government has always been on the alert for any terror activity that may be directed towards the country or may be viewed as a threat to national security....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

1947 U.N.'s Special Commission on Palestine

after considering the reasons of Arabs fight in Palestine, we, as a committee does not see Arabs rule as the best suited to rule Palestine (Tal, 2000).... 1947 U.... .... s Special Commission on Palestine is a committee was created as a response to the request of making recommendations under the article 10 of Charter by the U....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Newly Established Nations in World Wars

Many of its colonial solders returned to native lands and began anti-imperial movements; Russia suffered from the civil war and the revolution (1917); Germany was subjected with obligations and reparations under the Treaty of Versailles.... New states emerged in Eastern Europe and after the collapse of the Habsburg Empire and Turkish Revolution.... after the war, Great Britain became one of the biggest debtors; the USA, and Woodrow Wilson, followed policy of isolationism; France occupied the Republic of Alsace-Lorraine but suffered from destructions caused by the war....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Managing the Partition of India

The writer of the following study intends to answer the question How Well Was the partition of India Managed.... hellip; The partition of India stands as one of the most significant events in human history.... Yet experts and citizens of India and Pakistan alike view the partition of India.... The political leaders from these two countries, having fought together for independence from the British, ultimately concocted schemes for the division and partition of the country....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

How Well Was the Partition of India Managed

Several wars between the two imperial powers finally resulted in Frances defeat and Britain was able to gain the upper hand.... The French soon after began to establish outposts, heightening the tension between Britain and France as the East India Company wanted to monopolize all trade.... This paper "How Well Was the partition of India Managed" sheds some light on the partition of India that stands as one of the most significant events in human history....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Why Have There Been so Many Wars in the Middle East since 1945

Regarding the wars in the Middle East, one can infer that it is the intervention of the western powers, ethnicity, deterioration of economic conditions and the lack of democracy and the civil wars are the main causes for wars and conflicts in the Middle East region.... This work "Why Have There Been so Many wars in the Middle East since 1945?... focuses on the real reasons concerning the wars in the Middle East since 1945.... nbsp;… Contrary to the wars fought in Africa: wars for poverty and racial discrimination, the wars in the Middle East had more complex reasons which need a thorough examination....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Ethnic Conflicts and Solutions for Them

In fact, both Downes and Fearon dedicate their works to finding the best solution for transforming violent ethnic wars into dormant diversities.... Among the main goals of his article, Alexander Downes assumes that “ending such wars with a partition or military victory may be more stable than agreements to share or diffuse power within the confines of a single state” (Downes, 2004, p.... On another hand, James Fearon (2004) wrote his “Separatist wars, Partition, and World Order” article in order to clarify the opposite view on the partition....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

India-Pakistan Wars

However, the clamor for a separate State for Muslims by the Muslim League in India led to its partition after its independence from Great Britain.... "India-Pakistan wars" paper focuses on Kashmir, the most significant reason or motivation for the three major wars between India and Pakistan.... Three major wars erupted between India and Pakistan for the period 1947, 1965, and 1971.... Either the invasion or protection of Kashmir was the main reason for these wars....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us