StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

An Individuals Right to Refuse Medical Care - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
In this piece, the following elements will be analyzed: the historical perspective (including a brief history of the Schiavo case through the judicial system and the legislature); a brief discussion on an individual’s right to refuse medical care; and the moral and ethical issues present in the case…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
An Individuals Right to Refuse Medical Care
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "An Individuals Right to Refuse Medical Care"

The paper “Terri Schiavo’s Case - One’s Right to Refuse Medical Care, Ethical Issues, Health Policy Issues" is a breathtaking example of a case study on health sciences & medicine. In this piece, the following elements will be analyzed: the historical perspective (including a brief history of the Schiavo case through the judicial system and the legislature); a brief discussion on an individual’s right to refuse medical care; and an identification and description of the moral and ethical issues present in the case; my ethical position relative to the issue; my defense of my stated ethical position; how parties (Terri, her husband, her parents, the medical staff, and taxpayers) would be affected by my ethical position; a discussion of the party that would have supported my decision and one that would have condemned my condition; the health policy considerations present in this case; a summary of the analysis; and a conclusion of what could have been done to avoid this ethical issue.

These issues will be thoroughly discussed in the following sections—with an adequate analysis which will follow shortly.II. The Historical Perspective (Judicial and Legislative)  The historical perspective is, to be brief, the fact that Terri Schiavo had a head injury which significantly impaired her. An autopsy later revealed that her brain had no significant cognitive functioning, with no chance of recovery. Overall, “there is no easy fix that will make end-of-life decision making simple and conflict-free.

”1 Legislation was put through allowing for feeding-tube removal. III. An Individual’s Right to Refuse Medical Care An individual has the right to refuse medical care, but usually, they will have to sign a form saying that they have been informed of their necessity for medical care—and are consciously making the decision not to receive medical care by outrightly refusing it. This has various potential outcomes, one of which is if appropriate medical treatment is not received, what will happen then? IV. Identification and Description of Moral and Ethical Issues Present The moral and ethical issues present include the following: whether someone can or cannot insert a feeding tube without the patient’s consent; whether someone can or cannot insert an IV without the patient’s consent; and whether or not someone can or cannot hydrate a patient without the patient’s consent.

Governor Jeb Bush passed “Terri’s Law,” stating that Terri’s feeding tube could be removed—a legislative move. V. My Ethical Position on the Issue My ethical position on the issue is that Terri’s feeding tube and hydration should not have been discontinued. In fact, I protested these end-of-life procedures when the Schiavo case was happening, in order to garner attention to how upset I felt that her rights were being violated. VI. A Defense of My Ethical Position The very basis of this ethical position is simple: any feeling being should not be denied food or water simply because there is little cognitive ability by the being.

That is not the being’s fault; that does not mean that Terri did not deserve to live simply because her cognitive ability level was relatively low. Even though the autopsy said her cognitive faculties had no significant power, now we will truly never know. VII. How Different Parties Would Be Affected by My Ethical Position Different parties would be affected in several ways. Terri would ultimately live. Her husband would probably be miserable because he would have to own up to his obligations as a husband to a woman who was severely cognitively challenged—although he would have a chance to atone for the fact that he wanted to see her dead.

Terri’s parents would be happy she would be alive, to be sure. Taxpayers might not be crazy about keeping a severely cognitively impaired woman alive, nor would necessarily her medical care providers. However, people cannot be killed in the name of inconvenience. That’s the bottom line. VIII. Discussion of One Party Pro and One Party Con One pro from one of the parties would be that, from Terri’s standpoint—she would be alive! One con from one of the parties—in Michael Schiavo’s case—would be that he would have to continue to care for his disabled wife. IX. Health Policy Considerations Health policy considerations that should have been thought about in advance include, for example: how people would regard highly cognitively disabled people after this case; and how end-of-life issues should be resolved by being fair to all parties involved. X. Summary of the Analysis Basically, the summary of my argument is that Terri Schiavo should not have been euthanized—basically being put to death by her feeding tube and dehydration having been taken out by force, due to law enforcement having passed a law that said that her feeding tube could be taken out. XI. Conclusion of What Could Have Been Done to Avoid this Issue This entire issue could have been avoided if Terri had not gotten this head injury—which was completely preventable.

In order to avoid this issue, another aspect which could have been elemental is if Terri had left behind, in writing, her wishes or advance directives as to what she would have preferred to happen to her were she to become cognitively disabled in the manner that she did.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“An Individuals Right to Refuse Medical Care Case Study”, n.d.)
An Individuals Right to Refuse Medical Care Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1761018-terri-schiavo-case
(An Individuals Right to Refuse Medical Care Case Study)
An Individuals Right to Refuse Medical Care Case Study. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1761018-terri-schiavo-case.
“An Individuals Right to Refuse Medical Care Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1761018-terri-schiavo-case.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF An Individuals Right to Refuse Medical Care

Medicare social insurance program in the US

In regard to the paternalistic argument for the government involvement in this market, it is important to denote that the constitution provides to a right in affordable health care to all Americans.... Medicare helps to provide insurance against the costs that emanate from receiving health care.... It is important to denote that the costs of accessing health care are what drive the Medicare program costs.... If the government reduces these increases in the costs of accessing health care, then it is highly possible that the cost of running the medicare program will be low....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Medicaid and the Uninsured

In response to the article by Kathleen Day (2006), it has to be said that she portrays a shocking picture of the state of medical care, suggesting that those most in need are being deprived and possibly cheated out of their right to health care.... (2003, February 12) How Much medical care Do The Uninsured Use, And Who Pays For It Health Affairs Web Exclusive.... Medicaid and the Uninsured In response to the article by Kathleen Day (2006), it has to be said that she portrays a shocking picture of the ofmedical care, suggesting that those most in need are being deprived and possibly cheated out of their right to health care....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

A Joint Venture Agreement and Central Park Medical Group

In the paper “A Joint Venture Agreement and Central Park medical Group” the author describes his experience when he has been directed by the board to enter into a joint venture agreement with Central Park medical group.... hellip; According to the federal anti-kickback statute, a part of the safe harbor regulations, it is against the law to knowingly solicit or pay a person or a group of people to refer individuals on state or government medical insurance to your medical center or group....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Medical Ethics and Duty of care

Persons who owe a duty of care to others must exercise “reasonable care in the circumstances”.... For example, in assessing whether there has been a breach of duty of care, if there is a likelihood that harm will occur, the doctor will be expected to take more precautions.... The Bolam test3 also imputes a higher level of professional liability and standard of care that is expected from a person such as a doctor who professes himself to the best in his field of expertise....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Basic Types of Public Policies

With all this, one has the right to either accept or refuse service at will.... This principle prevents pollution of the environment air dealing this is a policy which will allow individuals to have a right to use the reference of other materials.... Core ethical principles relevant to the delivery of health care    Principle of common good this principle is composed of all the conditions that the social experiences and the positivity behind those conditions....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

The Challenge of Medicare and the Most Affected

People who have kidney failure and constantly… Medicare covers hospital insurance, essentially inpatient services, medical insurance that covers outpatient services, advantage plans that focuses on services However, it is of essence to note that this insurance program is faced with numerous challenges that have led to strains on various stakeholders that access help from this program.... Worse still, the authors continue to indicate that some individuals actually spend from their pockets to get treatment (Schieber, et al....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Efficiencies and Inefficiencies in Managed Care

To develop the overall qualities of healthcare, various states along with local authorities… The development of Medicare Advantage (MA) has certainly found a source of value within its beneficiaries (Shi & Singh, 2011). The popularity of the managed care system has emerged in this modern world and the employers in the present day context get involved in making as well as executing an effective plan with utmost focus on paying premiums.... The same has been illustrated in the form of the following chart: Managed care has proved its dominance in providing “qualified health plans” with the aid of different health insurance organizations....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Best Practices for Credentialing Post-Acute Providers

The SNFs in the medical care institution should be qualified and should have several skills.... he star rating might as well reduce the chances of medical care failure, on the basis that the life of the patient is important and might not get another chance in case of failure.... The star rating comparison covers about 3500 of certified hospitals that offer medical care.... The research paper “Best Practices for Credentialing Post-Acute Providers” analyzes choosing the best and qualified SNFS, which will ensure patient satisfaction and complete home care....
30 Pages (7500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us