StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The U.S. Constitution: A Global Perspective, - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
A study by University of Virginia and Washington University scholars in 2012 reported that 160 out of 170 constitutions around the globe, as of…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
The U.S. Constitution: A Global Perspective,
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The U.S. Constitution: A Global Perspective,"

The U.S. Constitution: A Global Perspective THE U.S. CONSTITUTION: A GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE The United s constitution has acted as a respected model around the world, especially regarding governance, for two centuries. A study by University of Virginia and Washington University scholars in 2012 reported that 160 out of 170 constitutions around the globe, as of 1987, were based partially on the United States constitution. However, this is not the case twenty-five years later. An examination of 729 federal constitutions collected from 188 countries as from 1946 to 2006 was also done by New York University, looking for any resemblances to the United States constitution.

The documents were assessed with the basis on two hundred and thirty seven variables, with the main focus on human rights. The results showed that references to the US constitution were dropping in the drafting of constitutions globally. This paper aims to discuss the reasons for this decline in influence, as well as why Americans should be worried about it. In comparison to a generic bill of rights collated from sixty human rights in over 70% of constitutions globally up to 2006, the constitution of the US guarantees relatively few rights (Amar & Tushnet, 2009).

The US constitution contains less than a half of the generic rights bill, for example, health care or women’s rights. In contrast, the US constitution is rooted in a tradition of constitutional libertarianism inherently antithetical to any notion of positive rights. Freedoms of the press and self-expression, a guarantee of equality, the right to privacy and the right to private property can be found in approximately 97% of all constitutions (Amar & Tushnet, 2009). In 10% or less of these constitutions, present rights included rights for the right to bear arms, the legal protection of fetuses and the victims of cruelty.

The other constitutions, which feature the right to bear arms, are those of Mexico and Guatemala. The 1990s, during which the cold war ended, saw a period of constitution making in Eastern Europe, Asia, and Africa, and with victory in the cold war, it might have been expected to see America’s constitution influence the writing of these constitutions. However, this was not so, with a noticeable decline in relative similarity to the constitution of the United States (Amar & Tushnet, 2009). While the average constitution possesses a 38% chance of revision in any year, with replacement every nineteen years, the constitution of the US has only been amended once in the last forty years, having survived for two centuries (Fletcher & Sheppard, 2009).

In many respects, therefore, the constitution is antiquated and dysfunctional. This analysis is suggestive of the fact that the United States constitution in many ways departs from the global mainstream, while also strongly hinting that it is not widely emulated anymore. In fact, the Canadian constitution is a leading model internationally compared to that of the United States. Rather than being a leader in global constitutionalism, the United States constitution is losing appeal as a model for drafters (Fletcher & Sheppard, 2009).

While the idea of constitutional adoption might trace inspiration to the US, the manner of writing quite clearly does not. Americans should not disregard these perspectives and findings. The American people will only see the need for amendments to improve democracy only if they pay attention this trend. The American constitution is, however, very hard to amend compared to other constitutions in the world. Around the country, diverse groups and people from the right and the left are agitating for reform to, for example, create term limits in Congress, get private money away from politics, imposing balanced budget requirements for congress, and removing corporate personhood.

Americans should realize the need to update and reform its constitution to avoid additional political interpretations by the Supreme Court, with continued federal erosion of personal freedoms.ReferencesAmar, Vikram. & Tushnet, Mark. (2009). Global perspectives on constitutional law. New York : Oxford University Press.Fletcher, George. & Sheppard, Steve. (2009). American law in a global context : the basics. Oxford : Oxford Univ. Press.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The U.S. Constitution: A Global Perspective, Essay”, n.d.)
The U.S. Constitution: A Global Perspective, Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1603887-the-us-constitution-a-global-perspective
(The U.S. Constitution: A Global Perspective, Essay)
The U.S. Constitution: A Global Perspective, Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/1603887-the-us-constitution-a-global-perspective.
“The U.S. Constitution: A Global Perspective, Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1603887-the-us-constitution-a-global-perspective.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The U.S. Constitution: A Global Perspective,

Cross-National Perspectives on Education

This study text will analyze education issues on a cross-national perspective by comparing education in the United Kingdom and Japan while focussing on dominant affecting factors such as the cultural, political, and educational contexts.... In a collective perspective, education is in most cases driven by internal affairs which remain the duty of authorities at institutional levels such as the government (OECD 2003, p....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Standard Constitution in International Law

The constitution can comprise of many kinds of law like conventions, customary law, statutory law and international law.... It is… As per Davies (2014) “As a stick with which to defend oneself against government people, the constitution is a lot better than nothing”.... The primary law need to apply to all of the country's constitution whereas the secondary constitutional law may or may not be applied by a nation.... One of the theory of constitution law is originals where original understanding in regard to the language used in the formulation of constitutional law....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Proposal

Should Environmental Rights be inserted into the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms

Approaching the protection of certain rights through statutory and constitutional means is a practical and achievable initiative and, in the present age of global warming, all citizens in the world, including future generations, are entitled to protection from unhealthy environments.... According to a survey conducted by the Center for global Development, based in Washington, Canada was placed 27th out of 27 among the industrialized countries (Erin 61).... Since a nation's constitution defines its people in more ways than just a simple set of legal instructions, it should also exemplify their highest values and aspirations....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Institutions in Business Strategy

This essay stresses that from a business strategy perspective, institutions are the intangible norms, regulations and procedures that dictate how people interact within a given social and economic setting.... nbsp;Rules making up institutions reflect the values and interests of involved parties....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Kant's Perpetual Peace

Nations also formed treaties to combat global terrorism and enhance peaceful coexistence of the nations.... Kant also indicated that global peace shall arise if the worldwide community and neighbors respect the sovereignty of other nations.... In the paper “Kant's Perpetual Peace” the author analyzes Kant's Perpetual Peace....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Federalization of Crime in America

Social history of the United States of America, though is replete with instances of movements for social rights and the US Constitution, though is considered as one of the most liberal constitutions in the global context, however, it would not at all be difficult to find such examples that would point out social governance of the nation quite frequently have come up with such initiatives that have confined scopes to respect and evaluate human rights both in social and national context....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

The Fundamental Issue of The State and The Individual

The constitution of the USA does not provide citizens with an explicit right to healthcare.... The Supreme Court has held that as per the constitution, individuals can seek healthcare services at their own cost from the available service providers.... The paper 'The Fundamental Issue of The State and The Individual" states that Liberal Lockean traditions have been always fundamental to American politics and thought in providing citizens with the essential rights and powers that are considered necessary for the survival of a free society....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Perspectives Paper on the Health of Institution of the Family

To highlight this aspect of family breakdown, a sociohistorical perspective is used.... This paper ''Perspectives Paper on the Health of Institution of the Family'' tells that Macionis and Plummer (2008) suggested that the relationship structures family as an institution through blood or even adoption, and by tradition, it is built around marriage....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us