StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Workplace Risk - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
However, to prevent the reel from rolling freely downstairs as well as cause damage, the workers were asked to tie 10-feet of rope to the reel and wrap…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Workplace Risk
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Workplace Risk"

Work Place Risks Unit Introduction VICTOR J. RUNNER, Respondent, v NEW YORK STOCK EXCHANGE, case no 197 Victorwho is the plaintiff of the above case was directed to move an 800 pounded wire with several other workers down stairs. However, to prevent the reel from rolling freely downstairs as well as cause damage, the workers were asked to tie 10-feet of rope to the reel and wrap it around the metal bar that was placed horizontally across a jamb on the door the same level as the reel. The plaintiff then held the loose end of the rope while the other workers pushed the reel downstairs.

As the reel went down, it pulled the plaintiff and the other workers into the metal bar, and as a result injured the worker’s hand. The Court of Appeal agreed with the trial court, that the movement of the reel was caused by a gravity risk and the failure to provide adequate device for safety was the main cause of the injury. In addition, the reel had to be moved from a high to a low elevator and the danger that was supposed to be guarded against came about from the force of the reel. The plaintiffs’ injury was as a result of a direct consequence of the reel going downstairs as if he was positioned in the reel’s path (Victor Vs New York Exchange, Case no 197).

As a result, he suffered from an injury that was elevation related while acting as a counterweight pulley to descend an 800 pound reel down stairs. He is said to have been dragged into the make shift pulley when the reel rapidly descended downstairs. The question was whether the plaintiff injury was as a result of a direct consequence of failure to have adequate protection against such a risk that arose from physically differential elevation. 240(1), of labor law claims that a liability strict statute was designed to prevent accidents where protection devices of the above enumerated injury of the statute proved to be insufficient to shield the plaintiff from any injury that occurred from the force of gravity to the reel.

Nevertheless, since the plaintiff was injured while trying to descend following the reels path, he is entitled to recover under section 240(1), and should not be denied any legal course. The differential elevation was not seen as de minimis, because the weight of the reel and the amount of force it had was enough to generate the course of a short descent, as well as cause harm to the worker (Victor Vs New York Exchange, Case no 197).The trial courts showed that the worker was indeed injured, in addition to suffering from permanent and serious injuries on both his hands while trying to descend the reel downstairs, as well as installing defendant power system in New York Stock Exchange premises.

Therefore, the manner as which the injuries were sustained were undisputed. The loose end that the plaintiff and other workers held pulled them down because they were acting as counterweights, on support of the metal bar. The wrapping of the rope was ineffective in terms of regulating the plaintiff and the descent the reason why it drew them horizontally, injuring both his hands ( Victor Vs New York Exchange, Case no 197).The jury was instructed that the pursuant liability to the law of labor was not assigned unless the workers’ injuries had been attributed to gravity risks, and having found no such injuries and risks, returned the verdict to the defendant.

Therefore, the motion by the plaintiff was set aside and the verdict ensued. However, in granting and directing the judgment upon the labor law 240, the court found that as a matter of law, the reel movement down stairs proved a gravity risk and adequate safety devices were not used in order to manage such a risk. Therefore, failure to use a safety device was the main factor that caused the plaintiff’s injury ( Victor Vs New York Exchange, Case no 197).It is obvious that no work place risk measure were put into place while descending the reel downstairs.

No statute was placed properly in order to give the plaintiff protection as a person who is employed in the building. It is often agreed that the purpose of any strict liability is to protect the people who work in construction areas from work place risks. Therefore, the court agreed that the plaintiff’s accident was a result of such risks, since the reel had to be moved from high to low elevator and the danger could be avoided if the heavy object was sufficiently checked. Therefore, the court ruled that the plaintiff harm was a result of the direct consequence of the gravity of the reel, Victor Vs New York Exchange, Case no 197.

ReferenceVICTOR J. RUNNER, Respondent, v NEW YORK STOCK EXCHANGE, case no 197 COURT OF APPEALS OF NEW YORK, Victor Vs New York Exchange, Case no 197

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Workplace Risk Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1582683-workplace-risk
(Workplace Risk Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1582683-workplace-risk.
“Workplace Risk Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1582683-workplace-risk.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Workplace Risk

Occupational health and safety

The fact that following OSH stipulations entails the installation of Workplace Risk prevention and the enhancement of proper health and safety management means that cases dealing with serious harm and injuries on employees are assuaged.... hellip; The effects of occupational health and safety in the workplace and environment are very profound, given that the goals of OSH include the fostering of a healthy and safe environment, protecting co-workers, customers, family members and even employers....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Work Related Stress and Safety

However, despite the fact that a lot of progress have been in ensuring workplace safety, statistics show that there are still a relatively large number of deaths related to Workplace Risk.... It is also their duty to ensure give the employees instructions on how safety procedures to avoid improper behavior that puts the worker at the risk of sustaining injuries or putting their health at risk.... They are also obligated to refrain from conducts such as operating machines when using drugs or drunk as this puts them at a greater risk if getting injured....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Security Planning of a City

1.... It is the aim of the Center for the Study of High Consequence Event Preparedness and Response to prepare the country to face high consequence issues.... Security assessment has to encourage the development of sophisticated and creative technologies.... This Center has to collaborate with the Department of Homeland Security Centers of Excellence....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Importance of Focusing on Health at Work - Avionics Solution

Having the need to deal with hard work responsibilities along with the duties that involve carrying or transporting heavy loads to and from a construction site, naturally brings in much risk to the laborers who are working on site that makes construction work such a huge concern for those who provide health insurances.... Certainly, Avionics Solution wants to make sure of its competitive status in the manufacturing industry by providing its employees a workplace that stimulates employee interaction and economic growth....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Personal Development Plan as a First Line Manager

Such challenges become extremely important and influential for middle level managers, especially first… In essence, first line managers must intensively and extensively apply both their personal skills and technical knowledge in effectively managing workplace teams.... Admittedly, management of practical organizations is characterized by multiple challenges like resource limitations, team diversity, personnel safety, and time limitations....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Role of Personality Within the Workplace

This essay "The Role of Personality Within the workplace" discusses personality in the workplace, personality characteristics and whether employers should use personality testing to select their employees.... Personality has a hold over the fabric of a workplace in entirety.... nbsp;… The workplace is a very difficult place as there are personality clashes happening for good and bad reasons.... The employers are studying their employees' personalities so that the workplace environments are made better and grey areas are taken care of....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Critical Analysis of a Risk Management System

"Critical Analysis of a risk Management System" paper conducts an analysis on the nature of a blasting risk management system as featured in the mining industry and thereafter gives recommendations or strategies that can be applied in bettering its effectiveness.... hellip; The analysis further elaborated the application of the MIRM model, and how its application works by decreasing the risk levels.... From the analysis, it can be concluded that while several risk management systems exist, their effectiveness differs and that some factors need to be changed or modified in achieving effectiveness....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

The Concept of Password Management

The paper focuses on the concept of password management and how to solve the issues of having so many passwords and having to change them for the different applications at the workplace.... Password management at the workplace is a constant struggle for the modern employee or worker.... An employee at the workplace today possesses different passwords for different applications.... Additionally, due to the vast usage of passwords for online authentication services at the workplace, there is an increasing threat about the vulnerability of these passwords, which pose a security threat to the employee/worker, and the organization....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us