StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Dispute Settlement (CIvil Suit) GP - Unit 2 - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Conflict of law is a set of rules that is used internationally to determine the legal system or jurisdiction that will be used to resolve contractual disputes. From the above case, it is evident that each of the four different parties will place a different argument as to the…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
Dispute Settlement (CIvil Suit) GP - Unit 2
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Dispute Settlement (CIvil Suit) GP - Unit 2"

Conflict of Law Conflict of law is a set of rules that is used internationally to determine the legal system or jurisdiction that will be used to resolve contractual disputes. From the above case, it is evident that each of the four different parties will place a different argument as to the rule of conflict of jurisdiction that would be used to resolve the civil suit. The lawyers for State X will argue that the closest and most real connection rule should be used to decide where the suit should be heard (Burton, 2006).

In this case, the lawyers will argue that ABC Company is incorporate in State X, and the factory being used in State Z belongs to State X, therefore the company has the most real connection to the contract (Hillman, 2009). This implies that the state has the most jurisdictions over the case being heard. The closest and most real connection rule is used by courts to reasonably determine the party that has the biggest connection to the case being disputed. State X could also state that it is the one being sued, so it has a bigger confection that the other parties to the case.

Conversely, the lawyers representing State Y would argue that proper law should be used to determine which country should hear the dispute. Commonly, proper law is the basic rule used to resolve most jurisdiction arguments, and it involves the terms used in the contractual argument (Frey and Frey, 2001). The parties in this case already agreed that all disputes regarding the agreement would be heard in State Y, which means that proper law gives State Y jurisdiction over the case. The Doctrine of Proper law is used to determine the intentions of the parties to a contract as to which jurisdiction should govern the dispute being resolved.

This means that a court will look at the wording of the contract to determine what the parties intended the lawsuit to be decided. State Z would also argue for the closest and most real connection to the case when the dispute a as to where the jurisdiction of the case is argued. From the case facts, it is noted that the factory was to be built in State Z and burnt down in the said State. The Lawyers for the state would argue that since the contract involves building in State Z, and the events occurred in this state, there is the realest connection to the case, so the jurisdiction should be there’s.

Finally, State Q would also argue that the closest and most implied connection is that the nationalities of the people killed in the tragedy came from its jurisdiction; therefore the dispute should be decided in their country. The decision, therefore, falls to the judge in the case to decide where there was any implied or express selection in the contract wording as to which state would hold the dispute hearing (Tetley,2009), which in this case, is State Y. State Y has both the power of proper law and express selection from the contract between the parties to the building of the factory.

References Burton, S. (2006). Principles of Contract Law. Bolton: West/Thomson Learning Publishers. Frey, M., and Frey, P. (2001). Essentials of Contract Law. Bolton: West/Thomson Learning Publishers. Hillman, R. (2009). Principles of Contract Law. New York: West Publishers. Tetley, W. (2009). Mixed jurisdictions: Common law vs. civil law. Unif. L. Rev. 3

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Dispute Settlement (CIvil Suit) GP - Unit 2 Research Paper”, n.d.)
Dispute Settlement (CIvil Suit) GP - Unit 2 Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1598499-dispute-settlement-civil-suit-gp-unit-2
(Dispute Settlement (CIvil Suit) GP - Unit 2 Research Paper)
Dispute Settlement (CIvil Suit) GP - Unit 2 Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/law/1598499-dispute-settlement-civil-suit-gp-unit-2.
“Dispute Settlement (CIvil Suit) GP - Unit 2 Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1598499-dispute-settlement-civil-suit-gp-unit-2.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Dispute Settlement (CIvil Suit) GP - Unit 2

Dispute Settlement between Iran and the US

Peaceful settlement of international disputes is considered the main objective in maintaining peace and security as legislated in significant principles of Article 2(3) of the United Nations Charter.... hellip; Article 33(1) of the United Nations Charter also discusses direct and peaceful settlement of international disputes where states are to settle their disputes by means of negotiation, inquiry, mediation, conciliation, arbitration, judicial settlement, regional agencies or arrangements, and other peaceful settlements decided on by them....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

WTO: Dispute Settlement Understanding

This research essay “WTO: dispute settlement Understanding” analyses the issues faced by DSU in making compulsory the compliance by member nations and how it find solutions to issues raised before it.... A consensus is required to stop the proceedings from advancing any stage of the formal dispute settlement procedures.... TO DSU offers the privilege to the members who are having a sizeable interest in a dispute to demand their grievances to be heard by a panel....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

International Law Dispute Settlement (DB-2)

According to International Law dispute settlement (DB-2) Despite the fact that MBI (a multi-national corporation), has produced military tanks in its numerous branches around the universe, it cannot sue Country D in Country C.... According to Scahill (2011), immunity against suit means that the party involved is not liable and it is impossible to use it, and it should not even be bothered to participate in the lawsuit....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Dispute Settlement DB-3

It enjoys a strong market position dispute settlement DB-3 dispute settlement DB-3 This essay will discuss about General Motors Company (GM) and howit has been affected by recent shifts in international policies and regulations in relation to foreign investment....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Ethnic Conflicts in ASEAN Member States

A POLICY BRIEF OF THE WAYS IN WHICH ASEAN CAN ENHANCE ITS COOPERATION WITH A VIEW TO AVOIDING OR MEDIATING ETHNIC TENSIONS IN IT'S MEMBER STATES IN THE FUTURE.... THIS IS WITH REGARD TO THE RECENT ETHNIC VIOLENCE IN MYANMAR This paper addresses the issue of ethnic conflicts in… The issue of major concern is the prevailing ethnic clashes in Burma....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Means of Dispute Settlement

The concerned parties each Means of dispute settlement Introduction Alternative dispute resolution also termed as ADR refers to the methods used to solve disputes and disagreements outside court.... However, after the clients and their lawyers have seen the jury reaction, they can compromise their decision and reach for a settlement (Twomey and Jennings 27).... Considering the bureaucratic, cumbersome and time consuming operations of the courts, it is highly advised for people with urgent cases to use ADR for… Alternative dispute resolutions provide a fast and cost efficient method of solving disagreements (Twomey and Jennings 25). Arbitration is the use of outside arbitrator(s) chosen by the concerned parties to solve the cases....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Dispute Settlement between States: The Iran-U.S. Claims Tribunal Case and the La Grand Case

The author states the importance of dispute settlement between states is exemplified by both the Iran-US Claims Tribunal Case and the LaGrand Case.... Article 33(1) of the United Nations Charter also discusses direct and peaceful settlement of international disputes where states are to settle their disputes by means of negotiation, inquiry, mediation, conciliation, arbitration, judicial settlement, regional agencies or arrangements, and other peaceful settlements decided on by them....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

WTO as a Dispute Settlement Body

The author of the paper "WTO as a dispute settlement Body" states that the development of trade worldwide led to the need for the establishment of a mechanism, which would resolve the disputes appear in the particular sector.... The World Trade Organization dispute settlement system became such a mechanism.... he WTO dispute settlement system (alternatively mentioned from now on as the 'System') has a rather short history; its operation started about 15 years before and shortly it has become one of the most important features in the resolution of disputes related to the international trade....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us