StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Auditing Negligence in Australia - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Auditing Negligence in Australia" discusses auditors in Australia and around the world that face challenges and criticism because of corporate collapses, as they are associated with professional negligence allegations and breach of statutory duties…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
Auditing Negligence in Australia
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Auditing Negligence in Australia"

Auditing Negligence in Australia AUDITING NEGLIGENCE IN AUSTRALIA Question Auditors in Australia and around the world face challenges and criticism because of corporate collapses, as they are associated to professional negligence allegations and breach of the statutory duties1. These allegations demonstrate the role of the current court system in protecting the auditors, creditors, and shareholders. However, the court has been on the forefront in protecting the rights of the auditor based on a number of policy considerations. The ultimate goals of the policy reforms have been to reduce the level and extent of third party liability towards auditors, and prevent the possible scenario where auditors cease to provide their auditing services. The two policy reforms considered in Australia include the proportionate liability and statutory capping schemes2. The various professional bodies governing auditing in Australia determine application of statutory capping. Nonetheless, statutory capping has various negative policy implications. One, it is a disadvantage to third parties who may be innocent victims of the auditors negligence. Two, it may induce the auditors to charge lower fees as they would expect to pay damages in case of a legal suit. Third, it allows for government interference in the auditing profession, which would hinder the independence of auditors. Question # 2 Australian security and investment commission vs. Rich (2009) One. Tel Communication company reported losses of $290 million as a result, its share price collapsed and the directors were sued for negligence. ASIC sued Jodee Rich and Mark Silberman for failing to meet their duty of care causing the collapse of the company in May 2009. ASIC claimed that by failing to communicate true financial performance and financial position of the company, these directors did not exercise due care and diligence, which resulted to the cancellation of the proposed rights issue in 20013. The directors were found not guilty of negligence on accounts that the summary presented by ASIC about Mr. Rich’s evidence was considered as false. The judge also implemented the business judgment rule under the Corporations Act 2001, Section 180(2). Directors whose conduct breached section 180(1) were provided defense in the business judgment rule4. HIH Insurance vs. Rodney Adler HIH Insurance was among the biggest insurance companies in Australia. However, in March 2001, the company lost a value of about $5.3 billion and, in turn, became insolvent. Some management member was sued for fraud after the Prime minister, John Howard, created the Royal Commission to investigate the collapse of the company. Rodney, the main defendant, had three unsecured loan transactions with no proper documentation to support the flow of the funds in his care 5. Rodney Adler was found guilty on the following accounts and was sentenced to four and half years in jail. He had; Purposely became dishonest in dealing with the affairs of company, Failed to fulfill his responsibilities truthfully as the director of the company and also failed to protect the interests of the company, Used misleading and false statements to obtain money for himself. It was held that Rodney failed to protect the interests of the company and that he refused to follow the right channel in relation to investment. His main objective was to safeguard the company’s share price on the simple basis that he was also a shareholder6. Question # 3 Duty of care The duty of care, in essence, necessitates the plaintiff to establish a legal relationship to the defendant in the form of a duty or an obligation. In the Donoghue v Stevenson case, the ruling of the court was that a legal duty to care existed between the two parties, even though, there was no direct correlation between the Defendant and the Plaintiff7. In this judgment, the court considered proximity relationship between Defendant and the Plaintiff and the reasonable foreseeability of harm altogether. This was unlike in current negligence auditing where they are viewed, as separate, and each are important in making a ruling regarding negligence. Standard of care The standard of care in the Donoghue v Stevenson case was the reasonable man. Based on this principle the conduct of the defendant was assessed with regards to the various standards of a reasonable man8. Conversely, the court is not capable of determining the various standards of a reasonable man. The standard of care in the current auditing laws is the employment of reasonable skill and care in handling a company’s financial reports. In order for the claim of negligence to stand under the current law, the plaintiff has to prove that the auditor failed to meet the standard of duty to care by acting carelessly. Question # 4 I do not agree with the current laws and regulations regarding auditor’s negligence in Australia. I believe that the current range of laws including contractual law, common law and statutory law, all contribute a significant role in determining the liability of the auditors in light of their increasing responsibilities and obligations9. The current laws and policy framework are also very important in setting the various standards and guidelines for governing; the actions and obligations of auditors and certified accountants in performing their statutory duties. The many number of laws and statutory regulations require auditors to extend a greater level of liability to third parties. This ultimately has the effect of demeaning the accounting and auditing profession. There is a need for the court and the judicial system to institute a number of policy framework and reforms, which would help in limiting the third party liabilities imposed on auditors10. Appropriate reforms would go a long way in protecting both accountants and auditors in performing their statutory and legal duties. It would also prevent unscrupulous and fraudulent third parties from instituting legal proceedings against the auditors. In addition to this, appropriate policy reforms would also protect the interest third parties who actually, suffer from financial loss, which has occurred as a result of negligence and enable them to seek appropriate compensation. References Dobson, AP. Reddy, KJ. & Jo, R., 2003. Commercial Law. UK: Psychology press. Hocking, BA. & Smith, A. 2003. Liability for negligent words. London: Federation press. Nguyen, V. & Pelma, R. 2008. An Analysis of the Auditors Liability to Third Parties in Australia. Common Law World Review. 37: p. 9-44 Plessis, JJ. Du, PJJ. Marko, B. & Anil, H., 2011. Principles of Contemporary Corporate Governance. London: Cambridge University. Sherer, M. & Turley, S. 2006. Current Issues in Auditing. London: Sage Tomasic, R., Bottomley, S. & Queen, R. 2002. Corporation Laws in Australia. London: Federation press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Business law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 11”, n.d.)
Business law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 11. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1626251-business-law
(Business Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 11)
Business Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 11. https://studentshare.org/law/1626251-business-law.
“Business Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 11”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1626251-business-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Auditing Negligence in Australia

The Talkback Radio Genre in Australia

Explain its controversy and issues in relation to the understandings and origins of the talkback radio genre in australia.... Such shameless deed of crossing the line that resulted to negligence of duty and of respect for responsible broadcasting deserves regulatory sanctions having violated the fourth section of the Broadcasting Services Act of 1992, stating “to encourage providers of commercial and community broadcasting to be responsive to the need for a fair and accurate coverage of matters of public interest and for appropriate coverage of matters of local significance....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Issues on Law of Negligence

negligence Tort of negligence occur where the following elements exist and can be proven duty of care and the breach of thereof, causation, and the damage itself (Mann et al, 2009).... These elements have to be proven for a negligence case to be successful; however, the most essential element is duty of care.... Furthermore, the other issue found in this case is to ascertain whether it was Metro Plc negligence, which led her to lose her earnings....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Corporate Governance Failure at Satyam Computer Services

The Satyam case scandal was a result of sheer negligence by the management towards it fiduciary duties, accounting procedure and lack of corporate social responsibility.... Apart from negligence to responsibility and duties towards the company ethical policies and procedures the company management planned to acquire 51 percent stake in Maytas infrastructure, which was one of the leading construction and infrastructure development companies (Caraballo, Cheerla and Jafari, 2010)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Auditing failures and quantitative measurement of materiality judgement

In almost all cases of the audit fraud, the auditors are investigated for supporting fraud in lieu of having direct and indirect financial interest in the organization or negligence.... For example, Ernst & Young in USA has recent been charged to pay around USD two million for violating PCAAOB rules of auditing in the audit of its client Medicis Pharmaceutical Corporation (Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, 2012)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LAW

rofessional liability in medical malpractice is based on the rule of negligence within in australia, the Medical Insurance law is designed mainly to deter medical negligence as well as to compensate patients who are injured by negligent doctors and other health-care professionals.... In the current scenario medical negligence is causing an unpredictable situation for Insurance companies for insurance of professional person within australia.... (Liebman, 2004, 24) This suggests that many injured patients do not sue for compensation while others readily attribute poor clinical outcomes to negligence....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Negligence of Auditors

The paper "Negligence of Auditors " states that generally speaking, the auditing reports provide fundamental evidence that as explained in the case of Ansett in australia helped the government protect the millions of investors from incurring huge losses.... arious companies have collapsed through scandalous ways in australia among other markets throughout the world.... nsett Australia, once a major airline company in australia collapsed in 2002 following a series of unwarranted market forces....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Changes in Audit Relationship with Clients and Third Parties

The focus is on the corporate auditing profession in australia, along with changes and trends in other areas like the US and the UK… Sole proprietorships, partnerships and joint stock companies are some of the common channels through which business is conducted today.... The focus will be on the corporate auditing profession in australia, along with changes and trends in other areas like the United States and the United Kingdom.... This paper looks at the evolution of the auditing profession over the past decade or so with regard to the relationship between auditors and third parties....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Human Factors in Aviation

10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us