StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Toulmin Analysis - the Ups and Downs of Flatter Taxes - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Toulmin Analysis - the Ups and Downs of Flatter Taxes" discusses that the biggest challenge of the global economy is to maintain a strong tax base, while the capital becomes increasingly mobile. Under such mobility of tax bases, won’t it be difficult to fix the flat rates?…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Toulmin Analysis - the Ups and Downs of Flatter Taxes
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Toulmin Analysis - the Ups and Downs of Flatter Taxes"

The enforcement agencies tend to ignore such non-compliances. They also do not find it economical to trace, communicate and then enforce such minor offenses, because the amount of money spent on enforcement far exceeds the gains in the form of tax.
iii. The system is not transparent enough and gives room for temptations to evade tax. In cases when big business houses can devise ways and mean to evade tax, tends to have a cascading effect on the employees and other concerned stakeholders in the business, which results in further revenue losses to the government.
iv. Flat tax system has shown its worth in some the countries like Russia, and some other economies in transition like the Slovak republic, while some OECD nations like Italy, Greece, and Mexico and actively pursuing the matter

Warrant: The flat tax system is likely to result in
i. Increasing compliance from the individuals. The easier tax formalities will help in encouraging more people to go with the system.
ii. More tax collections for the state. This effectively means the state would be able to mop up more tax without additional efforts.
iii. Tax filing becomes simple as the cumbersome structure of exemptions and deductions is gone
iv. More funds available for the activities like infrastructure development, and social welfare, one of the key components of nation-building.

Backing:
The country needs more investments in services and infrastructure because;
i. The population of aged people is rising, which calls for adequate arrangements for their healthcare and other social needs. The corporate sector has already taken note of the needs of senior citizens and accordingly started tuning their products and services accordingly. It is therefore the duty of the government as well to supplement such efforts while making efforts for strengthening the health care facilities etc.
ii. Education needs of the children are to be met with funds collected from this account. Higher education is becoming very costly nowadays and increasing competition in the job market/ outsourcing of jobs calls for a well-prepared youth.
iii. Taxes need to be made competitive for inviting more investments even into the sectors, which are not considered lucrative enough from the profitability point of view.

Grounds:
i. Many OECD countries have recognized the need to reform their income tax system over the last two decades.
ii. Flat tax system's simplicity will encourage people to comply with the tax rules. This forms the key to going for such a system.
iii. Russia was the first major country to adopt a flat tax rate in January 2001, when it declared a flat rate of 13%. Over the next year, personal revenue jumped by 26% in real terms, and as a percentage of Russia's GDP, incomes increased by a fifth. It is worth considering that if a country has been facing a series of troublesome situations for quite a while, why other developed and well-placed countries can’t do it?

Qualifier:
The real dilemma is how to fix the tax slabs. While a lower tax rate might create incentives to work, save and invest, become entrepreneurs, and take risks. It might as well throw away the real benefits of such a system. On the other hand, a high tax slab proves different in cases where the tax bases keep shifting particularly when globalization and the opening up of economies is the key trend.

Conditions for Rebuttal:
 Questions might be raised about fixing the tax slabs and corresponding rates. It is indeed a very challenging task for the income tax office to devise suitable slabs for tax deductions so that it reflects the social composition and earning potentials truthfully. But the slabs can in this case be rationalized in due course, as it is an evolutionary process, and once the tax office receives the feedback it can incorporate more changes into it.
 Arguments are advanced that in such a system, high-income earners might gain at the expense of middle-income earners who will have to pay a higher tax rate as they are bracketed in that particular slab.

 Russia and Slovak Republic in principle have a system of a flat tax, but they continue to levy social security contributions separately. This ‘contribution’ is meant to take care of the gains from shifting between capital and labor income.
 The flat rate of tax resulted in slightly higher tax rates for the lower-class taxpayers while the system benefitted the rich people. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Tax System Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Tax System Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525510-tax-system
(Tax System Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Tax System Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525510-tax-system.
“Tax System Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525510-tax-system.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Toulmin Analysis - the Ups and Downs of Flatter Taxes

Main Points in Ethics in Toulmin and Jonsen

This review "Main Points in Ethics in Toulmin and Jonsen" discusses the methods of phenomenological analysis in ethical rationality.... Moral reasoning should thus be studied in the context of discourse analysis.... Most Illuminating toulmin and Jenson assert that moral decisions are made on the basis of deliberation of moral reasons which are also obtained from societal observances rather than from the consequences of an act....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review

Toulmin Argumentation

PART ONE: Should the military be allowed to recruit at high schools?... The issue regarding national security in the United States of America has been a serious one since the terrorist attacks last 2001.... Since then, the country has implemented more strict regulations in order to promote national security and maintain it at the best level possible....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

An Analysis of Christianity Through the Lens of Toulmins Method of Argumentation

This analysis will utilize Toulmin's model of claim, ground, warrant, rebuttal, and qualifier to help explain the Christian's responsibility to the environment and how it should be formulated.... As will be expanded upon in greater depth within this analysis, this fundamental concept of stewardship with regards to the way the Christian should interact with the material world traces its understanding not only to the life and example of Christ or the writings of Paul but back to the very beginnings of humanity with the creation and instruction given to Adam and Eve (Bookless 39)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Toulmin Model Argument about the Environment

The paper "toulmin Model Argument about the Environment" states that Christians and everybody else should still not destroy God's creation!... There are some scholars according to toulmin who believe that God created us so that we can rule his creation, therefore human beings should use his creations for livelihood (Mead, 2008)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Ethics at the Top Two Auction Houses

As seller of the consignor's items, the auction house manages all the account procedures: bills the buyer, remits the consignor the money after the purchase of the merchandise, minus the commission, taxes and other expenses.... At a glance, auctions of fine arts and other high-valued merchandize allow ordinary people to glimpse at the mystifying, ostentatious world of the rich....
23 Pages (5750 words) Essay

Toulmin Analysis

In this paper, a toulmin analysis is carried out, of the online advertisement for Smile Brite teeth whitener in the Top, Teeth Whitening Kits website.... Interpreting the results using the toulmin analysis above, indicates that the overall effectiveness of the argument appears to be strong, with structured support.... The toulmin analysis is a useful tool for researchers and writers, since the various parts of an argument: the claim, data/ support and warrants, and the qualifiers, rebuttals, and backing for the warrants can be analyzed and compared separately....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

The Toulmin Schema

The paper "The toulmin Schema" discusses that pilots and other crewmembers should be given better treatment and enough rest periods to ensure their attentiveness during flights and the safety of passengers, as well as to feel motivated and satisfied with their jobs.... ... ... ... Because resting will allow flight members that operate for long distances to have a normal pattern of sleep and wake hours, and thus not suffer from exhaustion....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Toulmin Analysis

The support is provided by the assertion that the involvement of Bowman with malfunctioning machine disconnects the memory circuit that is responsible for controlling artificial brain.... The support for the claim.... ... ... Additionally, the claim is emphasized by the assertion that the author's concentration starts to drift after reading two to three pages (Carr 1). ...
3 Pages (750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us