StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

18 kids were right all along - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Richard Melcher’s article entitled “18 Kids Were Right All Along” published in Business Week in 1999 discusses a problem most teenagers are already know well. The problem is that much of high school work is redundant. According to the author, teenagers should be released…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
18 kids were right all along
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "18 kids were right all along"

The High School Debate Richard Melcher’s article en d “18 Kids Were Right All Along” published in Business Week in 1999 discusses a problem most teenagers are already know well. The problem is that much of high school work is redundant. According to the author, teenagers should be released from formal school by the time they are 15 or 16 because what they experience following their sophomore year is generally simply repetitions of what they’ve learned through the first two years of high school.

This seems to be the main thrust of his argument, citing teenagers fed up with the boring nature of their second two high school years and little else in support of his argument. While he has a point that high school can be boring and repetitive in the final two years, Melcher fails to adequately take into account the possibilities available to students in high school to keep them interested, the problem of maturity level of students and misses perhaps the strongest argument in favor of his position, the school system established in England.

Students who have planned their education well are capable of graduating from high school as many as two years earlier than normal now thanks to specialized advanced level classes and limited electives. However, many of these students opt to remain in school longer as a means of further exploring other interests, beginning the difficult process of selecting an appropriate career by discovering interests and ruling out others. Other programs, such as dual credit courses and vocational courses, serve to continue high school students’ interest even further.

For those who are bored with school, just a little application enables them to leave earlier as Melcher suggests. Teenagers aged 15 or 16 are notoriously confident of their own maturity level and abilities to their own delusion. In addition, they are provided with a driver’s license and often a vehicle at this age, giving them unprecedented freedom and range. Should they be turned loose on the streets at this point, without even a class to attend, it is difficult to say what they might do.

Some very few would undoubtedly continue their education with a view toward their future, but too many, without further guidance or other guidelines put in place, would simply go wild. This is, indeed, a problem among the poorer segments of the urban population in England and elsewhere where school is optional after age 16. Finally, Melcher neglects to mention the strongest argument in favor of his position. England, for example, has a school system where attendance after age 16 is optional rather than mandatory.

Because of this, there are several colleges, universities and trade schools designed to accept younger students providing them with a place to go should they be bored with traditional classes and ready to move forward. By neglecting to even mention this system, Melcher demonstrates that his research into the subject was severely limited at best and weakens his argument in the process. While it is difficult to disagree with the idea of providing teenagers with greater flexibility and options in their lives, particularly as it relates to their educational and future training, it is concluded that a stronger argument must be brought forward before such ideas can be reasonably considered.

Examinations into how other countries have designed their school systems and the effects of these, development of after school services for younger people and full exploration of just what is available in the American schools would be necessary before this argument can be considered convincing. Works CitedMelcher, Richard A. “18 Kids Were Right All Along: High School is Obsolete.” Business Week. 1999. McGrawHill. January 29, 2008

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“18 kids were right all along Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
18 kids were right all along Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1544275-18-kids-were-right-all-along
(18 Kids Were Right All Along Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
18 Kids Were Right All Along Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1544275-18-kids-were-right-all-along.
“18 Kids Were Right All Along Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1544275-18-kids-were-right-all-along.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF 18 kids were right all along

Children Literature and Its Significance

Today children have fewer scopes to expand their capacity to imagine since the abundance of electronic media brings their imagination right in front of their eyes through various cartoon and comic characters.... The importance of Children's Literature Children's literature is a dominant factor in the lives of kids as it has got the capability to encourage the power of imagination within them.... kids often take pleasure in reading and listening to their much loved fantasy tales over and over again....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Issues on Teenage Drivers

Jay Giedd, along with a team of professional researchers, analyzed 4000 brain scans from 2000 volunteers to record how brains develop as children grow up and mature.... (Davis, 2005) However, many people also believe that the sweeping statement blaming all young drivers should not be made as there are only a portion of the total teenage drivers that cause the major chunk of accidents (Davis, 2005).... Backed up by several statistical evidences, facts, and medical researches, most of the people are of the view that children should be at least 18 years old to get a driving license....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Meritocracy, Inequality, and Mobility

Initially, meritocracy was unheard of since people used to be given jobs on basis of their parents achievements or the persons looking… In the UK, meritocracy has been practiced at different levels, however, rules and regulations which have been enacted make it easy for all to be included in the education system as well as the equal opportunities for education making it Social mobility has become an issue even in politics since each and every policy now deals with whether it will allow people to change or rise from the current situation (Marshall, G....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Enhancing Interpersonal Communication in a Family

The kids are either busy working or too young to take sufficient care of their grandfather.... This paper under the headline "Enhancing Interpersonal Communication in a Family" focuses on the fact that Bruce and Susan Bright reside at a moderately urban part of Queensland City.... Bruce is 44 and Susan is 41 and they are married for 21 years by now....
15 Pages (3750 words) Case Study

Legislation Frameworks, Codes of Practice and Policies of Positive Behaviour

A few of the challenging behaviours and its associated legislation frameworks and policies are explained hereunder:Repetitive behaviour among the children can be dealt in with the kind and understanding behaviour of the carers and also be going through constant verbal and nonverbal communication along with social interaction.... Doing these activities will also aid in promoting positive behaviour among the children along with the young people.... These Acts state that all individuals have the full right to take their own decision regarding the treatment and care and it is also a crime to discriminate a mentally challenged individual....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment

Philadelphia Mandatory Curfew

This research stresses that the city of Philadelphia is in duress from the city not enforcing its own curfew hours.... Many minors are running the streets of Philadelphia at night.... Philadelphia has a curfew ordinance in place but they are not following up on this ordinance and enforcing it.... hellip; From this research paper, it is clear that there are many pros and cons on the effectiveness of the implementation of the curfew ordinance....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Some Kids are Likely to be Bullied than Others

Family background can engineer bullying for instance methods of bringing up a kid in a single parent family where the female parent is the sole breadwinner and she sells her body in a disrespectful manner by doing it openly with different men, this can brandies her kids all shots of bullying names for example “one kid with many Dads” as Sandera stated in his book.... The researcher states that some kids are more likely to be bullied than others in the context of their gender, for instance, you'll find a male kid pokes and mocks a female kid now and again in the pretext that he enjoys pocking and mocking her not knowing he is causing emotional torture to her female target....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

The Issue of Wellbeing

If I was to choose a husband again I can use any so long as we get along together happily.... She was a childhood friendMy family members were happy with the perception that my husband was a UN worker.... This case study "The Issue of Wellbeing" presents the major challenge that was the economic challenge because both of us had no enough money that will have facilitated our meetings frequently....
13 Pages (3250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us