StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Plato and Rousseau’s Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown" explains that for Plato, an excessive increase in something would cause reactions directed in the opposite direction.Case in point, excess liberty, brought about by democracy, is highly likely to lead to excess slavery. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.5% of users find it useful
Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown"

Plato and Rousseau’s Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown al Affiliation) Plato and Rousseau’s Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown Plato, just like some of the great minds of his time, criticized democracy as part of the constitution, especially after the death of Socrates under democratic law. In his book the republic, he reviewed the four major types of government constitutions, which he deemed unstable and bound to degenerate with passing time (Rosen, 2008). Important, in this case, is Plato’s view of democracy, which is brought about by the constitution.

For Plato, by the constitution allowing for democracy, it fosters a life or no law and order. In this case, democracy leads to a continuous increase in the desire for liberty among the citizens, which in turn leads to disorder as people increasingly chafe without patience at any form of authority. With time, the people stop caring for both the written and unwritten laws as they quest to have no one above them. For Plato, an excessive increase in something would cause reactions directed in the opposite direction (Stein, 2011).

Case in point, excess liberty, brought about by democracy, whether among individuals or in states, is highly likely to lead to excess slavery. Plato thus emphasized that democracy, just like oligarchy, draws a rift between the rich and the poor (Rosen, 2008). With the perceiving the rich as plotting against them, they seek protection through rallying their support behind a champion. With the increasing support of the mob, such a champion is likely to turn into a tyrant. For Plato, the law ought to be a defining factor for all the actions of individuals within a certain jurisdiction and that people have to lose their freedom for the sake of gaining peace and harmony.

To prevent degeneration of the constitution, Plato postulates that the law has to become the master of the government and the government to be its slave, so that every person is answerable to the law (Stein, 2011). In addition, Plato suggests that for a constitution to be effective then the government should be run by the best (aristocratic), so that the leaders are highly wise and that they receive proper training concerning how a state should be run. Contrary to Plato’s view, Rousseau believes that constitutions that fail to recognize the individual moral responsibility of the citizens is bound to degenerate with time.

As such, for any constitutional coercions to be justified, they must be based on certain general agreements among the citizens (Plamenatz, Philp, & Pelczynski, 2012). Rousseau observed that constitutional governments were driven by an assumption that citizens within a given state, regardless of their divisions in terms of personal opinions, remain firmly in agreement concerning the desire to share the same political existence. With such an agreement, the citizens become willing to sacrifice their views for the interest of the shared action.

As such, Rousseau maintained that a distinct skill of the constitution is to minimize the collective action’s demand to the area of potential or actual agreement (Stein, 2011). Thus, most constitutions fail in cases where limiting such demands proves to be impossible, as minority groups under such constitutions increasingly feel that the community values are of less importance to them as compared to the particular interests that they compromise on the community’s behalf. Such an occurrence leads to the loss of constitutional legitimacy, upon which coercion can be based.

Rousseau’s argument is based on his view of the “general will”, where he observes that the society’s citizens should be trusted with the ability to handle their individual responsibilities towards the good of the greater society (Stein, 2011). His solution to this problem is relaxation of the constitutional government’s demands such that to allow for winning back of the minority who have been disaffected. On the other hand, the government may consider recognizing the rights of such minority and allow them to establish themselves independently as a political society.

References Plamenatz, J., Philp, M., & Pelczynski, Z. (2012). Machiavelli, Hobbes, and Rousseau. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Rosen, S. (2008). Platos Republic: A Study. New Haven: Yale University Press. Stein, J. B. (2011). Commentary on the Constitution from Plato to Rousseau. Lanham Maryland: Lexington Books.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown Essay”, n.d.)
Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1700209-plato-and-rousseaus-commentary-on-constitutional-breakdown
(Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown Essay)
Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown Essay. https://studentshare.org/politics/1700209-plato-and-rousseaus-commentary-on-constitutional-breakdown.
“Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1700209-plato-and-rousseaus-commentary-on-constitutional-breakdown.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown

Conception of the General Will Safeguard Against Tyranny

Does Rousseau's conception of the General Will safeguard against tyranny or promote it?... The Genevan philosopher and writer Jean-Jacques Rousseau has conceptualized the theory of General will in the 18th Century.... It is the crux of the many contributions made by Rousseau in political philosophy....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Contrast the Buddhist ideal of the self with Rousseau's

According to Buddha,… This paper contrasts the Buddhist ideal of the self with Jacques Rousseau's. The five heaps or Skandhas which makes the individual include consciousness, form, Contrast between the Buddhist ideal of the self with rousseaus The nature of the self is considered as one of Buddha's hardest teachings, also central to Buddhism....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Henri Rousseau as a Master of Overlapping Shapes

This paper focuses on the processes of industrialization and high-speed technological development that have always shifted accents in art.... A great phenomenon of Henri Rousseau reflects the influence of humanity on nature during the technological advancement of the 19th century.... hellip; Henri Rousseau had many opponents around him and he wanted to find the best opportunity for the realization of his inner ideas and thoughts on canvas....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

The Origin and the Foundations of Inequality among Men

This is because, a man has Hobbes Leviathan and rousseaus Dis on the Origin and the Foundations of Inequality among Men Hobbes view man as anobject in motion, according to him, men are materialistic.... Therefore, the only thing that occupies most of their mind is how and where to acquire wealth (Hobbes 16)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Rousseau and the Social Contract Tradition

From the essay "Rousseau and the Social Contract Tradition" it is clear that Rousseau disapproves of the social contract tradition on the basis that it just promotes equality and liberty whereas it actually does the opposite of that.... He has made realistic and reasonable suggestions.... hellip; Rousseau is of the opinion that the independence of man should not be conditional as implied by the tradition of the social contract....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Rousseau's view on language

The philosopher goes further and develops rousseaus view on language Rousseau argues that that the need for communication was initiated by the fact that humans understood that there are similar beings as themselves.... A question which is analyzed in details by this famous philosopher also focuses on the mystery why humans started using their voice… Rousseau comes to the following conclusion: the main advantage of verbal interaction lies in that it is able to convey feelings and passions while gestures are hardly useful for that....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Origins of Inequality

He uses the standard Aristotelian thesis of marriage, that is, a union made for reproduction, sexual desire, and employment.... Moreover, he acknowledges that beyond those elements are mutual affection,… For Locke, marriage is not just utilitarian; there is a factor of love to it.... The same way a dad's power over his kids is not absolute, a man's power over his spouse is not absolute also....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Breakdown of Chile Democracy

From the paper "breakdown of Chile Democracy" it is clear that the NSC is made up of the President, the national Contralor, the President of the Supreme Court, the President of the Senate, the three commanders-in-chief of the armed forces and the director of the national police.... This essay focuses on the origins of the breakdown of democracy in Chile and the violent experience under the current regime.... he breakdown of Chile Democracy can be traced chiefly in the patterns of political mobilization prior to the election of Allende....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us