StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Difference between Mental Illness and Insanity - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Difference between Mental Illness and Insanity" discusses that alcohol usually alters an individual’s rational thinking making individuals not function in the normal way and make rational decisions. However, this may not be used as a defense under McNaughten's rule…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
The Difference between Mental Illness and Insanity
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Difference between Mental Illness and Insanity"

"McNaughton rule" in this case is based on the insanity presumption. As such, a defendant who pleads insanity at the time of committing the act is required to prove beyond reasonable doubt that he or she was suffering from a mental disorder so severe that he or she could not know the quality and nature of the act committed at the time of insanity (John, 2006). This implies proving that he or she was not in a position to establish that the act was either right or wrong. However, John notes that mental illness cannot act as a defense since an individual may be mentally ill but still know the nature of the act. This shows the reason why Clark’s case was dismissed.

This is because alcoholism is considered one of the causes of mental illness and not insanity. The presumption made is that an individual who murders someone is capable of knowing the type and quality of action committed and must therefore take responsibility for his actions (John, 2006). Therefore it does not fall under the definition of insanity on which McNaughten's rule is based. Under this rule, the murderer will be required to prove that he or she was insane and did not know what he or she was doing which is not easy.

Rational and guilty
This is a situation in which an individual committed an offense, knew what he or she was doing, and knew whether the act was right or wrong. The person is, therefore, considered rational and guilty of the offense committed.

Guilty but insane
This is a situation in which an individual accused might be found guilty of an offense, but because he or she was insane at the time of the commission of the act, the person would be taken for a medical check-up and treatment first after which the accused would proceed to prison. This is based on the fact that the accused has pleaded guilty to the alleged offense.

Not guilty because of insanity
This is a situation where the accused is judged not guilty due to the fact he or she did not know his or her actions and the consequences of the act. However, such people are usually taken to a mental organization until he or she becomes of sound mind or sometimes stay locked up for life.
If you were deciding this case, how would you rule? Briefly explain your decision
My ruling of the case would be that the murderer is rational and guilty. This I based on the fact that the person only suffered mental illness but not insanity. For this reason, he did it, knew what he was doing, and had knowledge that the murder was wrong.
Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Mind Over Matter Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1595334-mind-over-matter
(Mind Over Matter Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/psychology/1595334-mind-over-matter.
“Mind Over Matter Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1595334-mind-over-matter.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Difference between Mental Illness and Insanity

Study of Diego's Medical History

It also provides standard criteria and a common language in the mental disorder classification.... These involve major mental disorders, substance use disorders, as well as learning disorders.... The most relevant categorization of Diego's disorder in this axis would be the mental disorder.... That would be a mental disorder, of course.... Besides, screaming in an elevator that serves as a medical facility at the top of his voice, claiming to be on his father's search, speaks volumes of his mental incapacity....
42 Pages (10500 words) Research Paper

Post-structuralism, Critical Realism and Materialism in Relation to Mental Health Disorders

Post-structural theory suggest that sanity and insanity are not binary opposed.... Research indicates that social structuring can cause mental health disorders and illness.... Sociology of Health and illness, 23,2: 135–58.... Post-structuralism, Critical Realism and Materialism in Relation to mental Health Disorders Post-structuralism developed to counter structuralism.... Critical realism and post-structuralism is increasingly being viewed as one of the methods of addressing mental health disorders....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Assessment of Mental State for Insanity Plea

Legally, for the defendant to plead the insanity plea, they have to reveal that there was a connection between the mental illness and the criminal offence that was committed.... In insanity plea of not being responsible, states, more specifically order that due to extenuating circumstances of mental illness, the defendant should not be held ethically chargeable for the offense (Simon & Shuman, 2002).... The reason behind this statement is that, the individual's mental illness affects his ability to be in a position to comprehend his deeds and confirm his conduct to law....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

A research and compare/contrast paper on the topic of Insanity (Ten days in a Madhouse / Voluntary Madness)

The methods used for treatment of mental illness differ from culture to culture.... So, one can see that development of methods used in this field is Thesis statement: The difference in methods used for treatment of mental illness then and now: A research and compare/contrast paper on the topic of "Insanity" (special reference to the works: "Ten days in a Madhouse" / "Voluntary Madness").... arlier, treatment methods in the field of mental illness were doctor oriented because less importance was given to the physical and mental health of patients....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Comparing the Difference between Duress and Insanity

This research gives an understanding of the "Twinkie Defense" and "temporary insanity" defenses as well as cases to show the difference between the two.... Though Poddar was ordered out of the United States after Tarasoff's death, the parents found some vindication in getting the legislation passed in their state the difference between duress and insanity is not always clear though both defenses are used in the criminal justice system.... This research gives an understanding of these two defenses as well as cases to show the difference between the two. ...
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Insanity Plea Condition of Mind

Later, the Model Penal Code of America compromised between the above said rules and declared that a person capable of knowing the difference between right and wrong is not insane.... and insanity is not necessarily to be accompanied by psychosis.... It neither wants to continue the plea of mental illness for heuristic reasons nor would approve psychiatric testimony for the ultimate decision on sanity or insanity.... Symptoms exhibited by a person suspected of malingering can be compared with those people who really have mental illness....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Post-structuralism, Critical Realism and Materialism in Relation to Mental Health Disorders

Post-structural theory suggest that sanity and insanity are not binary opposed.... Research indicates that social structuring can cause mental health disorders and illness.... Sociology of Health and illness, 23,2: 135–58. ... "Post-structuralism, Critical Realism and Materialism in Relation to mental Health Disorders" paper states that social and health inequalities are a persistent feature in the world today.... The issue arouses enough passion to cause mental arrest in family units and the general society....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Issues of The Sociology of Mental Health and Illness

In the exploration of Koerner and Carlat about the role of marketing and promotion strategies concerning mental illness and its perpetuation, they argue that marketing and promotion strategies are evil ways of portraying mental illness (Koerner pg.... According to Kuthcins and Kirk in their article, they argue that racial issues have been a preoccupation in response to mental illness and diagnosis.... Rosenhan gives it the approach of trying to find the difference between sanity and insanity given the often non-compelling evidence....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us