StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper "Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria?" investigates the case between the teachers’ union, Newbury Education Association and employer, Newbury Ohio Local School District Board of Education that primarily deals with the teachers with the extra duty of supervising cafeteria during the lunchtime. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.7% of users find it useful
Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria"

Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria? The case is between the teachers’ union, Newbury Education Association and employer, Newbury Ohio Local School District Board of Education that primarily deals with the teachers with the extra duty of supervising cafeteria during the lunch time. During 2001-2002 the principals of the school observed increased behavioral problems amongst the students in the cafeteria and the playground. Thereafter, 20 minutes lunch period was introduced, every three days, for teachers to supervise the cafeteria, resulting in two teachers being present in cafeteria during the lunch breaks.

The teachers filed the grievances for these new assignments.According to the employers, there was standard management rights’ clause in the parties’ collective bargaining agreement which they had invoked in the present case to contain rowdy behavior of the students, during the lunch break. The union, on the other hand, asserted that cafeteria supervision was mentioned in the agreement for the secondary teachers only and due to lack of any past practice, assigning these duties to the elementary teachers was against the contract.

Case Answer 1 Yes, Union’s claim is right. There is a contractual basis, expressed in language because the contract mentions the supervision duties for the secondary teachers and not the elementary school teachers. Case Answer 2 No, there is no past evidence of elementary school teachers burdened with the added responsibilities of supervising cafeteria during the lunch break. There was also no inclusion of such in their job description as against the fact that cafeteria supervision was included in the agreement for secondary teachers.

The union also claimed that the lunch time was used by the teachers for various other educational activities like meeting parents, remediation, preparing and planning students’ performance enhancing activities etc. that were designed for the overall development of the students. Cafeteria supervision would restrict these extra activities that are essential part of teaching aids and measures. Hence, extra duties are legally and ethically wrong.Case Answer 3 As an arbitrator, I would ensure that the elementary teachers were not burdened with the extra duty of cafeteria supervision because children in the elementary school require more educational aids and teachers-parental interaction for improved results.

The roles and responsibilities of a teacher are multidimensional. The teachers often serve as role models for their students so they need to be very meticulous and at the same time, he/she should be extremely knowledgeable so as to command respect from their students. In the contemporary times, lunch breaks are critical time for teachers as they use the time for improving and improvising the teaching methodologies. The time is also used for interacting with the parents to evolve easy for improving students’ performance.

What do you think the outcome should be? The elementary school teachers should not be assigned the duty of cafeteria supervision. Though the management may have discretionary rights but the fact that there has been no evidence of past practice of binding elementary school teachers for cafeteria supervision and the contractual agreement is silent on the issue for elementary school teachers gives legitimacy to the grievances of the elementary school teachers.ReferenceCase Study: Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria?

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria Essay - 7”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1556396-case-study
(Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria Essay - 7)
https://studentshare.org/education/1556396-case-study.
“Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria Essay - 7”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1556396-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria

Students-Teachers Friendship on Facebook

This paper will focus on the main reasons why teachers should avoid being friends with students on Facebook.... They act as role models to their students and whenever they decide to send them a friend request they are most likely to accept.... On the other hand, students are most likely to find a teacher's profile in the process of surfing and send a friend request.... nbsp; Privacy  When teachers and students become friends, their privacy is compromised....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

A Teacher's Expectations of Students

When looking at students in grades fourth through sixth grades, this is a trying time to get the students to become more independent with their studies.... The author argues in a well-organized manner that when a teacher considers the expectations that they should have for their classroom students, they need to keep one thing in mind: if a teacher expects nothing, they will get nothing from their students.... If these expectations are met, students experience a self-fulfillment prophecy (Stipek)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Dealing with Bullying and Domestic Violence in Schools

For several children, bullying appears to be a reality that they are informed to recognize as an element of growing up.... Those kids who fail to distinguish and end bullying… Bullying often leads to greater and prolonged violence.... Not merely does it damages its anticipated victims, but it also depressingly affects the ambiance Bullying among kids is usually defined as intended, recurring hurtful deeds, words or other performance, like threatening, name-calling, also rejecting....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

A Teachers Role in the Lives of Students

Teachers guide students in facing the different challenges that life offers.... “A teacher's purpose is not to create students in his own image, but to develop students who can create their own image.... The essay “A Teacher's Role in the Lives of students” will look at teacher's role in the shaping of the behavior, learning process and the total personality of a child.... The impact of the teacher on the lives of students is immeasurable....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Commonly Accepted Principles of Supervision

In a democratic school environment, those goals must be supported by a majority of the school community, of whom teachers are the most affected.... The author argues that in the absence of clear goals, teachers will waste valuable time speculating what the school expects of them....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article

The Renovation of the University Cafeteria

Also, the cafeteria lacks adequate space for seats and enough trashcans-the furniture available is not comfortable.... nbsp; In addition, the computers which are not updated slowly down the service delivery at the cafeteria.... The above conditions result to the inadequate circulation of the students within the cafeteria.... Moreover, the cafeteria has few entrances and exits and suffers from the noise from the surrounding that disrupts the students and the university staff....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Building Students Self-Esteem Is a Teachers Goal

The author of the paper "Building students Self-Esteem Is a Teachers Goal" will begin with the statement that self-esteem is the principles, ideas, and outlook of how we see ourselves or how one thinks about himself either, automatically, or intentionally.... nbsp;They have certainty that students with an optimistic idea about themselves and skills, end up achieving high scores than those with pessimistic feelings in mind.... He noticed that those students with problems in spelling some words, their response relied on how they carried themselves as failures, and the number of mistakes in their work, regardless of the different trickiness of the word spelling, were similar....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us