StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Reading on the Surface: The Power behind the Internet - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Severe criticism of the Internet and other digital technologies has become rampant due to several currently published works where the assumption of the damaging impact of online habits on reading comprehension is enclosed within a discourse which emphasizes the disadvantages of technology…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.2% of users find it useful
Reading on the Surface: The Power behind the Internet
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Reading on the Surface: The Power behind the Internet"

Download file to see previous pages

In his book The Shallows: What the Internet is doing to our Brains, Nicholas Carr (2010) severely criticizes digital reading. His evaluation of his own reading experiences in the Internet age thoroughly describes the growth of his habit to speed read or read on the surface, an adverse online behavior. He views this habit as an indication of lack of concentration, browsing from site to site, and discouraging deeper reading. However, this essay argues that the Internet does not weaken an individual’s ability to comprehend texts, especially lengthy ones; rather, the Internet promotes surface reading that eventually leads to deeper, insightful, and corrective reading.

Carr’s assumption about the reason deeper reading is not possible on the Internet is vague. He argues that skimming “is becoming our dominant mode of reading” (Carr 28). People willingly scan for information or do quick reading because of the massive quantity of information available today. But this does not imply that most people today cannot read in detail or reflectively. Basically speaking, skimming is not evidence that there is an absence of deep reading. Rather, it is simply an indication of overflowing information.

The particular type of reading which Carr calls ‘surface reading’ has its equivalent in a different type of surface reading—the ‘prelectio’ (Fowley, English, & Thouesny 97-98). In order to explain the relevance of the concept of ‘prelectio’ to this argument, it is important to provide an overview of its history. In the monastic practice methods were created to decode and understand texts without reading thoroughly or in depth. Hence, it is believed that ‘prelectio’ and word separation were involved in the emergence of silent reading (Fowley et al. 98). In his book Space Between Words: The Origins of Silent Reading Saenger (1997) explains that the tradition of canonical word separation resulted in the emergence of silent reading in religious communities.

The reading of the text to initially begin word separation was a skimming or browsing for information. The clerics scanned the text’s surface before performing a deeper reading. This preliminary pre-reading or browsing for information was a vital aspect of the decoding process. The transition is from pre-reading to a thorough or deeper reading. Therefore, this transition from skimming to reflection and comprehension disproves Carr’s argument. Surface reading, which Carr attributes to the Internet, in fact allows deeper reading.

The connection between Internet reading and ‘prelectio’ is that both are performed on the basis of reading for information and not for the message. The form of reading provided by pre-web screen reading resembles the process of word separation (Fowley et al. 99). As argued by Giffard (2009, para 4): Before the web, in the practice of reading on a screen, the text is not the objective of the reader. Rather is it a control reading, a certain way to decipher and survey the information (sic) and operations of the computer.

And reading is submitted to another activity that is the real goal. Internet reading resembles a control reading, reading for information, or ‘prelectio’ to make sure that the information provided is accurate or inaccurate. Internet reading is in fact ‘functional’ reading. Giffard (2009) claims that this type of reading for information or control reading is innate in any reading on screen and is very common today. Therefore, Internet reading is not really detrimental to an individual’s mental processes because it actually promotes higher order reasoning by scanning for and identifying

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Reading on the Surface: The Power behind the Internet Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1485030-reading-on-the-surface-the-power-behind-the-internet
(Reading on the Surface: The Power Behind the Internet Essay)
https://studentshare.org/english/1485030-reading-on-the-surface-the-power-behind-the-internet.
“Reading on the Surface: The Power Behind the Internet Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1485030-reading-on-the-surface-the-power-behind-the-internet.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Reading on the Surface: The Power behind the Internet

Atomic force microscopy

This tip is attached to the free end of a The material to be scanned is placed below the tip, as the tip moves across the surface it is attracted or repelled by different forces, the atomic deflection from rest is recorded and an imaging software is used to process the results.... The results normally appears as a topographical image of the surface imaged2.... Different imaging techniques are used to picture the surface or for different surface analysis, they include the contact mode, non-contact mode and tapping mode....
5 Pages (1250 words) Lab Report

Laser Sheet Metal Formation

This review intends to investigate the technology behind the laser forming of sheet metals.... Based on examination of magazine articles, published journals, published books and internet sites, this report focuses on creating an understanding of the attributes of laser forming of sheet metal.... Research on these types of lasers uses power ranging between 100-kilowatt level watts to kilowatt level.... The amount of power used depends on the forming conditions and the thickness of the material....
8 Pages (2000 words) Literature review

Aircraft Wing Design Considerations

Thirdly, some have the misconception that during generation of an aerofoil lift, the inherent upper parts of the foil must have more curvature compared to the lower surface.... Designing an effective airfoil requires comprehensive understanding of how the wings work in relation to drag and lift generation....
10 Pages (2500 words) Book Report/Review

Aerofoil - How Wings Work Tasks

Individuals tend to believe that during generation of lift, the there must exist a stronger curvature of the upper surface than lower surface of the airfoil.... Size and shape are essential in enabling efficient movement of airplane through space by minimizing resistance to the moving air....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review

Water Resource Monitoring Using Remote Sensing

It also addresses the technical aspect behind the applications of remote sensing techniques in water resources management.... nbsp;The radiations used in remote sensing technique such as infrared radiations, UV radiations, x- rays, γ- radiations and other types of radiations can distinguish different tones of color as well as giving different color characteristics on various phenomena detected in or above the water surface (Bartholom´e & Belward, 2005)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Introduction to Materials, Tribology and Surface Engineering

This assignment "Introduction to Materials, Tribology and surface Engineering" presents steel as the most widely recycled material.... It is an advantage to recycle steel economically and that has been the reason why it has been continued for more than 150 years.... hellip; Recycling steel is cheaper than iron ore and it is easy to manipulate the old steel to form new steel through the production process....
22 Pages (5500 words) Assignment

Equipment to Measure the Static Coefficient of Friction

hellip; When a person pushes an object like a wooden block on a smooth steel sheet the exercise is very easy, whilst in the case of a wooden sheet the activity is deemed to be more difficult and cumbersome, but if one pushes some wooden sheet on a road surface the whole endeavor becomes even more difficult.... The rolling friction is the ultimate resistance produced when a rolling surface moves over a static surface like when a vehicle or a bicycle moves on the road....
26 Pages (6500 words) Term Paper

Aerodynamics of Supersonic Aircrafts

Researchers in aerodynamics while coming up with wing or body design, major on surface flow designs which are based on putting certain pressures on the surface of experimental objects then looking for the shape of objects that will provide safe surface conditions.... Supersonic aircraft are therefore designed to have more power than subsonic aircraft (Mason, 2006).... The drag is caused by forces that are a result of pressure distributions on the aircraft's body surface (Hornung, 1986)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us