StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Dravid Luis and His Oppinions - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay declares that the major ethical issue in this case is whether Dravid Luis will be doing or not doing what Jimmy Westfield wants regarding the documentation of the worth of the equipment which is at $3,500,000 following its net realizable value. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.7% of users find it useful
Dravid Luis and His Oppinions
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Dravid Luis and His Oppinions"

1. What is the major ethical issue in this case? What are Dravid Luis’ options in this case (i.e. what can he do)? (3 marks) ANSWER: The major ethical issue in this case is whether Dravid Luis will be doing or not doing what Jimmy Westfield wants regarding the documentation of the worth of the equipment which is at $3,500,000 following its net realizable value. This is the major ethical issue as it creates a dilemma among the fundamental principles that govern the code of ethical actions within Dravid Luis’ field, accounting. In this case, the options that are open for Dravid Luis are: he can just follow the wish of Jimmy Westfield to record the value of the equipment using the net realizable value which is at $3,500,000. Or he cannot follow what Jimmy Westfield asks him to do and write $6,000,000 as the value of the equipment following his professional judgment that the proper way to determine its value is via using the current replacement cost for similar capacity. Or he can look for other estimates which he can offer to Jimmy Westfield. This suggestion is raised since Dravid Luis has based his valuation on just two estimates that he obtained. The number of estimates that he has obtained seems to be a little low considering that worth of the equipment that is being evaluated amounts to millions of dollars. Or he can consult another accountant regarding alternative options that may be offered to Jimmy Westfield to settle their difference in evaluating the worth of the equipment. 2. Assume you are in Dravid Luis’ position evaluate the ethics of going along with Jimmy Westfield’s desire to record the equipment at net realizable value from a utilitarian and rights perspective. (3 marks) ANSWER: Utilitarianism is basically the greatest happiness principle which holds that actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness or pleasure and wrong if they tend to produce pain. (Mill 1861) However, it is important to note that there are two kinds of utilitarianism- act utilitarianism and rule utilitarianism. In act utilitarianism the consequence of the act should produce the greatest happiness to the greatest number of people (Velasquez 1999) while rule utilitarianism means that we should act so that the rules governing our action produce the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people. With utilitarianism as the ethical framework, we now analyze Dravid Luis’ going along with Jimmy Westfield’s desire to record the equipment at net realizable value. In the act utilitarianism, Dravid Luis’ act of going along with Jimmy Westfield’s wish is wrong because if you are simplistically going to count the number of all the stakeholders who will be happy or who will not incur any pain as a result of the disadvantage brought by a lower estimated cause of an asset, then the majority- Dravid Luis, possible investors in the future, and the third party finance company- will not be happy since they are not presented with the true value of the equipment. And as such they are deceived, since a lower depreciation amount could make the difference between showing profits instead of losses. And it seems that Westfield is the only one happy as he intends to sell off the equipment soon after the purchase which will yield a higher price following the use of replacement costs for its evaluation. Alternatively, if we are going to use rule utilitarianism, more difficulty is confronted since we have to know the rule that governs Luis’ action. Supposing that the rule Luis should follow is satisfaction of his client, in this case, it’s Jimmy Westfield, then what Luis has done is right. It’s the rule. On the other hand, if Luis ‘action of going along with Westfield will be analyzed using the rights perspective following Kantian ethics which hold two important maxims, namely “Act only on that maxim whereby thou canst at the same time will that it should become a universal law” and “So act to treat humanity, whether in thine own person or in that of any other, in every case as an end withal, never as a means only”(Kant 2002), then Luis’ act of going along with Westfield is wrong. For the following reasons: first, he allowed himself to be used as means towards Westfield gaining much advantage. And second, he cannot will that his act of lying in document can be universalized. He cannot will that other rational beings like him who may find themselves in the same ethical dilemma as Luis is in will do what he did- lie. 3. If you are Dravid Luis, identify three fundamental principles in APES 110 Code of ethics for Professional Accountants which would be of greatest concern to you while deciding the course of action to take in this case? What concerns would you have about your newly established employment relationship with Jimmy Westfield and NEWCO? (4 marks) ANSWER: The three fundamental principles that will highly influence my decision making regarding the course of action that I will take in face of this dilemma are “integrity, objectivity and professional competence and due care.” (APES110 Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants, 2006) Integrity, as an accountant, I should be fair and honest in all my dealings. My personal integrity and the integrity of the institution that I represent are always at stake in all my transactions. It is not only to protecting my name and selfhood but also protecting the institution where I belong. Objectivity, it is the only way that I can maintain and sustain my integrity – to be objective in all my dealings. This implies that I have to exert all efforts to be free from undue influences or threats as I fulfill my function as the accountant of the company. And finally, professional competence and due care. This is the best approach that will enable me to secure my integrity and objectivity in the performance of my job. Professional competency and due care assures the client that I possess the necessary skills and knowledge needed in the diligent performance of my job and that I have utilized all the necessary means and ways to ascertain that I am doing the right thing. Of course, as the fundamental principles will be a major part of the decision –making process, of same weight, are considerations pertinent to the repercussions of the decision in terms of how it will affect my relationship with my new boss – Jimmy Westfield. The first major concern is that he may terminate my services right away. Let us face it, he is the boss and owner of the corporation and he can fire me anytime. The other consideration that bothers me is that if I do not follow him, and since he is Jimmy Westfield a wealthy investor, he might use his influence so that I’ll have some difficulty in finding new clients. We know that in the accounting business the best way to advertise your services is by word of mouth of your clients. And if a well-known investor like Jimmy Westfield is displeased with my services then it’s detrimental to my career. My final concern me is that he may sue me for insubordination, since he has given a clear directive as to what I should do and yet I did not follow him. With regards to NEWCO, my primary concern is that it is a shell corporation and in corporations like this there is a thin line which defines it as between legal and/or illegal Corporation. The seeming lack of guidelines for is another concern.LBO 4. Assuming that Dravid Luis chose not to go along with Jimmy Westfield’s desire to record the equipment at net realizable value, justify the reason why he would not modify the asset value at each of the six stages of Cognitive and Moral Development as outlined in the Kohlberg framework. Which stage of the Kohlberg framework does Jimmy Westfield appear to be and why? ( 5 marks) ANSWER: In each of the six stages of the Cognitive and Moral development in the Kohlberg framework (Reiter 1996), Dravid Luis’ action of not going along the wish of Jimmy Westfield to record the equipment at net realizable value can be justified. In stage one wherein individual avoids punishment, Dravid Luis can justify his action by claiming that there are clear punishments regarding the action that Westfield plans to do. And that the only that way he can protect himself from the punishment is not to follow him. In the second stage which is characterized by individuals who are motivated by satisfaction of their needs. Dravid Luis can use as an argument for his action the Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. According to Maslow (1943) human needs are not just constrained within the boundaries of physiological needs. Higher up the triangle are human needs for belonginess, self-esteem, self-actualization, and transcendence. And in Dravid Luis’ case, not following Westfield is essentially satisfying these higher human needs. In stage three which is described by group norms providing motivation, Luis can argue that by following the reorganized “Maslow’s and Alderfer's hierarchies” (Huitt 2004) which claims that motivation for action stems the importance of relatedness and that this factor is of integral importance in the attainment of growth. And following the norms provided by group where Luis belongs ascertains his position and relation within the group. In stage four where laws or rules set by the society act as a guide in solving the conflict. Luis can claim that the rules on how accountants like him should conduct their dealing with their clients are quite specific. Though the examples to show the actual application of the principles and concepts are limited, it does not mean that it cannot address similar issues. As such, since principles and guiding rules are clear, then he has to follow. Thus, affirming the law and order morality. In stage five, wherein the capacity to take in the interests of all the parties involved is emphasized, Luis can claim that after weighing and evaluating all the necessary factors in making the decision – the interests of all the stakeholders in the case- he has come up with the decision that the best action to be taken is not follow Jimmy Westfield’s wish. And finally the last stage, stage six, the creation of the moral principle. Luis can claim that whatever action he will make, its validity goes beyond their particular transaction. The ‘universalizavility’ of his act lie on the fact that the public sphere is shared with other rational human beings who just like Luis can move beyond self-greed and come up with universal principles that will allow human flourishing not just for one or two individuals but for all persons involved. On the other hand, looking at the action of Jimmy Westfield – his desire to use the net realizable value of the equipment in the documentation – he is in stage two of the Kohlberg’s framework. This claim is based on the following reasons. First, he is motivated by greed. In stage two, when much focus is on satisfying basic needs at the lowest level – physiological needs - people tend to be trapped in the boundaries of securing ‘unlimited wealth’ to the point of becoming ruthless, greedy and blinded to the authenticity of their actual need. Second, Westfield is in stage two because his basic question is ‘what’s in it for me?’ His utter disregard to the moral sensibilities of Luis shows that his interest is to protect only his own interest. And finally, he is in stage two because his self-interests govern his manner of dealing with Luis and the people around him. BIBLIOGRAPHY: APES110 Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants. (2006). Accounting Professional & Ethical Standards Board. Huitt, W. (2004). Maslow's hierarchy of needs. Educational Psychology Interactive. Valdosta, GA: Valdosta State University. Retrieved [5 October 2009] from, http://chiron.valdosta.edu/whuitt/col/regsys/maslow.html. Kant, I.(2002). The Foundations in the Metaphysics of Morals. Trans byT.K. Abbot. IN Philosophy: The Quest for Truth 5th Edition by Louis P. Pojman. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Maslow, A. (1943). A theory of human motivation. Psychological Review, 50, 370-396. Mill. J. (1965). Utilitarianism. In Essential Works of John Stuart Mill. Ed by Max Lerner. New York: Bantam Books. Reiter, S. (1996). The Kohlberg-Gilligan controversy: Lessons for accounting ethics education. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 7, pp 33 – 54. Velasquez, M. (1999). Philosophy: A Text with Readings 7th Edition. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Dravid Luis and His Oppinions Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/english/1558168-ethical-case-study
(Dravid Luis and His Oppinions Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1558168-ethical-case-study.
“Dravid Luis and His Oppinions Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1558168-ethical-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Dravid Luis and His Oppinions

Utilizing Work Performance Habits Effectively

This project “Utilizing Work Performance Habits Effectively” is designed to address three key business success tools available to aid in professional performance: Group and organizational behavior, writing proficiency, as well as conflict management.... hellip; Theories about these key performance-enhancers indicate that within contemporary organizations, groups must not only work together to accomplish business goals but must also understand the dynamics of how to effectively communicate and handle potential adversarial relationships between group members....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Death of Socrates by Jacques-Louis David and The Period Eye by Michael Baxandall

his right arm is raised in an argumentative gesture.... his left arm is leisurely reaching for a golden cup, held by a young man in red.... The philosopher is sitting on the couch in the middle of the canvass surrounded by his friends and disciplines, all of them crying and grieving.... Loyal to his ideas of the immortality of the human soul, Socrates has decisively and calmly chosen death.... He continues teaching his disciplines until his last breath....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Slavery and movents to end it

In his writing, Frederick Douglass emphasized the need for immediate and radical action to end slavery and racism in the state.... He offered an indomitable voice of hope to slavery in his writing.... In his lecture, Frederick also talked about the need to embrace anti-slavery politics in the country.... In his writings, Pessen talked about the need to fight for equality of the entire American citizenry.... In his literature, Frederick Douglas talked about the immediate adoption of fair and appropriate policies and politics that will eliminate racism and slavery....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Successful Celebrity Endorsement in Real World

His good looks, pleasant personality and his outclass performance in soccer had made him a style icon for not only the youth but... his good looks together with his ability to score with free kicks made him a star and a large number of fans in Asian and European countries.... He has been one… Beckham started his career as a trainee with Manchester United which was quite popular in the UK.... Soon, Beckham made an impression by his exceptional play his free kicks and Beckham, married to ex-member of the pop group Spice Girls' Victoria Adams, became one of the most popular celebrity couples of the time....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Development of photography

his contribution to photography is he studied photographic pictures of Venus and its moons.... He gave his heliocentric theory as opposed to the geocentricism as a result of his photographic study of planets. During the 16th century, J.... his contribution to photography is he studied photographic pictures of Venus and its moons.... He gave his heliocentric theory as opposed to the geocentricism as a result of his photographic study of planets....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Pieta and Jean-Paul Marat in Davids Painting

In this depiction, his body forms an S shape with his head dropping over his shoulder toward the face of his mother and his legs trailing behind in the other direction as he is brought to her.... In each, the lifeless form of Jesus is seen draped upon his mother's form.... In one statue and the painting, he is completely in his mother's embrace, lain either across her lap or clasped in her arms.... The earliest statue, the one now housed in Rome, depicts Jesus lain across his mother's lap as she looks down upon him in sorrowful acceptance of his passing....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

The New Individualism Theoretical Concept

"The New Individualism Theoretical Concept" paper contains a discussion on how individualism was first brought into the picture of human lives by sociologists to its gradual development of critical review, the psychology behind this concept has grown by leaps and bounds.... nbsp;… New Individualists, Paul Leinberger and Bruce Tucker reveal the generational transformation between the 1950s “organization men” and their children, who value self more than loyalty....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Analysis of The Oath of the Horatii

He is well-known for his grandiose history paintings, particularly with political and social connotations This particular picture provides a lot of significance to David's body of works because it is his introduction to neoclassicism style in French paintings.... After his initial years of formal education, he was tutored by Joseph-Marie Vien, who embraced the newfangled classical reaction to Rococo in his paintings.... In the 1780s, he established his career as a Salon painter and was soon lodged by the King in the Louvre, an ancient prestigious privilege for great artists....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us