StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Why does Montaigne change so many definition of words - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
By moralizing, it pertains to the way that people use their language to assert their superiority over others. Montaigne redefines the words of “barbarian,” “victory,” “wild,” and…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
Why does Montaigne change so many definition of words
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Why does Montaigne change so many definition of words"

16 October The Morality and Ascendancy of Language “On Cannibals” is an essay that questions the moralizing use of language. By moralizing, it pertains to the way that people use their language to assert their superiority over others. Montaigne redefines the words of “barbarian,” “victory,” “wild,” and “bodies,” as a way of criticizing the moral values placed on these words by their users. He does not contradict himself, but instead, he criticizes the moral values imbibed in what should be random words.

Montaigne changes the meanings of words because he wants to prove that language is arbitrary, and people define concepts, according to their views of truth and reason, without considering the existence and validity of other truths and reasons.While people define “bodies” in the physical sense, they stress its sacredness, which is why they think that people who eat human flesh are “barbarians,” but Montaigne disagrees with the idealization of the human body, when it can serve many immoral purposes.

He reminds his readers that “bodies” are not exactly detached from the act of being consumed or used in other corrupt ways. He provides examples of ancestors who ate the bodies of people who were “incapable of fighting” (114). This means that able bodies trump weaker ones, even if they both have bodies. People in power define “bodies” as they see fit, and the morality of doing so becomes blurred in different circumstances and cultures. “Barbarian” is another word with contested meanings.

Montaigne defines “barbarous” as a concept coined by a society that looks down on a pure society, and if the latter are described as “wild,” they are wild because they are pure. He denigrates that people call something “barbarous,” simply because they are “contrary” to their “habits” (108). If these barbarians are considered “wild,” for him, they are wild in a good way. They are wild because “the true, the most useful, and natural virtues and properties are alive and vigorous” (Montaigne 109).

Instead of seeing “wild” as the opposite of civilized, Montaigne argues that it is a civilization on its own that is not inferior to Western society. To be barbaric is related to “victory” and its many hued definitions. Montaigne describes “victory” as aligned to the simple desire of controlling people’s emotions. For the “barbarians,” “victory” happens when they have broken the spirit of their prisoners, until the latter beg for their lives (115). Montaigne differentiates this from the “victory” of his people.

For them, “victory” is not about honor, but about getting power, mostly over the economic resources of others. He further defines “victory” as a process: “The true victory lies in battle rather than in survival; the prize of valour in fighting, not in winning” (117). At some point, people can say that Montaigne is contradicting himself by saying that victory is a journey, when he also commends victory that is won through battles. However, he asserts that victory comes from valor, which is only tested through their experiences in battle.

Thus, controlling people’s emotions, in the context of the “barbarians,” is also a process of valor, and one which results to the outcome of victory. Montaigne argues that people use their language in absolute terms. They forget that language is an arbitrary set of signs and meanings. As a result, he redefines words from the “barbarian” perspective. In doing so, he strives to understand the world of another culture from their own perspective, without applying a moralizing lens on their views, customs, and practices.

In essence, Montaigne contends that Western society expands and promotes its power by diminishing other cultures, wherein calling them “barbaric” justifies the violence of colonization.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Why does Montaigne change so many definition of words Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/english/1605334-why-does-montaigne-change-so-many-definition-of-words
(Why Does Montaigne Change so Many Definition of Words Essay)
https://studentshare.org/english/1605334-why-does-montaigne-change-so-many-definition-of-words.
“Why Does Montaigne Change so Many Definition of Words Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1605334-why-does-montaigne-change-so-many-definition-of-words.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Why does Montaigne change so many definition of words

Classic Film Noir Style and its Characteristics: Citizen Kane

Film scholars, however, cannot agree on any single definition of film noir.... The structure of film noir does not follow the normal three-act arrangement of many films, and instead, it showcases an intricate plot with elaborate flashbacks.... The reason why Kane is so difficult to understand is because he does not want to open up to other people in the first place.... In the end, no one truly knows who Kane is, which is why nobody discovered what Rosebud means to him....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Karl Marxs Theory in the Realm of Media

Marx theorized that the upper-class control the formation and definition of these ideologies so as to prevent people in the lower-class from knowing how society truly operates.... It has given society an undeniably enhanced appreciation of history's social dynamics and reveals many of its obscure yet significant attributes.... Commodities are articles of wealth created solely as a means to exchange other objects so as to enhance wealth....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Evolution of Graphic Design

hellip; Generally speaking, from its earliest beginnings, graphic design has continued to be shaped and changed over time by the influences of the fine art world as it has shifted focus, definition and attention on various theories and philosophies influenced by the technological advancements of the digital age.... These attributes meant digital illustration became the wave of the future for graphic design as well as many other forms of art media....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Who Is Jack the Ripper

Where the murders that took place in 19th century managed to haunt the citizens of East London for decades; its after-effects are still felt by the Western world due to literary evidences… In addition to the horrifying and abhorrent methodology of conducting murders and mutilating victims' bodies, the fact that Ripper remained unidentified, forced many citizens of This fear was further aggravated due to social and economic conditions of the-then London.... The place was even a hub of many brothels and sex-rental houses, where reaching a woman was not an issue....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Florian Boxing the Compass Embraces Idolatry

They were involved in many devastating actions that did not augur well with God.... many times various forms as indicated above have been applied by many worshippers who do not believe in the existence of a supernatural being.... The author of this essay "Boxing the Compass" focuses on the ideas depicted by Sandy Florian in "Sandy Florian"....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Trading Places: Supporting Marxs Commodity Fetishism

Thus, many of the films that come out of Hollywood tend to reflect the glamorous, comfortable aspect of life that can only be obtained by acquiring a high degree of material wealth or the struggle to attain this status, reinforcing the idea that the only way to live is to have a great deal of wealth and that without it, life is not worth living.... This message is so prevalent that it is not even questioned in most circles, but rather exists as a fundamental belief of the prevailing culture....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Status of Aids in the US

AIDs will, however, have a continued lasting impact on the future of all of world history … However, for the time being, that is not so.... The author states that Aids has been a growing and changing part of American culture ever since it started killing people all those years ago....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

The Stalemate between Science and Religion

hellip; The impasse is probably best described in David Hume's famous words on miracles which the religious readily accept and scientists remain sceptical about.... This paper ''the Stalemate between Science and Religion'' tells that in many cases the two subjects tend to be mutually exclusive with the claims made by science being deemed heretical and immoral by religion while atheist scientists view religions as a conglomeration of superstition, ignorance and at best non substantive beliefs and claims....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us