StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

DRED SCOTT WAS NOT A CITIZEN OF MISSOURI - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Student identification Course Institution Date (all above optional – if you need them; please also see the references section – and please complete for the source that you attached, as indicated.) Dred Scott Was Not a Citizen of Missouri Today, the Constitution of the United States of America is widely seen as the most important document in the country…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
DRED SCOTT WAS NOT A CITIZEN OF MISSOURI
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "DRED SCOTT WAS NOT A CITIZEN OF MISSOURI"

Download file to see previous pages

Thus, presently, the Supreme Court is the Court which most closely carries out the intentions set in the Constitution. Both the Constitution and the Supreme Court are federal institutions, and as such are ultimately respected by the citizens, the public officials and the law-makers of this country, within States, and by the people as a whole. Early in the development of the United States, though, this was not always the case, and a particular case, Scott v. Sandford, gave rise to a series of legal events which called into question both the US Constitution and the power and validity of the US Supreme Court.

In fact, this case may even have primary importance in explaining the reasons for the Civil War. Perhaps the most significant social factor at work in the US in the late 1700s, and throughout the 1800s was slavery. This economic and social fact at work within society was considered, though, to be a political issue. Legal debates and decisions were largely made to enforce the Constitutional acknowledgement of slavery, not to make rulings about slavery being right or wrong. Political solutions were sought to the question of slavery, rather than legal solutions.

By 1787, slavery was recognized in the Constitution (Author, year p. . ervice or Labor …” The Constitution went further, not to regulate slavery within States through Congress until 1808, but only to tax the movement of slaves into States, or between States up to that date (Art. I Sec. 9 Para.1). Slavery was, then, accepted as a fact which existed within States, and the federal Government restricted its involvement in the affairs of individual States. States made their own decisions about whether they were “Free States”, or whether they would allow slavery, and Congress respected those decisions.

But the implication was that 1808 would be the year in which Slavery would be abolished. In 1819, Missouri appealed to be included in the Confederation as a slave-owning State. This appeal was met by much resistance from the Northern States – in which Abolitionism was dominant – and the Midwestern States – where economies without slave labor would struggle against the slave-owning State economies. But Missouri entered the Confederation as a slave-owning State in 1819; Texas and Florida did likewise in 1845.

By 1854, though, a Bill was passed to enable the building of a railroad system to cross the continent, and it expressed overtly that regions, and the people themselves, could decide on slavery issues, rather than the Federal Government. This trend continued and by 1856-7, Abolitionism in the Northern States was becoming more powerful as a political force. Still, though, the Courts tried to avoid the issue of Slavery. Nonetheless, some decisions were made in the Courts, related to this question.

In 1824, for example, a case was heard relating to an 1803 Act of Congress preventing States from admitting persons of color. Arguments in the Gibbons v. Ogden case claimed that the rights of States to regulate slave traffic – the

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“DRED SCOTT WAS NOT A CITIZEN OF MISSOURI Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1406438-dred-scott-was-not-a-citizen-of-missouri
(DRED SCOTT WAS NOT A CITIZEN OF MISSOURI Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1406438-dred-scott-was-not-a-citizen-of-missouri.
“DRED SCOTT WAS NOT A CITIZEN OF MISSOURI Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1406438-dred-scott-was-not-a-citizen-of-missouri.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF DRED SCOTT WAS NOT A CITIZEN OF MISSOURI

Slave Who Sued His Owner for His Freedom

More importantly, the Supreme Court's ruling (by 7-1 no less) determined that dred scott was merely property of his owners and as such was subject to the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution.... Name Date Course Section/# dred scott: An Analysis and Review Once the final shot of the Civil War had long since faded into memory, the court cases, legislation, and societal understanding of the African-Americans were ultimately of the most importance with regards to building a new Republic based upon existing determinants of race and the means by which an individual of African-American ethnicity would ultimately integrate within such a society....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Dred Scott v. Sandford (1875)

hellip; In this first case he lost as the ruling was that he was not a citizen of US thus, could not sue.... Summary of Sources The following articles obtained from the State Historical Society of missouri have been used in support of this case analysis.... dred scott v.... Sandford (1875) Name: Institution: Introduction of case subject The case of dred scott v.... Sandford was one which involved dred scott, a peasant slave against his master Sandford, and begun in 1846 in the Missouri lower state courts....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Dred Scott v. Sanford,The Lecompton Constitution, Freeport Doctrine and Fugitive Slave Law of 1850

After a series of trials, the US Supreme Court found that dred scott was not entitled to citizenship.... dred scott was a 61 year old slave who sued for his freedom in the case of Dred Scott v.... According to Huston (2003), the opposition argued, " being a slave, had no right to petition the court like a citizen— slaves, obviously, were not citizens and had no citizenship rights " (p.... Upon returning to missouri, a slave state, he sued for his freedom and the court ruled 7-2 that he did not have citizen status and therefore could not sue....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Major Landmark Decisions

hellip; Congress tried repeatedly to organize a single territory for the area west of missouri and Iowa, but was unsuccessful.... Congress tried repeatedly to organize a single territory for the area west of missouri and Iowa, but was unsuccessful.... Paul Finkelman in dred scott v.... The Enabling Act of 1820 represented a win, win, situation for most of the parties directly involved; missouri entered the union as they had petitioned, with no conditions or restrictions on their status, and the anti-slavery proponents were reasonably assured that slavery would not encroach on the neighboring territories....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Cause and Effect of the Dread's Scott Decision

With dred scott, the Supreme Court under Taney sought to permit the unhindered expansion of slavery into the territories.... The paper "Cause and Effect of the Dread's scott Decision" states that Frederick Douglass, a prominent African-American abolitionist who thought the decision unconstitutional and the Chief Justice's reasoning inapposite to the founders' vision political conflict could not be avoided....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Scott v. Sanford

The main issue of this case was that Dred was asking the courts to decide as to whether he was no longer a slave and instead was not a citizen of the land and as such, should be accorded the same rights as a free man under the U.... In his courts decision, seven out of 9 judges declared that “no slave or descendant of a slave should be considered a citizen of America.... The fact of the case is that Dred Scott, an African-American slave from the slave state of missouri had an opportunity to live in certain free states of… Army surgeon Dr....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Role of Dredd Scott Case in the Civil War

The decision stated that since Dred was of African descent, a Negro, he was therefore not a citizen of the United States and it follows that he has no right to seek redress to the court for his freedom.... The main argument at the Supreme Court was whether Scott's was indeed a citizen.... dred scott case can be said to be the worst decision that the United States Supreme Court has ever rendered that it even become the catalyst of the American Civil War....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

An Aspect of the Career by Roger B Taney

The case came on appeal before the Chief Justice who deemed it unconstitutional because Scott was the descendant of slaves and therefore not a citizen.... Roger Brooke Taney was the controversial fifth Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States whose name is most famously associated with the dred scott case of 1857.... In this case, a black slave called dred scott sued for his freedom.... Roger Brooke Taney was the controversial fifth Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States whose name is most famously associated with the dred scott case of 1857....
16 Pages (4000 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us