StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The American Uniform Commercial Code versus the English Approach - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The American Uniform Commercial Code versus the English Approach" describes that the English approach is perfectly in tandem with the fundamental ethics of trade and commerce and adequately protects the interest of most of the parties engaged in a commercial arrangement…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
The American Uniform Commercial Code versus the English Approach
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The American Uniform Commercial Code versus the English Approach"

Letters of credit are a pivotal tool that facilitates international trade and commerce. It is simply owing to the instruments like letters of credit that it is possible to allow for the exchange of goods and services in an international context. Without such financial aids, it would have been next to impossible to conduct trade on a global scale. The very relevance of letters of credit is quintessentially based on its autonomy from the transaction that it supports. Any bank that issues a letter of credit simply cannot refuse to honour it and extend the requisite payments, once it is presented with the apt and authentic documents. This also stands to be true in a scenario when the transaction is backed by a letter of credit that does not actually take place. On the one side, the letters of credit extension to the sellers the assurance of a guaranteed payment, while on the other side they safeguard the interests of the buyers by necessitating the presentation of the right documents that to a large extent ensure performance. Such documents may be the like of insurance forms, transportation documents and quality-related certificates.

The Autonomy Principle
The underlying dogma supporting the autonomy principles associated with letters of credit is that the transaction backed by a letter of credit stands to be autonomous of the sales deed formalized by the buyer and the beneficiary. To put it simply, the two essentially contractual arrangements mentioned above are regarded as being independent of each other. In other words, the utility of letters of credit is pragmatically solemnized by the severance of services and documents. It is this principle that is the legal ground on the basis of which banks agree to such transactions.

Fraud Exception
As already mentioned, a letter of credit is the legal and financial instrument, which extends to the beneficiary the security of getting the payment due to one. Yet, this bolstering of security to the beneficiary in a way dilutes the security against risk or loss to the account party. Thus, in the letters of credit, the balance of risk is tilted more in favour of the seller. Though the autonomy principle practically assures the expected commercial results in business transactions, this principle stands to be defective and inequitable when the underlying transaction is vitiated by fraud. Under such circumstances, the autonomy principle gets limited by the fraud exception.

The US Approach
In the United States, in Maurice O’Meara Co v National Park Bank, the court of law simply denied the possibility of invoking a fraud exception. The New York Court of Appeal ruled that that the primary concern of the bank should be pertaining to the veracity of the drafts and the accompanying documents, and not the associate transaction of goods.
Also in New York Life Insurance Co v Hartford National Bank and Trust Co, the court ruled that the inquiry of fraud by a bank needs to be limited to the establishment of the compliance of the documents with the letter of credit. Hence, the Uniform Commercial Code in the US allows the fraud exception only in case of fraud in the complying documents.
Besides as per Article 5-109(a) of the Uniform Commercial Code, even if a seller has committed fraud in the complying documents, the bank is still required to honour a letter of credit in a situation where the claim for payment has been transferred to a third party. The American approach actually safeguards the interests of innocent third parties, by allowing for a waiver of the fraud exception.

The English Approach
In the United Kingdom, in Harbottle v National Westminster Bank, the court stated that a buyer to avail any injunctive dishonour must establish an evident and clearly discernable case of fraud. This viewpoint laid the foundation for deciding on future fraud exceptions pertaining to letters of credit.
In Edward Owen Engineering Ltd v Barclays Bank International Ltd, the court ruled that a bank is not required to honour a credit obligation if the complying documents are forged or the presented request for payment is fraudulent and devoid of any right to payment.
Hence, in the UK, the fraud exception is applicable to both the scenarios that are while the presentation of the forged complying documents and a fraud committed in the contract backed by the letter of credit under consideration, in a scenario when the beneficiary is aware of such a fraud while presenting the complying documents. In a way, the English approach to fraud exception is more broad-based and holistic and is not unwarrantedly tilted in favour of the seller. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Compare Article 5-109 (a) of the ( Amercian) Uniform Commercial Code Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1416817-compare-article
(Compare Article 5-109 (a) of the ( Amercian) Uniform Commercial Code Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1416817-compare-article.
“Compare Article 5-109 (a) of the ( Amercian) Uniform Commercial Code Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1416817-compare-article.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The American Uniform Commercial Code versus the English Approach

Avon in Global Markets

Impact of social institutions in India to Avon's IHRD plan in India 14 Conclusion 16 Annex 18 References 20 Avon in global markets in 2009 Managing and developing a global workforce Introduction Avon is planning to expand its operations in India using the same formula of direct selling approach in India....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Students perceptions of women in advertising commercials

While probabilities can be determined regarding what percentage of viewers will react positively versus those who will react negatively or indifferently, getting more specific than this is very difficult and depends to a great deal on what images and ideas are included in the advertisement itself....
49 Pages (12250 words) Coursework

Role of Arbitration in International Commercial Disputes

With the advent of global commercial enterprise and with the expansion of that global commercial enterprise corporations are now expanding, developing into global entities.... The necessity for arbitration in commercial disputes has become more and more prevalent.... With this advent in global enterprise and necessity for contractual arbitration in commercial enterprise and disputes within that realm several aspects affect such negotiations....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Manchester United Background, Pricing Strategy

The club reportedly has a playing side with revenue from ticket sales, a media side to manage broadcasting and Internet rights to its matches and stars, and a merchandising and commercial side, which collectively aim to turn fans of the first into customers of the second two in their bid for brand extension (Maidment, 2004)....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

The Politics of Identity in Contemporary Literature

esisting StereotypesIn the eighteenth century, when the empirical theories of english thinkers John Locke and Sir Isaac Newton were shaping American literature generally, the African American presence in America added a new dimension to the cultural identity of American literature.... The whole range of possible interpretations can be found in american works.... With the passage of time, African american...
14 Pages (3500 words) Book Report/Review

Levis Strategy and Marketing

The company maintained a balanced sourcing approach from different countries and withdrew from countries where it sensed problems.... This report would look into the factors that led it to adopt a different approach to marketing its products in different regions and countries....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Arbitration Systems in the UK and in the Middle East

The concept of arbitration developed historically in the context of resolving cross-border commercial disputes2.... From the paper "Arbitration Systems in the UK and in the Middle East" it is clear that going back to the original arbitration process in the Middle East and the Western world, its practice has always recognized the merits of informal, speedy, cost-friendly, and good faith proceedings....
66 Pages (16500 words) Essay

Avon in Global Markets in 2009

The paper "Avon in Global Markets in 2009" discusses that Avon uses uniform strategy everywhere and internet website wherein all interested applicants can apply.... Hired locals need training and development because employees from HNC find it difficult to understand the home culture of the main office....
18 Pages (4500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us