StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Gores Argument in an Inconvenient Truth - Movie Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper critically analyses "An Inconvenient Truth" by Gore focusing on criticisms advanced against this film. The writer claims that the movie has managed to create and raise public awareness on global warming but most of its claims have been refuted…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Gores Argument in an Inconvenient Truth
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Gores Argument in an Inconvenient Truth"

Gore’s Argument in an Inconvenient Truth Gore’s An Inconvenient Truth is a global warming documentary that provides arguments in favor of greenhouse gas reductions needed by the Kyoto Protocol. However, this film abandons the evidence that atmospheric temperature is cyclical in nature. This movie focuses on alerting individuals about some of the challenges and dangers that society faces from changes in climate and proposes urgent and immediate action be taken to deal with such issues. Undoubtedly, this documentary is a perfect illustration of how scientific information can be conversed to uninformed audience. This was one way Gore used to educate citizens on global warming and encourage them to take necessary action. But this documentary has created a heated debate as to whether it precisely grants the scientific argument that human activities are the major cause of global warming. Various scholars and climate change experts have expressed their views on the scientific validity of the claims proposed by this documentary. This paper critically analyses An Inconvenient Truth by Gore focusing on criticisms advanced against this film. Many claims proposed by Gore in his film have been criticized by many scientists. There are many criticisms that have been advanced against gore’s documentary of an inconvenient truth. First, Gore has been accused of attempting to use individual extreme events like Hurricane Katrina to provide evidence about the existence of global warming. Another critique of this film is that it mainly focuses on humans and their activities as the major cause of global warming, but it fails to address other natural causes of climate variability that also contribute to the occurrence of global warming. Gore and his supporters believe that human beings contribute to changes in the climate in various ways but mainly by engaging in certain activities (Jackson 475). The real inconvenient truth is that science is not aware of the extent to which the recent warming is natural or result from human activities. In addition, this film has been accused of entirely relying on observational evidence and minimal research. His critiques have claimed that Gore’s arguments on global warming were based on emotions (Jackson 475). Gore argues that the snowcap at the summit Africa’s Mount Kilimanjaro is shrinking as a result of global warming. On the contrary, scientists believe that the leading factor behind Mt. Kilimanjaro’s snow recession can never be established easily. Some have argued that even if the ice decrease on this mountain can be seen as the result of global warming, other factors such as deforestation of the mountain’s foothills can be a major cause of that. For instance, the absence of forests’ humidity causes the ice to evaporate in the strong equatorial sunshine. Therefore, as much as global warming can be viewed as the main cause of ice loss, deforestation also contributes largely to this. More so, Gore argues that there is glaciers shrinking in Himalayan mountains as a result of global warming but reports reveal that glaciers are growing in the Himalayan Mountains contrary to Gore’s arguments. In his global warming documentary, Gore argues that global warming leads to more frequent and severe hurricanes. However, research findings state that hurricane activity has significantly reduced now as compared to the past. Studies reveal that major hurricanes have declined over the past. Hurricane scientists have confirmed that global warming enhances wind shear necessary for preventing any increase in future hurricane activity. Gore’s attribution of Hurricane Katrina devastation to global warming had no sufficient evidence and so was not approved by the judge. Moreover, Gore attributes the increasing cases of tornadoes to global warming but the truth is, there is never been any scientific connection developed between the two aspects. Accordingly, Gore claims Greenland and west Antarctic ice sheets are at risk of melting due to global warming which is likely to increase sea levels (Nielsen-Gammon 22). He argues that the rapid melting of Greenland (Anderson 37) as one effect of global warming is a threat as it can increase the level of the sea by twenty feet. However, studies state that the Greenland ice sheet is thinning at the margins and growing inland with a limited mass gain. Further, Gore argues that polar bears drowned while looking for icy habitats that were melted due to global warming. There was no convincing evidence developed to back this claim and so in the quest of determining whether Gore’s film should be shown in secondary schools, British high court revealed that the only drowned bears were four that died as a result of violent storm. Again, he proposed that there is an exact fit between an increase in the level of carbon dioxide and an increase in temperature for a long time now. However, it was found that scientist believe that there is an association between the two but they disagree with Gore’s claim of an exact fit. British High Court judges revealed Gore’s film was misleading since over that period, the level of carbon monoxide remained low as compared to that of temperature. Additionally, Gore’s film displayed the drying up of Lake Chad was due to global warming, but this was not proved to be the case because population increase, overgrazing, and regional climate variability was the major cause of this. Lastly, Gore attributes the melting of the Antarctic ice sheet to global warming (Anderson 37). This is not the case according to various reports Antarctica has been cooling for decades. It was noted that Gore’s claim of rapid rise in sea levels by melting icecaps was overly alarmist. According to this film, the sea level could rise to high levels forcing many individuals to be displaced. Scientists confirmed that there is indeed an expectation of the rise of the sea levels, however, no such massive displacement expected. More so, Gore’s claims of rising sea levels has been refused as he does not provide the time scale and the degree to which such sea levels are dangerous (Nielsen-Gammon 23). Truly, Gore has been acknowledged for creating public awareness of man-made global warming and has also explained to individuals which increased atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases causes warming. Gore’s film contributed to the explanation and understanding of global warming (Cochran 146). However, some experts have supported this film claiming that it follows the fundamental scientific requirement and that the minor factual mistakes do not interfere with what the film intends to communicate. They have argued that even though many inaccuracies and criticisms have been advanced against this documentary, it depicts necessary scientific information needed to explain the concept of global warming and its effects in the society. More so, this film had significant impact on individuals views on global warming and it helped in raising more public awareness on the global climate change as compared to other scientific reports. Gore’s film enabled individuals to know more about the nature, cause and the possible effects of global warming (Cochran 146). In conclusion, gore’s argument in his film An Inconvenient Truth has managed to create and raise public awareness on global warming but most of his claims have been refuted. Some of the criticisms that have been advanced against his film include the focus on human activities as the main cause of global warming and abandonment of natural causes of climate variability. More so, Gore argues that snowcap at the top of Mt. Kilimanjaro is shrinking as a result of global warming, but this has been not proved as true as scientist claim that the cause of snow recession on this mountain cannot be established. Other Gore’s arguments that have been criticized include the shrinking of Himalayan glaciers; hurricanes; more tornadoes, rapid meltdown Greenland and increase in sea levels, and the exact fit between carbon monoxide and temperature levels among others. Despite the presence of these many criticisms of Gore’s film, it has been acknowledged for its contribution in global warming and its focus on taking argent action to solve this societal problem. Works Cited Anderson, Dale. Al Gore: A Wake-Up Call to Global Warming. New York: Crabtree Pub, 2009. Print. Cochran, Clarke E. American Public Policy: An Introduction. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Cengage Learning, 2009. Print. Jackson, Robert J. Global Politics in the 21st Century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2013. Print. Nielsen-Gammon, John W. An Inconvenient Truth: The Scientific Argument. GeoJournal. 2007. Vol. 70, pp.21–26. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Gores Argument in an Inconvenient Truth Movie Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words - 2, n.d.)
Gores Argument in an Inconvenient Truth Movie Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words - 2. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1809755-critical-analysis-essay
(Gores Argument in an Inconvenient Truth Movie Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 2)
Gores Argument in an Inconvenient Truth Movie Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 2. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1809755-critical-analysis-essay.
“Gores Argument in an Inconvenient Truth Movie Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 2”. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1809755-critical-analysis-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Gores Argument in an Inconvenient Truth

Global Warming Is Not Pollution-Related - It Is Rather about Mass Genocide

nbsp; On the other hand, the argument that global warming may cause tropical cyclones to turn into more relentless is rooted in the supposition that sea level temperatures will boost as the atmosphere becomes warmer.... Again, the confirmation for this argument is vague....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Inconvinient truth: Analysis

This is proven, repeatedly, by an inconvenient truth.... The evidence is there, and is provided by Mr.... Gore.... For instance, Gore states that our world releases greenhouse gases into the atmosphere, and that these gases consist of… While some greenhouse gases are necessary to keep the earth warm, because, without them in the atmosphere, our earth would be too cool for life to be sustained, there are too many of these gases in the atmosphere....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

The Argument in An Inconvenient Truth Film by Davis Guggenheim

An The Argument in “an inconvenient truth” An incendiary documentary, “an inconvenient truth” is a film directed by Davis Guggenheim based on the multimedia presentation of former U.... an inconvenient truth).... an inconvenient truth).... an inconvenient truth).... “an inconvenient truth” is already problematic enough to be absorbed so offering a sound solution to it would be convenient towards the real change we need....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Response to the Film: An Inconvenient Truth

an inconvenient truth” is a documentary film directed by Davis Guggenheim, taking inspirations from the former United States Vice President Al Gores campaign against global warming.... No other films in the history of film making, has been successful as this film in educating… This paper is written as a response to the major themes of this film. The major theme of this movie is the climate changes caused by global warming....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Social Media as a Greatest Potential Threat to Humanity

The author of this paper claims that the world has become a global village that is a thought which transformed the current reality of the human race.... In the past, people were literally obsessed with nationalism that was bred by the ruthless philosophy of “realism”.... hellip; The time when nationalism was a leading way of life had been rated better than the current way of life by most of the philosophers....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

An Inconveniente truth

an inconvenient truth” opens the viewer's eyes on the one of the most important problems of the modern humanity – the global warming – and its influence on the planet and the future of humanity.... Going back, the first idea to measure carbon dioxide in the atmosphere was proposed by Roger “an inconvenient truth” of the Human's Progress “an inconvenient truth” opens the viewer's eyes on theone of the most important problems of the modern humanity – the global warming – and its influence on the planet and the future of humanity....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Evidentialism or Non-evidentialism

89) A decision that is right for a particular issue in a particular situation may not hold well in another situation as such William Clifford's argument for evidence-based approach has limitations and their implementation in real-life situations is impossibility whereas William James' faith-based arguments hold well.... 89) It is easy to make the argument that it is not lawful to terminate a doubt....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Gossips and Their Role in Human Life

The paper "Gossips and Their Role in Human Life" discusses that Eudora Welty's “Petrified Man” introduces females' gossips in their negative and even somewhat destructive for people's comfort character, which is only able to stimulate human mental activity.... hellip; By the example of Mrs....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us