StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Fair Value Accounting - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay 'Fair Value Accounting' is devoted to the theory of accounting in Australia, the factors influencing it, as well as the events that led to the slaughter of a change in the international market in the dimensions and standards of the financial paradigm that arose in the second half of the twentieth century…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
Fair Value Accounting
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Fair Value Accounting"

Fair Value Accounting Introduction In the second half of the 20th century, the financial environment had been strived with international market shiftin financial paradigm measurement and standards. Political and economic bodies such as the government, institutions, corporations and interest groups which are related to the financial market have been key players in shaping and formalizing accounting standards adopted today. While a lot of deliberation has been put into consideration for the current international accounting standards, the system is far from perfect. Financial instruments, disclosure systems, and measurement standards are still greatly debated despite their formal application. One such standard that has been much debated is the fair value accounting measure. Fair value accounting has gained popularity in the recent years as the standard for measuring assets and liabilities by firms. Although, fair value accounting has been accepted and adopted by firms across the world, it is still considered to be inefficient in its utility. Perhaps it is because of the discrepancy in the financial systems and conceptual frameworks which have given rise to the chaos that is evident in todays corporate environment. In the following discussion the researcher shall discuss the impact of fair value accounting and disclosures based on current accounting standards, conceptual frameworks and theoretical assumptions with the view to enumerate on its viability, utility and efficiency. Discussion International accounting standards are broadly divided into the United States’ independent regulators’ approach and the European public ownership approach. The European approach had been based on the theoretical framework that since corporations are usually serve their own profit interest, it is up to the government to curb private monopolies and monitor their activities. On the other hand the US independent commissions for monitoring and enforcing regulation had been developed with the view to give the market economic independency on the premise of laissez faire. Ironically, as Gaffikin (2005) points out, both the systems fail to achieve its objective of regulation as a result of market inefficiency and economic regulation consideration. This led to the development of a regulation system based on interest theory - that is serving both the private and public interests (Gaffikin 2005). Today, accounting standards across the world is based on the US Financial Accounting Standard Board and the International Accounting Standard Board. Australia follows similar measurement paradigms as adopted by the FASB and the IASB whereby the transaction and cost based accounting are being replaced by fair value accounting. Fair value accounting according to these standards is defined as "the amount for which an asset could be exchanged or a liability settled, between knowledgeable, willing parties in an arms length transaction." (Australian Accounting Standards Board 2007). This standard requires firms to disclose the value of assets and liabilities based on market’s fair value in an unbiased manner. However, fair value accounting is surrounded by controversies and criticisms as it relies on management decisions, expectations and projections of value; as well as market inefficiency in determining financial instruments and their values (Hitz 2007). Given the current convergence of accounting standards fair value is defined as "the price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date." (Hitz 2007). This definition takes into account of the fact that fair value is acquired under idealized market conditions or at least close to ideal market conditions. It also hypothesize that the parties involved are "knowledgeable, independent and economically rational parties." (Hitz, 2007). Moreover, Hitz (2007) also points out that fair value follows a three-tier hierarchy principle. The first tier involves market-based measure of prices, reliability of information and quality of market information on prices. The second tier involves the consideration of prices of comparable items and cash flows. In case these two tiers fail to comply, only then internal estimates and calculations should be taken into account. This is known as mark-to-model technique (Hitz, 2007). These theoretical assumptions, however, are flawed. According to Beaver (2002), application of accounting standards and techniques are based on market efficiency, value relevance, analysts behavior, discretionary behavior and Feltham-Ohlson modeling. Fair value accounting is largely dependent on market efficiency and its information flow. This premise is highly unreliable in its assumptions that the market is unbiased and efficient. Beaver (2002) points out that regulations make the assumption that firms are honest and willing to make accounting data public. While in practice disclosure is mandatory for all, the authenticity of the data and its presentation cannot be vouched for. This is clearly demonstrated in the recent cases of misinformation and disclosure manipulations of corporate America. Fair value accounting therefore cannot be relied upon for "fair" accounting and disclosures as it is based on unreliable information sources. Consequently, one can understand that fair value accounting rely holistically on equivocal market information and disclosure. This unreliability of information is against the premise of fair value accounting theoretical framework which is set on the paradigm of usefulness. According to Hitz (2002), fair value accounting is based on the decision usefulness paradigm. The objective of fair value accounting is to provide alternative measurement inferences to provide information to investors and decision makers to assess future cash flows from shares or securities. For this purpose, fair value accounting relies on the information aggregation hypothesis that market information is unbiased and is generally uniform for all items. While this premise, to some extent, is true when considered in the economic term, it is not really a reliable framework for reportage and information usage. Without quality and reliability in information, the utility of fair value diminishes. This is especially true in the case of financial instruments which rely on market information holistically such as fair value hedges, cash flow and net investment funds (Australian Accounting Standards Board 2007). These instruments rely on active market quoted prices for determining value for assessment and transactions. In Australia, if a financial instrument cannot be measured according to active market prices, then it would be measured using a valuation technique agreed by both knowledgeable parties. The valuation technique has not been specified by the Standard Board, but it has been noted that the technique should be commonly used by general financial entities. This technique should use maximum market inputs and rely least on entity specific inputs (Australian Accounting Standards Board 2007). What this does is further ensures the unreliability of information, especially if the market is inefficient. On the other hand, if the market is operating in idealized conditions, and it is efficient, then the chosen fair value accounting standard proves to be highly reliable for carrying out market transactions by entities which are already strived with distrust, uncertainties and risks. For example Beaver (2002) points out that market inefficiency is a common phenomenon, and reliability on market factors and information is naive. This is because portfolio strategies involve risks. Consequently, analysts and market leaders rely on market-to-book value ratios to model earnings forecasts. For these reasons, it is better to rely on a proxy fundamental valuation standard then to use overpriced or under priced stocks and attempt to value it at book value. With regard to the third tier information, fair value accounting may have to rely on internal inputs if the first two tiers are not available. This third tier is highly unreliable in terms of accounting information verification. Corporate history indicates general distrust among the government, corporations and the stakeholders. For these reasons independent institutions such as the IASB have been created to monitor and control individual firms, and curb them from irregularities. Despite these measures, financial crises and malpractices in reporting system continue to prevail. It is therefore safe to assume that corporations do not necessarily act in the interest of stakeholders. Instead, they often vie for opportunities to monopolize, disguise, and hinder information flow to misrepresent, and indirectly benefit from these activities. Profit skimming, free riders and information asymmetries according to Gaffikin (2005) are common in the corporate scenario. Regulations exist to curb these externalities from infringing on the stakeholders. Moral hazards exist in both formal and informal industries. Consequently, to rely on internal sources for fair value accounting purposes can be construed as ineffectual and inaccurate. While it may serve the purpose for one party in case of transaction (such as the seller) but it may not be useful for the other party (or parties) involved (such as the buyer). This is clearly evident in the rule for hedge instruments and cash flows transactions where revaluation for income is carried out at fair value but historical cost ceiling are also mandated to curtail abnormal returns (Hitz 2007) when carrying out fair value accounting. In such instances, regulations are mandatory for sustaining market efficiency, and to ensure all entities gain fairly from transactions. Fair value accounting regulations came into existence to address this type of chaotic and volatile financial environment of today. Fair value accounting is still at its rudimentary stages. With issues of reliability, disclosure methods, valuation techniques and so on plaguing fair value accounting standards, the practice is far from perfect. Since fair value is a disclosure regulation, it is not interventionist based (Gaffikin 2005). As a result, it largely relies on trends in accounting standards set by professional bodies or agencies. In Australia, where accounting standards follow international trends have to go through similar pitfalls of new regulations before it can perfect its implementation. Conclusion Regardless of these negative impacts, fair value has a significant impact on the measurement, information and decision usefulness accounting regulation. It is a transition standard which is slowly gaining respect and independence. Accounting problems and issues associated with corporate social responsibility in accounting disclosures will have to be modeled on an intermediary model of command and control, and self-regulation before fair value accounting standards can acquire its truest efficiency. Once perfected over its many flaws, eventually fair value accounting would have achieved its desired objective of providing a platform for financial accounting practice that is based on current information rather than on old or future financial information. This eliminates the critical issues of distrust, misinformation and risks involved in financial decision making activities. Lastly, fair value accounting may be developed to attain credibility through stricter regulations which can be achieved by independence of regulatory institutions. References Australian Accounting Standards Board (2007) Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement. Compiled Accounting Standard AASB 139. Beaver, W. H. (2002) Perspectives on Recent Capital Market Research. The Accounting Review, Vol. 77, No. 2, pp. 453-474. Gaffikin, M.J.R. (2005) Regulation as Accounting Theory. Working Papers Series, School of Accounting & Finance, University of Wollongong, Australia. Hitz, J. (2007) The Decision Usefulness of Fair Value Accounting - A Theoretical Perspective. European Accounting Review. 16:2 pp. 323 — 362 Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Fair Value Accounting Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
Fair Value Accounting Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1548571-accounting-theory-in-australia
(Fair Value Accounting Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Fair Value Accounting Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1548571-accounting-theory-in-australia.
“Fair Value Accounting Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1548571-accounting-theory-in-australia.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Fair Value Accounting

Relationship between Financial Markets and Neoliberalism

Fair Value Accounting” is an accounting method that forms part of the architecture of neoliberalism, embedding the broader ideological commitments of neoliberal globalization within accounting techniques. The Chinese accounting standard –ASBE 22: Recognition and… nt of Financial Instruments, which is equivalent to IAS 39: Financial Instruments, Recognition and Measurement –has brought about the most significant changes to Chinese listed companies' financial reporting since the introduction of the new CAS in 2007. A policy of Slide #2 (History) Lets have a glance at the history of accounting in People's Republic of China During its first decade, Soviet style fund accounting was implemented to support and sustain its communist political commitment....
1 Pages (250 words) PowerPoint Presentation

Fair Value Accounting, Financial Economics, and the Transformation or Reliability

Fair Value Accounting, financial economics and the transformation or reliability” explains how and why Fair Value Accounting gained a lot of significance before the financial crisis of 2007 despite the growing opposition against it.... The primary author of this paper, Michael… The paper was originally delivered as a lecture at Chartered Accountant's Hall London on 15th October 2009 with a title “Fair value: the influence of financial economics on The article concludes that four conditions necessitated the significance of Fair Value Accounting....
3 Pages (750 words) Literature review

Fair Values in Accounting for Financial Instruments

Therefore, Fair Value Accounting is a financial measurement of liabilities and assets of a company at fair value (Kemp, 2005, pp.... As a consequence of the synchronization of international accounting standards and additional disclosure requirements regarding risk and volatility, companies are changing from historical cost accounting to Fair Value Accounting.... Fair Value Accounting provides the users of financial statements present economic state of affairs of a company and presents a better manifestation of market values liabilities and assets, and consequently, the actual company's worth....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Fair-Value Accounting

This guidance is the same as US… IFRS 13 defines fair value and sets out a requirement about fair value measurement disclosures. Fair Value Accounting is an approach in financial accounting where firms are allowed or required to quantify and report an ongoing basis of the financial instruments at These are the estimates that they would get if they were to sell the financial instruments in this case assets and liabilities.... The guidance is provided on the way that fair value measurement should be undertaken but not when it should be adopted....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

A Fair Value Accounting System as a Critique for Its Applicability in the Market Present Conditions

The crisis had marked illiquidity in various financial markets including the market for financial assets which went… Financial institutions have lost billions when the fair value of certain securities dropped steeply and suddenly (Kotz, 2009). The paper is a discussion of the Fair Value Accounting system as a critique for its applicability in the present economic and accounting It compares and contrasts the Fair Value Accounting system with other measures like the historical cost accounting, replacement cost accounting and deprival value in the light of its contribution towards the occurrence or even increasing the severity of the recent financial crisis....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Fair Value Accounting

Many politicians and economists in Europe and the US had suggested removing the concept of fair value system of accounting and favoured historical cost accounting in which assets were generally valued at their original prices (Benston, 2008).... In order to critically analyze whether or not fair value system had any role to play in the financial crisis, it is important to first know about fair value system.... fair value system of accounting is that system where assets are valued at their market price....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Financial Crises and Fair Value Accounting

Prior to the financial crisis, the Fair Value Accounting method was adopted as a main part of the financial accounting reform process by the FASB and the IASB due to the evaluated benefits of the Fair Value Accounting methods over other accounting methods like historical cost,… But after the financial crisis, the opponents of the Fair Value Accounting method pointed out that the Fair Value Accounting method was one of the main factors which intensely fuelled the financial crisis....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Benefits and Drawback of Fair Value Accounting Measurement

Fair Value Accounting is the valuation guideline introduced by Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) for standardizing the fair value calculations of financial instruments.... According to the definition provided by International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), it is a… Fair Value Accounting principle was initiated in early 1990s, but the method was amended in 2006 after clarifications of all the bewilderments regarding the The accounting system demands an estimation of fair market value in order to demonstrate the present value of future cash flows (Penman, 2007)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us