StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of Outbreak of Varicella at a Day-Care Center Despite Vaccination Article by Galil Karin - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Analysis of Outbreak of Varicella at a Day-Care Center Despite Vaccination Article by Galil Karin" paper focuses on the article which relies on reports given by parents or physicians for diagnosis, thus leading to either overestimating or underestimating the effectiveness of the vaccine. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Analysis of Outbreak of Varicella at a Day-Care Center Despite Vaccination Article by Galil Karin
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of Outbreak of Varicella at a Day-Care Center Despite Vaccination Article by Galil Karin"

Kona Vishnu Critical Analysis 19 November 2005 Critical Analysis of "Outbreak of Varicella at a Day-Care Center Despite Vaccination" Galil Karin and et al. The New England Journal of Medicine in an article named "Outbreak of Varicella at a Day-Care Center Despite Vaccination" stated that "Although the vaccine affords excellent protection against moderate and severe Varicella, a modified form of Varicella develops in some vaccinated persons after exposure to someone with an infectious case. By definition, these breakthrough cases occur more than 42 days after vaccination and are usually caused by wild-type virus." This implies that a modified form of Varicella may develop in a vaccinated person on exposure to an infected case and the effectiveness of vaccine is only for 42 days and also the infection may be due to a wild-type virus, thus defeating the very purpose of inoculation. Further the article states "To date, there is no evidence of an increase over time in the rate of breakthrough disease that would suggest waning immunity after vaccination." Then why does a person get infected after 42 days (though mildly) In the case definition it is stated "We defined a case of natural Varicella as an illness involving a pruritic, maculopapulovesicular rash with no other apparent cause beginning from December 1, 2000, through January 11, 2001, in a child attending the day-care center who had not received Varicella vaccine or who had been vaccinated less than 14 days before the onset of rash. Breakthrough disease was defined as Varicella in a child who had been vaccinated more than 42 days before the onset of rash." Varicella here is defined in two ways first is natural Varicella and the second is Breakthrough disease, but what is the exact definition Is it that the second version is advanced form of Varicella infection or failure of the vaccine In the statistical analysis "The effectiveness of the vaccine against moderate-to-severe disease was calculated by classifying mild cases as noncases." First and foremost it is not understood as to why children less then 12 months age and children with history of Varicella disease are not considered (numbering 18 children) And how could the mild cases be considered as noncases and ignored Everywhere in the paper stress is laid on the boys, why What about girls Is the Varicella disease restricted to only boys In the Investigations on Index Case section it is stated "His only known exposure to Varicella-zoster virus was contact with an 11-year-old sister who did not attend the day-care center and who had herpes zoster (confirmed by Tzanck testing)." Point to be noted here is that the index patient was in contact with his sister, who was already infected by herpes zoster and not by Varicella zoster as stated in the article. Did this contact have any effect on already Varicella inoculated index patient The index patient though vaccinated earlier has become a carrier in this case. In the outbreak section it is stated that the effect on 17 vaccinated cases were mild and in 8 unvaccinated cases was moderate or severe out of a total 25 cases and no infants or children with a history of Varicella disease were reported. The section further states that "No child had a severe complication of Varicella or required hospitalization. As compared with unvaccinated children, those who had been vaccinated had milder disease, had new lesions on fewer days, had rash that crusted more quickly, missed fewer days of day care, and were less likely to have fever." Here the table indicates that vaccinated cases were marginally better over unvaccinated cases. In the risk for vaccine failure section it is stated Two continuous variables - time since vaccination and age at vaccination - were associated with the risk of vaccine failure. Children vaccinated three or more years before the start of the outbreak had more than twice the risk of disease found among those vaccinated within three years before the outbreak. Age at vaccination did not remain significantly associated with vaccine failure when it was dichotomized into vaccination at less than 14 months of age and vaccination at older ages. Firstly it implies that the vaccine is effective only for a period of three years. But the article contradicts this fact in the earlier paragraphs. Secondly it is not discussed any where regarding age at which the vaccine is to be administered and children below 12 months were not considered for statistical analysis at all. In the discussion part it is reported that "The cumulative attack rate among unvaccinated, susceptible children 12 months of age or older was approximately 86 percent in Building A and 9 percent in Building B. The low attack rate in Building B suggests that most children in this building were never exposed to Varicella." It is stated that the transmission of virus is through air and the two buildings in question are only 20 yards apart, then the results could be expected to be atleast consistent to some extent, but on the contrary the results are quiet different and not convincing. The article relies on reports given by parents or physicians for diagnosis, thus leading to either overestimating or underestimating the effectiveness of vaccine, further the article states that "the small number of children in the day-care center limited our ability to explore the independent effects of the time since vaccination and the age at vaccination in multivariate analyses." Hence the results cannot be totally relied on. The results ought to have been taken by laboratory testing and not through parents or physicians feedbacks. With all the contradictions it is reported that "Although the vaccine provided suboptimal protection against Varicella in this outbreak, it provided robust protection against moderate and severe Varicella and has reduced the incidence of Varicella dramatically in the United States. Given the approximately 11,000 hospitalizations and 100 deaths due to Varicella that occurred annually in the era before vaccination, vaccination remains the most effective strategy for protecting children and adults against illness and death due to Varicella." To conclude I feel that the effectiveness of vaccine formulation in question is doubtful and not 100%. Works Cited Galil Karin, M.D., M.P.H., Brent Lee, M.D., M.P.H., Tara Strine, M.P.H., Claire Carraher, R.N., Andrew L. Baughman, Ph.D., M.P.H., Melinda Eaton, D.V.M., Jose Montero, M.D., and Jane Seward, M.B., B.S., M.P.H. "Outbreak of Varicella at a Day-Care Center despite Vaccination." The New England Journal of Medicine Volume 347:1909-1915 December 12, 2002 Number 24. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical Analysis of Outbreak of Varicella at a Day-Care Center Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1528152-critical-analysis-of-outbreak-of-varicella-at-a-day-care-center-despite-vaccination-galil-karin
(Critical Analysis of Outbreak of Varicella at a Day-Care Center Essay)
https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1528152-critical-analysis-of-outbreak-of-varicella-at-a-day-care-center-despite-vaccination-galil-karin.
“Critical Analysis of Outbreak of Varicella at a Day-Care Center Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1528152-critical-analysis-of-outbreak-of-varicella-at-a-day-care-center-despite-vaccination-galil-karin.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of Outbreak of Varicella at a Day-Care Center Despite Vaccination Article by Galil Karin

Verucella vaccine

(Verucella vaccine) vaccination Introduction vaccination is the deliberate introduction of pathogenic compounds that are either attenuated or inactivated.... Vaccines have been widely used to contain various infections world wide, Vericella vaccine being one of them that has been used to provide protection against a viral infection; chickenpox, postherpetic neuralgia and Herpes zoster....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Pros and Cons of Not Vaccinating Your Child

vaccination against the highly prevalent infectious diseases is necessary to protect the individual from acquiring the disease and eradicating the disease from the whole community as well as stopping its further transmission.... Many goals of eradicating particular infectious diseases have been attained by mass vaccination programs.... In 1980, the WHO eradicated small-pox worldwide by a mass vaccination program.... In 1988, WHO, resolved to eradicate poliomyelitis by vaccination....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Childhood Vaccinations and Immunizations

A paper "Childhood Vaccinations and Immunizations" outlines that the importance of vaccination can never be downplayed given the fact that it has been effective in fighting certain diseases.... The first formal vaccination for adults was introduced in the year 2002.... As compared to treatment, vaccination is usually safe....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Measles Outbreak and the Centre for Disease Control

hat began as an outbreak of measles among seven people, who in December visited Disneyland, has The unvaccinated women from California transmitted the virus in theme parks and Airports (Gastañaduy, et al.... Four days later, on January 7th, health officials in California announced an outbreak of measles (Jin, 2015).... This article would examine measles, its main source, and the issues that cause it and develop a campaign to address its issue. ...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Chicken Pox Vaccination Controversy

This essay "Chicken Pox vaccination Controversy" examines the issue of whether it should be mandatory for parents to vaccinate their children against life-threatening diseases such as chicken-pox.... The paper seeks to analyze the data provided about the chicken-pox vaccination and its effectiveness.... The reported attitudes and reactions of parents to vaccination will be examined.... The varicella vaccine was approved in 1995 by the US Food and Drug Administration....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Immunization in Childhood Prevents Vaccine-Preventable Infectious Diseases

This research aims to identify causes of refusal or hesitancy to vaccination of children by parents so that implications can be made as what is the best clinician approach towards parents who refuse to vaccinate their children.... For the purpose of this research, articles were retrieved from PUBMED and discussion of findings were done, based on which it is concluded that it is important for health professionals, especially pediatricians and pediatric nurses, to educate parents about the safety and efficacy of vaccination....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Cuba and USA Vaccination Programs

The article written by Wakefield was retracted after his claims were proved wrong and malicious (Brumback, 2009).... The paper "Cuba and USA vaccination Programs" states that Cuba has been able to succeed in vaccination programs as compared to developed countries such as the USA.... Developed countries such as the USA have been able to eliminate measles by vaccination and cases of Rubella are almost nonexistent.... The medical establishment has a number of tools to deal with contagious diseases; one of the most efficient instruments to address these diseases such as measles and others is a chart of vaccination....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Poliomyelitis Outbreak in Syria as a Historical Outbreak of Global Health Importance

The paper "Poliomyelitis Outbreak in Syria as a Historical outbreak of Global Health Importance" is a good example of a term paper on health sciences and medicine.... The paper "Poliomyelitis Outbreak in Syria as a Historical outbreak of Global Health Importance" is a good example of a term paper on health sciences and medicine.... Political instabilities also jeopardize response activities to any outbreak of Polio thus providing it with the ideal conditions for spreading rapidly with minimal chances for detection....
17 Pages (4250 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us