StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The case of Susan - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The patient in question was a Turkish lady named Susan, who came to England as a refugee with her husband and three children, now aged 9,6 and 4 respectively. She found herself alone after her husband committed suicide a year ago…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
The case of Susan
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The case of Susan"

The case of Susan Introduction: The patient in question was a Turkish lady d Susan, who came to England as a refugee with her husband and three children, now aged 9,6 and 4 respectively. She found herself alone after her husband committed suicide a year ago. Thereafter she moved in with a friend in Kent where there is Kurdish community from her village in Turkey. She began to develop mental problems such as panic attacks and was treated with anti depressants as a temporary patient. Two months later, she was treated again after overdosing herself on tablets. A few weeks later, her friend communicated her inability to continue to accommodate her and she is now living in a lodge with her children while the local council is arranging housing for her. Her children do not go to school and she has been referred to the mental health trust, where I have been one of the persons assigned to perform a mental health evaluation with the help of an interpreter. Legal aspects to be considered in Susan’s case: As a refugee, Susan does not yet have the legal status necessary for employment. The curtailment of the right to freedom of movement and employment places her in a legally indeterminate state, ridden with anxiety, especially since legalizing residence has been refused arbitrarily in some cases (Amnesty International, 2004). Since 2003, with the introduction of Section 55 of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002, many claims of refugees for asylum have been rejected under this provision, on the grounds of delay in filing their claim for asylum, thereby leaving them destitute (Williams, 2004). Although Susan, being a refugee as defined in the 1951 UN refugee convention, may be entitled to remain in the UK for a provisional, limited five year period; however permanent residence is not guaranteed since it is to be evaluated on a case by case basis (House of Commons, 2005). These changes have been implemented as of 30th August, 2005 and have proved to be detrimental to the mental health of refugees, since they generate high levels of anxiety with placement remaining indefinite. According to the Medical Foundation for the Care of Victims of Torture (2003), there is a high level of risk of suicidal tendencies among refugees. There have been five Directives introduced in Europe, including the Reception Directive which ensures that refugees receive necessary health care, especially emergency treatment (Anonymous, 2005). However, with the increasing strain placed on the health care system in the UK and the perceived abuse of the system by refugees, new proposals introduced by the Government are regulating the provision of free secondary health care services and withdrawing it for those refugees whose asylum bid has failed (Hargeraves et al, 2005). Only infectious diseases are still freely treated. Further legislative moves have also begun to restrict welfare benefits for refugees and asylum seekers which could pose further risks to the health and psychological wellbeing of refugees by forcing them to live in poor conditions (Tribe, 2005). All of these aspects would also apply in the case of Susan. However, I have found some difficulties in my efforts to discover how well informed Susan is about her legal status and the status of her application for permanent residence. The reason is that I have to work through an interpreter and find it difficult to discuss such sensitive issues that involve issues of confidentiality and legality. Therefore, it is difficult for me to assess the extent to which Susan’s indeterminate legal status may be impacting negatively on her mental health, especially since her husband is also dead and her friend has now denied her shelter as well. Social Aspects: In Susan’s case, it appears likely that her mental condition and panic attacks may be closely related to delayed bereavement for her husband and the resulting anxieties (Burnett and Peel, 2001), especially since she has three children to support. Social isolation is also likely in her case, especially since her friend is no longer able to support her at her residence. Research has also shown that to a large extent, it is the stressors in the environment that may be responsible for psychiatric and psychological disorders in refugees (Vega et al, 1987) and since Susan has been persistently experiencing attacks of depression, there is a strong indication that her mental state is being severely affected by the trauma in her life in the past year. Bach et al (1982) have highlighted the proclivity of refugees to experience mental problems because of the problems they may have experienced in their home country and the tortuous conditions that they may have run away from. It appears that Susan is suppressing memories that may be causing her pain, however it has been difficult thus far to get her to speak about them and relive her mind of the anxiety and pain that she may have experienced. The pain of her husband’s death may also be festering in her mind, however the intensely personal nature of the problem seems to make it difficult for Susan to communicate these problems, even to the interpreter who is also from her own country. Issues of trust appear to play a significant role in Susan’s case, and it is possible that her already shaky trust in a new land and people may have been further eroded by the rejection of her friend who had supported her for so many months. As Meucke (1992) has stated, refugees have often faced fear and oppression, lies and deception from those they trust in their home land. They may have learnt to lie and hide their true feelings and views, for fear of being exploited or persecuted on account of those views and vulnerabilities. I have found this to be a huge problem in Susan’s case and it appears that her trust has taken a beating, so that she is not comfortable confiding in anyone. Added to the trauma that she has already experienced while fleeing her country, the loss of her husband and the support of her friend have further reduced her willingness to trust and share her fears and worries, and health problems so that they can be effectively treated. I have also found the inability to communicate in Susan’s language a big barrier, since language is so intimately associated with cultural norms. A study by Shah and Priestly (2001) revealed the lack of cultural sensitivity of health care services, especially where the needs of Muslim and Asian patients was concerned. This has been a difficult issue to deal with, since Susan’s inability to communicate freely could be linked to inadvertent cultural insensitivity of the team that is treating her. Ethical issues: One of the most difficult issues in dealing with Susan has been the question of ethics and confidentiality of her health issues. Since our team is working through interpreters, there is a great deal of uncertainty about how exactly to ensure that confidential medical information pertaining to Susan’s condition is not made available to other parties through the involvement of the interpreter. Since the interpreters are not professional health providers, it is difficult for them to conceive of the legal and ethical implications of patient-provider confidentiality. Although every effort has been made to ensure that interpreters are made to understand the ethical issues involved, there is still uncertainty attached to this aspect. Moreover, it has also been difficult to secure the services of the same interpreter each time while dealing with Susan, and this has only compounded the problems. The difficulties and limitations associated with using such ad hoc interpreters have also been highlighted by Putsch (1985:3344-48). Article 8 of the European Convention of Human Rights also mandates the protection of the privacy of individuals, and this places a legal and ethical duty upon interpreters never to disclose confidential health information. However, under the ad hoc circumstances we are working with, no such guarantees can be ensured. Moreover, the question of mental health care involves complex decisions about health care where Susan’s individual autonomy is involved (Austen et al, 2005), therefore the difficulties in communication have proved to be a very thorny problem. The element of trust is vital in the relationship between a health care provider and a patient and obtaining informed consent for treatment is a vital aspect.(Putsch, 1985). Conclusion: On an overall basis, I would rate the linguistic problem as being the greatest difficulty in treating this patient. If I had been conversant with her language and cultural norms, I feel it would have been far easier for her to build trust enough to communicate her problems freely. Moreover, it appears that in Susan’s case, there is also a great load of trauma that she is carrying in her mind, through a series of tragic events, including the suicide of her husband and what she may perceive as the betrayal of her friend through her failure to support her. Moreover, using interpreters on an ad hoc basis and having to communicate through them is the most difficult aspect of all because it does not provide for that one on one contact which can be so informative for a health care provider. This is not a problem I would face with a family that knows English, since it would be easier to slowly build the levels of trust necessary for the patient to discuss her problems for effective treatment dispersal. References: * Amnesty International, 2004. “Get it Right: How Home Office Decision Making Fails Refugees”. London: Amnesty International. * Anonymous, 2005. “Refugee health: Questions for a new Commissioner.” The Lancet, 365 (9467): 1281. * Austen, Garwood-Gowers, Tingle, John and Wheat, Kay, 2005. “Ethical Practice: Contemporary issues in health care law and ethics.” Elsevier. * Bach, Robert L, Bach, Jennifer B and Triplett, Timothy, 1982. “The ‘flotilla’ entrants: Latest and most controversial.” Cuban Studies, 11: 29-48 * Burnett A and Peel M, 2001. “Asylum seekers and refugees in Britain: health needs of asylum seekers and refugees”. British Medical Journal , 322:544-547 * Hargreaves, Sally, Holmes, Alison and Friedland, Jon S, 2005. “Charging failed asylum seekers for health care in the UK.” The Lancet, 365 (9461):732-33 * House of Commons Hansard (2005) “Written Ministerial Statement for 19 July 2005”. Immigration. Column 67WS. London: TSO. * London Assembly and Mayor of London, 2003. “Access to primary care: A joint London Assembly and Mayor of London Scrutiny Report.” London: Greater London Authority. * Medical Foundation for the Care of Victims of Torture (2003). “Suicide in Asylum seekers and Refugees”. London: Medical Foundation for the Care of Victims of Torture. * Putsch, RW, 1985. “Cross cultural communication: the special case of interpreters in health care.” Journal of the American Medical Association, 254: 3344-3348 * Shah, Sonali and Priestly, Mark, 2001. “Better services: Better Health: the healthcare experiences of black and minority ethnic disabled people” [online] available at: http://www.leeds.ac.uk/disability-studies/projects/healthcare/LIPfinalreport.pdf * Tribe, Rachel, 2005. “The mental health needs of refugees and asylum seekers.” The Mental Health review, 10(4):8-16 * Williams, Lucy, 2004. “Refugees and asylum seekers as a group at risk of adult abuse.” The Journal of Adult Protection, 6(4): 4-16 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The case of Susan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
The case of Susan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1539391-the-case-of-susan
(The Case of Susan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
The Case of Susan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1539391-the-case-of-susan.
“The Case of Susan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1539391-the-case-of-susan.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The case of Susan

Relationship Therapy

Tom and susan are an elderly couple, but they have different bio-mechanical activities going on that the therapist needs to realize.... Sexually, Tom is waning, while susan may even be waxing in terms of her appetites.... There are many issues in this case, because there are also psychological changes and factors going on with Tom and susan's retirements.... There are specific issues to Tom's sexual performance during late adulthood which are more complicated for him, than for susan....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Human resources case study

The change in trend and the increased reliance on performance appraisal results has changed the focus of the process towards team building, employee… It has therefore become apparent that the appraisal process needs the input of more than one player.... The multiple input strategy of performance appraisal otherwise referred to as the 360 degrees assessment brings on board the input of peers, This method does not require that all these sources be included but the more they are the better....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Who Creates the Schools Vision

5), school visioning is a collective responsibility of the school and the community and the role of an ideal principal is often to merely facilitate the vision of their schools by collecting pertinent data, identifying the case#6: Who Creates the School's Vision?... As seen in the case study, Susan is seen alluding to a community culture means she is indirectly calling to attention the important of the beliefs, values as well as the collective thoughts of those who belonged to the broader community of the school....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Westco Enterprises Personal and Organisational Consequences

In Westco's case, the two individuals affected, susan Thompson and Oscar Hernandez, both face discrimination against for factors outside inherent of their being.... susan Thompson, a 48-year-old single mother, is on the receiving end because of her sexuality and age....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

The Issues of Employment Law

The voluntary resignation of susan may have grave repercussions for the company as the said employee has several valid reasons to file the claim in the employment tribunal under more than one clause.... For example, susan who is being criticized by the center manager publicly who finally demotes her to Assistant head of the department, without decreasing her salary.... susan, the said employee is a bonafide employee, employed under the contract of employment as head of the marketing department....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Principles of Criminal Law

In the case of Barton v.... In the paper “Principles of Criminal law” the author discusses the criminal liability of susan.... susan had stolen a DVD from the stores and while leaving with the stolen goods under her jacket, she was caught by a store detective.... In this case, it could be said that while actus rea is present when susan steals the DVD, the men's rea is not present, since she did not voluntarily have the will or intention to commit the theft....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Business Law: Contracts

The author examines the 3-year agreement signed in between the Susan Glass and the managers and concludes that all the facts presented in the case, it appears that the offeror, breached the contract by dishonestly concealing some material facts about her then current contracts with the managers … Susan's case presents a typical example of how contracts can are entered into between two parties.... It is an agreement between one party, susan Glass, who offers to contract services to the other party, Spock/Noglass management to manage her acting and music industries by training and offering consultancy services  First, both the offeror and the offeree have the contractual capacity to contract as noted from their age and the nature of the contract in this case....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Good Leadership Enhances the Success of an Organization

From the case, one can deduce that the conflict between professionalism and democracy result in loss of time as well as a crop of disagreement (“The Principal's Vision” page 222, Lines 13-19).... s outlined in the case, the committee members grant Susan the opportunity of exploiting her potentials.... s a leader, susan believes it is good to incorporate every persons' ideas in coming up with amicable decisions concerning some pressing issues....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us