StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Civil Right vs. National Security : Padilla/Hamdi vs. Rumsfeld - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
Civil Rights vs. National Security Case Study Padilla/ Hamdi vs. Rumsfeld [Full name] [Student Registration Number] Introduction Since the compromise of national security witnessed during the September 11 attacks on US soil, tough measures to counter terrorism continue to find their way in national security policies inside and outside the country…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.4% of users find it useful
Civil Right vs. National Security Case Study: Padilla/Hamdi vs. Rumsfeld
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Civil Right vs. National Security : Padilla/Hamdi vs. Rumsfeld"

Download file to see previous pages

Questions on the legality of the government’s actions in countering terrorism emerge in the form of compromise on civil rights and liberties that the constitution is strongly vocal in guarantee. In several cases before the courts, the federal government has been found in contravention of the provisions of the constitution, which raises questions on the practicality of providing national security without compromising civil rights (Picarelli 1). In the following discourse, two cases before the courts facilitate in the illustration of the difficulty of implementing some of the most decorated milestones that country boasts of in countering terrorism.

Padilla v. Rumsfeld and Hamdi v. Rumsfeld took place in the similar period when the US was facing the aftermath of the September 11 attacks and the nation was enforcing Authorization of the Use of Military Force Act, with a series of court battles on infringement of constitutional rights. Case Summary and Facts Padilla v. Rumsfeld Jose Padilla, a US national serving in the US military operations in Pakistan during the period when 11 September 2001 terrorist attack occurred and he was taken in as a material witness.

The arrest was dramatic since it took place as Padilla stepped off his flight from Pakistan on 8 May 2002, with the federal warrant of arrest for a material witness acting as the legal explanation. Details of the arrest changed and the applicant was suddenly facing charges of acting as an Al Qaeda agent. Legal position for his incarceration advanced from a material witness to “enemy combatant” and the federal government found reason for treatment of the applicant as any terrorist warranting the firmest action from the federal government such as indefinite imprisonment.

It implied that the applicant could not access legal rights provided for in the Constitution while the government held the opinion that he was such a high profile threat to America’s national security (Baird, Darmer and Rosenbaum 264). Six months after his incarceration, his attorney made an application for habeas corpus in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York which was declined on the grounds of the authority of the president to execute the “enemy combatant” principle.

As such, the court found that the war on terror was still an issue and that the court could not allow the application as it would compromise the federal government efforts to counter terrorism on American soil. The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit subsequently received the appeal that found the decision of the District Court improper. The held that despite the commander-in-chief having such powers as exercised in the case, such treatment could not be meted on Americans incarcerated on American soil.

Such transfer of charges from civilian to military authority without access to legal resources infringed on the constitutional rights. In the court’s ruling, Padilla was released but only from military authority to civilian custody. The case proceeded to the United States Supreme Court for determination of the matter if the Authorization for Use of Military Force from Congress was an applicable as the circumstances of the case proved. In the appeal, the matter before court

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Civil Right vs. National Security Case Study: Padilla/Hamdi vs Study”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1401535-padilla-vs-rumsfeld-hamdi-vs-rumsfeld
(Civil Right Vs. National Security Case Study: Padilla/Hamdi Vs Study)
https://studentshare.org/history/1401535-padilla-vs-rumsfeld-hamdi-vs-rumsfeld.
“Civil Right Vs. National Security Case Study: Padilla/Hamdi Vs Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1401535-padilla-vs-rumsfeld-hamdi-vs-rumsfeld.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Civil Right vs. National Security Case Study: Padilla/Hamdi vs. Rumsfeld

General Synopsis of Organizational Strategy

Amongst numerous organizations that exercise the processes of strategic management, Utica national is an organization that provides its customers with the insurance services and products and is one of the good models that practice the strategic management processes in an appropriate way.... Utica national is an insurance group that dates back to early twentieth century that comprises of several companies namely Utica Mutual Insurance Company and Graphic Arts Mutual Insurance Company came under establishment as its principal companies....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

National Interests Vs Human Interests in Takastand

This paper “National Interests vs Human Interests in Takastand” aims to plan the international conference for the human security problems in State.... This paper aims to plan the international conference for the human security problems in State through following three steps: Economic: Economic stability and long term sustenance plays the most vital role in bringing peace and prosperity to a nation (Strauss-Kahn).... These issues should be tackled through ensuring complete implementation of democracy by allowing different political parties to acquire same status in the national and provisional assemblies....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

International Relations in Saudi Arabia

hellip; Freedom, justice, peace, security, social welfare, and orderliness play a modest role in motivating citizens of a country and even winning the confidence of the foreign states.... The reasons for low levels of security range from frequent active Protests demanding to air their grievances to the government (Al-Ahmadi 2011).... The security forces had to deal with armed Protestants in the early protests.... Another recent big blow to help fight the war against insecurity in Saudi Arabia surfaced when the government turned down the chance to take up membership in the United Nations security Council....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Human Resource Management in the Knowledge Economy

In contemporary society, many women are still suffering from escalating level of discriminations that seem illegal when they are pregnant and more often than not lose their jobs altogether when they are on maternity leave.... Figures in many polls such as ones conducted by Research… Other get cut in work hours, demotion or just replaced by the person who was covering for them (Sims et al....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Why Barilla Has an Increased Supply Chain Variability

Also, it will eliminate the inventory problems of retailers as they will receive goods at the right time and they will not have to deal with problems of lacking given products that the customer need.... Founded as a small shop in Parma, Italy, by Pietro Barilla, Barilla is by far the largest Pasta manufacturer in the world....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Homeland Security of the US

In response to the attacks of September 11, 2001, President Bush authorized the national security Agency (NSA) to conduct warrantless surveillance on international communications into or out of the U.... The paper "Homeland security of the US" describes that the DHS works with the U.... The DHS also works with the country's economic and industrial sectors to develop a range of vulnerability assessment tools to meet their unique security challenges....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

National Security Agency

This work called "national security Agency" focuses on a cryptanalysis agency NSA used by the US government for protection towards the state's security information.... hellip; The mission of the agency is to take the challenge of preventing access to sensitive information concerning the security of the nation by foreigners.... The agency uses signals of intelligence to collect, process, destroy from foreign signals so as to protect the defense operations of the military The agency as well helps the Network Warfare Operations in defeating terrorists and all their organizations, alongside upholding US laws and protecting the privacy and civil liberties (the United States 1)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

International Law and National Security

Argument: Realism is the most useful theory when dealing with cases of international security: The case of nuclear proliferation in AsiaArgument: Realism is the most useful theory when dealing with cases of international security: The case of nuclear proliferation in Asia  Realism is predominantly the most useful theory, especially when dealing with cases of international security.... The theory does not apply in a complex dependency model where transnational characters move across borders and form coalitions that do not have a national definition (Hassler, 2013, p....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us