StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

John Locke vs. Jean-Jacques Rousseau - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Class Professor Date Word count excluding title and reference: 845 John Locke versus Jean-Jacques Rousseau If John Locke (1632-1704) and Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712–1778) will run for President in the 2012 Presidential election, people, most especially students like me will have a better understanding about the underlying principles why government are formed and appreciate governance better…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
John Locke vs. Jean-Jacques Rousseau
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "John Locke vs. Jean-Jacques Rousseau"

Download file to see previous pages

The differences of these two great political thinkers stems on how they assessed the evolution of society. Locke’s perspective begins with man’s natural state of being free but this freedom does not mean imposing itself over another (Chapter V). Eventually, people form society and to best protect them and their property, they have to submit to a government that will enforce a certain standard of behavior that will benefit everybody. For Locke government is good for everybody. Rousseau differed from Locke as he likened the natural state of man to that of a beast and differs only with his perfectibility or capacity to improve himself.

Rousseau theory of man’s formation of society is unhealthy because it induces the people to have a new need that will make them compare to others eventually leading to a dominance of certain people over another. To avoid conflict, the prevailing class proposed to have some sort of body politic. Those who are powerless accept this believing that this will provide them freedom and safety when in fact will only make inequality more permanent by the establishment of laws. In a way, Rousseau can be said to be a precursor of Karl Marx’s socialist idea of class conflict that is precipitated by inequality in society.

Locke on the other hand is the precursor of the modern idea of democracy because his theory of government in his Second Treatise of the Government  that puts forth the sovereignty of the people who chose to establish it to serve them is the same concept that we have now about democracy. His other ideas about government that it derives its sovereignty from the people that government by itself has no sovereignty and the people has the right to abolish it if it no longer serves its purpose and replace it with one that serves its purpose is the same idea that we have about democracy.

Just like Rousseau, Locke also anticipated that the acquisition of property will lead into conflict. They only differ in perspective as Locke thought that the establishment of body politic would best protect them by enforcing laws for certain standard of behavior while Rousseau thought that it will make inequality more permanent. If their treatises will be translated into platform of government, Locke would likely be more appropriate to America’s neo-liberal political orientation that man is basically free and only agreed to establish a strong government for everybody’s good.

This is consistent with American’s value system and being such, it is very likely that Locke will win if he will run against Rousseau in America. With regard to policy direction, Locke is likely to oppose Obama’s Health Care Program as it infringes on the property of other who have to subsidize those who cannot afford it. Locke’s puts a primacy on private property and the idea of subsidizing others might not sit well with him. Locke would also likely to strengthen business by introducing laws that would protect it and its property.

Rousseau treatise on the other hand would be incompatible with America’s value system but he would make an interesting case. As he is oppose to inequality, Rousseau will likely introduce government programs that will bridge his perceive inequality in American

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“John Locke vs. Jean-Jacques Rousseau Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1442814-john-locke-versus-jean-jacques-rousseau
(John Locke Vs. Jean-Jacques Rousseau Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/history/1442814-john-locke-versus-jean-jacques-rousseau.
“John Locke Vs. Jean-Jacques Rousseau Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1442814-john-locke-versus-jean-jacques-rousseau.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF John Locke vs. Jean-Jacques Rousseau

Locke and Rousseau on Social Contract

The Social Contract: According to John Locke and jean-jacques rousseau Locke's Social Contract As a political philosopher, Locke believes that humans have their own will and thus capable of making their own judgment.... This finding as proposed by john locke may have contributed to the present understanding of filial relationship.... According to him, humans have decided to form the society as it is not good for them to be alone in battling the challenges of life (locke 253)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Notion of Social Contract by J.J. Rousseau

hellip; “jean-jacques rousseau was born to Isaac Rousseau and Suzanne Bernard in Geneva on June 28, 1712.... Ever since his time, those who considered themselves reformers have been divided into two groups, those who followed him and those who followed john locke, an English... Jean Jaques rousseau's Social Contract “Almost everything in rousseau's writings is the subject of debate.... But one of the points which commands universal agreement is that rousseau set out to propound a theory of a just political order or, to use a phrase which reflects his intention, the doctrine of the “well ordered society”....
22 Pages (5500 words) Essay

The Concept Of Property In The Philosophy Of The Enlightenment

hellip; john locke is considered one of the precursors of American democracy, and his political concept is based predominantly upon social contract theory and natural rights of human beings.... john locke is considered one of the precursors of American democracy, and his political concept is based predominantly upon social contract theory and natural rights of human beings.... Talking of freedom as the natural condition for all the citizens of his ideal state, john locke stated that the main natural right of people (the right of property) should necessarily be secured using legal regulations, so that no conflicts arise....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Jean Jacques Rousseau: The Natural Inequality

The very smoothness of social polish, which in rousseau's view derives mainly from intellectual refinement, is, therefore, an obstacle to true social cohesion and integration; and although this mistrust is doubtless born of his own concept of Natural Inequality, it is something which he never abandons, but tends rather to ascribe to all men.... Refusing to consider the opposite point of view, rousseau now puts this idea forward as his major thesis.... rousseau stated that the state of nature is disorganized and chaotic, there is still a semblance of order and organization....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Political Philosophy: Jean-Jacques Rousseau's Social Contract Theory

The author of the paper examines rousseau's contract theory that proposes that the people forfeit some rights to a governing body in order to receive the psychologically important feeling of stability in the form of social order through the rule of law.... hellip; Civil society, for rousseau, is based on convention.... The problem with rousseau's Social Contract, and with his consent theory, in particular, is that it seems to prescribe the complete opposite of what rousseau's assumptions about human nature, and the state of instinct, would necessitate....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Can Rousseau plausibly be described as a totalitarian democrat

Jean Jacques rousseau has been a significant and accepted name that advocated totalitarian democracy.... In addition, Jean Jacques rousseau has been a prominent name and one of the greatest figures in the history of the French Enlightenment as he was one of the popular French philosophers whose ideas and thoughts persuaded the French Revolution.... In addition, more than just being a philosopher, Jean Jacques rousseau has also gained a prominent name as an author/novelist, painter, political and educational theorist/philosopher, musicologist, and composer....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Equality and inequality in Political Theories

john locke, (1632 – 1704) an English philosopher, in his book titled ‘Second Treatise of Government' (Locke, 1980) gives us insightful information on one of the most sought after and debated topics, the importance of equality and inequality within the framework of his… Rousseau, another eminent political theorist, highlights the importance of equality and inequality and how it impacts society, in his book titled ‘The Basic Political Writings' (Rousseau.... 1987) In this essay, we attempt to articulate and critically analyze the ncepts of both the theorists Locke and rousseau and try to have a better understanding of these important concepts and how to incorporate them into society to ensure a better standard of life....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Jean Jacques Rousseaus Social Contract

The paper "Jean Jacques rousseau's Social Contract" discusses that rousseau held the position that all citizens should be involved in voting for government leaders.... nbsp; rousseau took the opportunity while his friend was having an epileptic seizure to slip away through the crowd and abandon his traveling mate.... rdquo;  rousseau's mother died only a few days later on July 7 and his only sibling, an older brother, ran away from home when rousseau was still a child....
22 Pages (5500 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us