StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Iraq War and the Patriot Act - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “The Iraq War and the Patriot Act,” the author looks at the Iraq War and the Patriot Act, which are the Bush Administration’s response to 9/11. Many Americans object to both the Iraq War and the Patriot Act because they are unjustified, unjust, immoral, and unconstitutional…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
The Iraq War and the Patriot Act
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Iraq War and the Patriot Act"

Step One Make a list of 10 issues that call for resistance or protest Vietnam War 2. Iraq War 3. Patriot Act 4. Military Draft 5. Seal Hunting 6. The use of animals in chemical testing. 7. Nuclear weapons 8. Racial profiling 9. Death penalty or capital punishment 10. Mistreatment of prisoners of war and enemy combatants Pick two of the 10 issues you listed above. What are ways people can wage non-violent protests against these issues 1. Iraq War 2. Patriot Act I picked out these two examples because they are related to one another. Both the Iraq War and the Patriot Act are the Bush Administration's response to 9/11. Many Americans object to both the Iraq War and the Patriot Act because they are unjustified, unjust, immoral and unconstitutional. To effectively protest against both, the protests should be non-violent so that the protests themselves are moral, just and constitutional. Two examples of non-violent protests include sit-ins and petitions and letters to the government and media What is the merit of non-violent resistance over violent resistance In your opinion which form of resistance is more effective Non-violent resistance is preferable to violent resistance because it is moral. Generally, protests are carried out against immoral and unjust actions. If protests are violent, they could be immoral themselves or a source of injustice. Therefore, they will not be effective because they are like the very thing that they are protesting against. Due to this, non-violent protests are more effective than violent protests. Can you think of concrete examples from history when violence was the only answer Explain your examples. The first historical example which comes to mind is the British colonialism of the United States. The Americans could not peacefully protest against this because the British had an army behind them and violently opposed any protests to their presence in the United States. Therefore, the only form of protest which could achieve the removal of the British from America was violence. The second historical example which comes to mind is the secession of the Confederate States. The North and all Americans who opposed the division of their country into two could not protest against this in a non-violent way. The confederate states had gathered their armies and had declared their secession from the United States of America. The only way that this development could be reversed was through violence, which means that protest had to take the form of military confrontation. Step Two 1. During which period in history was Thoreau writing Henry David Thoreau was writing during the era of slavery. 2. Against what government acts did Thoreau wage protest Thoreau waged protest against corrupt, unjust and immoral government acts such as the enslavement of a race. 3. What type of direct action did Thoreau's essay call for The type of direct action Thoreau called for was civil disobedience. 4. What type of direct action did Martin Luther King, Jr.'s letter call for The type of direct action which martin Luther King called for was peaceful protest in the form of sit-ins and marches. Reverend Ling emphasised that protestors should be prepared to obey the rules of non-violence regardless of the violence which they may be subjected to. 5. To whom was King's letter addressed Reverend King addressed his letter to his fellow clergymen and, more specifically, to eight Alabama clergymen. 6. In whom did King express his deep disappointment Reverend King expressed disappointment in Alabama's economy community and white moderates but, he reserved his deepest disappointment for the white church and its leadership. Step Three: Making Connections Although Henry David Thoreau and Reverend Martin Luther King Jr. were the products of different historical eras, separated by close to a century, their philosophy of non-violent resistance was inspired by the same reason. This reason was the treatment of blacks in the United States: slavery and segregation. Not only was racial injustice the inspiration for both these men but their views on protest were similar as both Thoreau and King advocated non-violence. Although Thoreau and King similarly advocated non-violence and emphasised that opposition should have a moral justification, they had different views on the form of non-violent protest which people should adopt. Among the more striking of the similarities between Thoreau and King are their attitudes towards the moral basis and framework of protests. In essence, Thoreau's essay may be described as an argument for adherence to one's conscience and the importance of upholding the basic moral principle of justice. As he writes, "unjust laws exist" and it is the duty of men and citizens with conscience to "transgress them at once," although non-violently. The implication here is that citizens should not blindly obey laws and governments but must use their moral judgement to determine whether or not the laws in question are just and moral. Only if they are, can a citizens obey them but, if they are not he should exercise civil disobedience. This particular aspect of Thoreau's philosophy of non-violence is very similar to Martin Luther King's as he also emphasised the duty to non-violently protest against unjust laws and immoral practices. Explaining the reason for his presence in Alabama, Reverend King writes, "I am in Birmingham because injustice is here." Like Thoreau, King believes that men have a moral duty to fight injustice and like Thoreau he also believes that protests and opposition to law have to be moral, as in non-violent. He thus asks protestors "are we able to accept blows without retaliating" In other words, regardless of the violence which protestors may be subjected to, they are morally obliged to abide by a philosophy of non-violence. Morality and justice, therefore, entailing non-violent resistance to injustice, are the primary characteristic of both King and Thoreau's philosophies. While there are fundamental similarities between Thoreau and King, there are also significant differences. Thoreau did not call for united action, while King did. Thoreau did not call for direct confrontation, while King did. It is interesting in this regard to quote Thoreau's view that "government is best which governs least." This does not appear to be King's view whereby it is evident from his letter that h supports strong governments; he wants a federal government which would step in and address the injustices committed by state governments. Indeed, as he writes, "injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere." The point here is that rather than confront injustice by disobeying the laws, such as refusal to pay taxes as recommended by Thoreau, men had to take such action as would alert both the religious and the political authorities to the presence and depth of injustice. In other words, while Thoreau appears to identify the government as the primary opponent, King seems t regard it as a potential ally, but only if protestor are able effectively expose the depth of injustice. From a personal point of view, the philosophy of non-violent resistance, as preached by both King and Thoreau has enormous potential. We are currently living in a world which is full of injustice and violence. Governments are not only failing to act against injustice but, more often than not, they are at the root of these injustices. Among the injustices which Americans are currently confronting due to the actions of their government, is the War in Iraq. This war has cost the country countless of billions of dollars and the death of thousands of American soldiers. There is no moral purpose to this war. The American people have to take a stand against it but, they must take a non-violent stand, especially that they are protesting violence. Sit-ins and marches could be very effective, and are forms of non-violent protest which would grab the attention of the media and send a strong message to Washington: the American people are against violence and injustice; they are against death and destruction and they want their soldiers home. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Iraq War and the Patriot Act Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
The Iraq War and the Patriot Act Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/history/1501757-connections
(The Iraq War and the Patriot Act Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
The Iraq War and the Patriot Act Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1501757-connections.
“The Iraq War and the Patriot Act Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/history/1501757-connections.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Iraq War and the Patriot Act

Definition paper on Patriotism

Once an academic understanding of the rights of citizens has been obtained, it is then necessary for the patriot to transfer that knowledge to his or her daily life.... That is why the act of engagement is so vital for patriotism.... A real patriot must know why the government works the way it does (Haynes, 2009)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Fahrenheit 9/11 - Documentary Analysis

The Bush administration promptly declared war on terror and pertinent legislation (the patriot act) was enacted.... According to the movie's argument, the Bush administration preyed on this emotional turmoil and fear of terror to endorse the iraq invasion.... Name Instructor Course Date Fahrenheit 9/11 - Documentary Analysis Fahrenheit 9/11 is a documentary that unravels the grand conspiracy during the advent of terror on the 11th of September 2001, and the subsequent iraq and Afghanistan invasion....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The US Invasion of Iraq: Neo-Colonialism at Work

1 In the run up to a Presidential election, what better rallying point could there be than a democratic US sallying forth to rescue the downtrodden people of Iraq from the deprivations of Saddam HusseinThe iraq war, however, was not about Saddam Hussein or even weapons of mass destruction.... Whereas earlier the US had a convenient adversary in the form of the erstwhile Soviet Union and the bogey of the Cold war, it now had to find newer enemies and causes to justify its aggressive foreign policy in the quest for global dominance....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Political Consequences of 9/11

(Diken & Laustsen, 2004) Section 806 of the patriot act added a new provision to section 981 that is an obvious response to 9/11.... Section 981 (a) (1) (G) authorizes forfeiture of all assets of anyone engaged in terrorism, any property affording any person a 'source of influence' over a terrorist organization, and any property derived from or used to commit a terrorist act.... nbsp; Even a former CIA director and chief adviser to New York's Terrorism Preparedness Taskforce has described the conflict against Al-Qaeda as the 'fourth world war', and he predicts it will go on for decades....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Socio-Political Factors of 9/11: Motivations and Responses

Despite these similarities, however,… most people would be hard pressed to find a connection between the actions of the United States during the Cold war and the rise of Islamic fundamentalism that has given rise to the much hotter war on terror.... The war on terror follows quickly upon the Cold war and though many obvious differences exist, many similarities can also be found.... Surprisingly, perhaps, the key connection between the Cold war and It may perhaps be far too simplistic to even suggest pointing to one singular event as the cause behind the rise of Islamic fundamentalist terrorism culminated in the 9/11 attacks and thereafter completely changed the political landscape within the US, but if any one event can be said to be the most important, then it would be the Soviet Union's ill-fated decision to invade Afghanistan in 1979 (Fellure 2005)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The Dilemma of State Building in Iraq

The above factors and the differences had its toll even when the iraq was set for restructuring after the decline of the rule of Saddam Hussein in 2003.... It was in the time of World War I, the iraq was aimed by the British forces.... The importance of the country has been all the more imperative because of the huge sources of oil… Looking in to the history of iraq, one could easily find that the country has been time and again attacked by external forces....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

The Patriot Act and Terrorism

The Act can also have an impact on the local and the patriot act and Terrorism Unit Question1 The Patriot Act was passed on 26th October 2001, in response to 11th September 2001 terrorist attacks in the United States.... Apart from the patriot act, there exist anti-terrorist laws, which cut the civil rights of American citizens.... Question 3 Scheb (2011) claims that the patriot act defines terrorism in a broader way for non-citizens than for the citizens of the United States....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

United States Military Foreign Policy

The US government came to the conclusion that in order to obtain domestic security, intervention across the globe was absolutely necessary to fight the war on terror.... armed forces prepared for war by not only increasing the military budget, but they also put forth principles and values fundamental to the American dream to garner support for any conflict deemed a necessity.... Aside from militaristic efforts, the federal government also sought to increase its own power and ability to utilize all of their resources in order to win the war on terror....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us