StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Comparison of Japans Meiji Period with Chinas Great Leap Forward - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The Meiji Period in Japan lasted for close to half a century (1868 – 1912). This time in Japan’s history was one of its most successful, mainly due to Emperor Meiji moving the capital from Kyoto to Tokyo. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
Comparison of Japans Meiji Period with Chinas Great Leap Forward
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparison of Japans Meiji Period with Chinas Great Leap Forward"

Comparison of Japan’s Meiji Period with China’s Great Leap Forward The Meiji Period in Japan lasted for close to half a century (1868 – 1912). Thistime in Japan’s history was one of its most successful, mainly due to Emperor Meiji moving the capital from Kyoto to Tokyo. This helped set up the foundation of a strong capital city today. On the other hand, China’s Great Leap Forward lasted no more than a few years (1958 – 1963). History will look back on this time in China’s history with regret because Mao set China back decades.

Even though these periods in Japan’s and China’s history were close to a century apart, the goal of each country was very similar—an attempt to catch up to Western imperialized nations. One of the main reasons why the Meiji Period is considered a success while the Great Leap Forward a failure is due to the length of time each was given to succeed. The Meiji Period occurred over a longer period of time, and so was more likely to succeed. Emperor Meiji decided that Japan needed to establish itself as one of the world’s leading nations both economically and militarily.

To fuel this growth, democracy was promoted as a key component of change in Japan. The old feudal lords had their powers decreased to the point where all Japanese citizens were treated equally. Conversely, China’s Great Leap Forward was abandoned after only a few short years because the goals and objectives set forth by Mao were completely unrealistic. He too realized that China needed to catch up to the Western powers, but he did so in a completely different way than Emperor Meiji. Unlike Japan, which had embraced democracy, China was deeply rooted in communist principles.

Mao decided that two improvements would significantly boost the Chinese economy: industry and agriculture. He was correct in saying that these are key areas that need to form the backbone of any economy. Where he got it wrong was setting unrealistic goals and targets for the people to reach. Additionally, families were housed in communes and had no control over their own state of affairs. The result of this was that many people starved to death due to a lack of food. Even though both the Meiji Period and Great Leap Forward set out with the same purpose, the reason why one succeeded and one failed is how they went about it.

Japan decided to study Western ways of learning; the Japanese education system was Western-based and education became compulsory for every Japanese child. Advanced intellectuals even went overseas to try and enhance their knowledge; from the other side, experts from Western countries were brought in to train locals. For the military side of things, the Japanese navy was based around the Prussian and British models. Compared to the Great Leap Forward, the Meiji Period was always likely to succeed because they put the right fundamentals in place to help the nation to thrive.

On the other hand, the Chinese Great Leap Forward was very inward looking, with no help from outsiders considered. Another thing that contributed to the Great Leap Forward’s downfall was that too much was attempted to be accomplished too fast. If more time and care had been taken, then it may have been possible for the Great Leap Forward to succeed.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Comparison of Japans Meiji Period with Chinas Great Leap Forward Essay”, n.d.)
Comparison of Japans Meiji Period with Chinas Great Leap Forward Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1593693-comparison-of-japans-meiji-period-with-chinas-great-leap-forward
(Comparison of Japans Meiji Period With Chinas Great Leap Forward Essay)
Comparison of Japans Meiji Period With Chinas Great Leap Forward Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/1593693-comparison-of-japans-meiji-period-with-chinas-great-leap-forward.
“Comparison of Japans Meiji Period With Chinas Great Leap Forward Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1593693-comparison-of-japans-meiji-period-with-chinas-great-leap-forward.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparison of Japans Meiji Period with Chinas Great Leap Forward

Meiji Revolution

This paper answers: what were the major reforms enacted by the new meiji government in the 1870s, who was Saigo Takamori, and why did he have a falling out with the rest of the oligarchy and What was the Iwakura Mission, and what did it accomplish.... hellip; The meiji leaders had experienced both the corrupt Tokugawa feudal rule and the pressure of Western imperialism.... What were the major reforms enacted by the new meiji government in the 1870s?...
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Acquisition of Empire. Japans wins due to its victory over China

This paper replies to such questions: Japan's wins due to its victory over China and Russia, motives of the meiji government in going to war with China and Russia and eventual annexation of Korea.... Japan's victory over China strengthened national cohesion in Japan resulting the unequal treaties with West and appearance as the supreme economic power and chief in East Asia....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Japanese Women in Meiji Period

It was during the meiji period in Japanese history that thoughts of respect for human rights and freedom, introduced from the USA and Europe, took root in the Japanese society This brief essay presents a discussion about women in Japan during the Meiji era.... It is clear, that although remnants of the Tokugawa thinking and fundamental influences from old Japan continued into the meiji period, processes of reform and efforts for change accelerated into the Meiji era....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Japan Meiji period and China great leap forward

The mostly notable periods have been The Meiji Era in Japan, and China's great leap forward, that presented significant economic development.... The great leap and Meiji era presented periods that saw significant progress in Asia's leading nation progress.... hellip; There are significant periods within the economy of nations that have contributed the historical significance to yield a period of success.... There are significant periods within the economy of nations that have contributed the historical significance to yield a period of success....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Modern Japan and Meiji Restoration

The Charter Oath, which was promulgated made very democratic and great pledges that would see Japan people being involved in decision making regardless of their social status as well as embracing the natural law of nature.... The Japan people believed that meiji just signified reshuffling of power and that much could not be done since the samurai class would still enjoy… The samurai class took themselves ethnocentric thus culminating the public with the ethnocentrism idea....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

A Hypothetical Debate

This was the period of imperialism and colonialism in which Western countries like the great Britain, France, Germany, the Netherlands, and Spain sought new lands in other parts of the world.... This period also saw two contrasting approaches in how to deal with the new world order.... Japan before the meiji Restoration (September 1868 to July 1912) had been always a country that was mainly agricultural (poor), beset with local wars (due to the feudal system in which samurai clans had held attachment to their ancestral lands), weak militarily, and little or no technological development to speak of....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Comparative Asian Economics: The Meiji Period in the Japanese History

An author of this paper "Comparative Asian Economics: The meiji period in the Japanese History" seeks to discuss the economic development of Japan during the meiji period (1868-1911) as well as major political, social and historical factors that influenced it.... he meiji period policy of using private businesses for the promotion of government policy objectives proved to be effective.... hellip; While people wonder how Japan could have achieved so much in a relatively short span of time, analysts and historians have drawn various factors that helped the country's leaders during the reign of Emperor meiji to successfully bring about the major political, economic and social changes needed to bring in advancement....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Bloody Lesson Paid for China's Great Leap Forward and Famine

The paper "Bloody Lesson Paid for China's great leap forward and Famine" presents detailed information, that eating Bitterness grows out of a workshop being conducted under the same title at the Institute for East Asian Studies at the University of Vienna.... It needs to be mentioned that the stated years were marked with great leap forward but resulted in severe starvation and thus a backward step rather than a leap forward.... Rather than examining the fact why party leaders stumbled so badly in their attempt to modernize China; the book revolves around exploring what exactly the great leap forward meant for ordinary people in the urban and rural areas....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us