StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Free and Independent Press on Democracy - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the "Free and Independent Press on Democracy" paper argues that there is little doubt about the fact that as long as a nation has a free press, they have a means of monitoring their government, which is ultimately the point of democracy…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Free and Independent Press on Democracy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Free and Independent Press on Democracy"

Free and Independent Press on Democracy Introduction A free and independent press is the cornerstone of every accountable democracy, without information, people cannot make competent decisions on how to govern themselves through the leaders they elect. Thomas Jefferson, one of the founding fathers of the United States, reportedly said that if he ever had to choose between a government with no newspapers or newspapers and no government he would pick the latter. He was a firm believer in the public’s right to information and that of the press to act as the watchdog for them. Indeed, free flow of information is critical to the functioning of the United States, which is the most powerful democracy in the world today (Little, 2009). Information technology has significantly broadened the role of the press as well as its scope, mandate, and reach. Breaking news stories from halfway across the globe are relayed to the international audience live giving the press a critical role in realizing the dream of a global village. Understandably, this has made the fourth estate immensely powerful and as a result, it has constantly been in conflict with the authorities. However, governments sometimes see the media as playing a subversive role, which they do at times, creating a culture of competition between the two institutions although in most cases they work collaboratively. It is the contention of this paper that the press plays a central role in providing the public with information that allows them to make informed decisions and choices in a democratic state. A functional and independent media serves the course of democracy in numerous ways, for one, elections can only be fair if the citizens know everything there is to know about their leaders (Little, 2009). In addition, in some countries, it is impossible for the leaders to connect with all the citizens and for them to present their agenda; they must use the media to expose the people to them. For example, given the size of a country like the US, the presidential candidates cannot expect to visit every town and street. However, through the media in the form of new reports, social media and newspaper article both online and physical, nearly everyone can form an informed opinion about their leaders. People want to know how their leaders have acted in the past and what intentions they have for the future of their country, through town hall style debates broadcast live on the media, they can have access to such information. The independence of the media allows them to highlight both negative and positive things about candidates without fear, of intimidation or reprisals should the particular candidate win. Similarly, the press ensures integrity because they can put politicians in a position where they have to provide vital information to the public. For example, during a press conference, the journalists ask any question they wish and most of these are published to ensure transparency and assist in the vetting process. However, despite their independence, there exit limitations that vary from country to country; this dictate how much freedom of expression even the media has to prevent it from abusing its immense powers (Bollinger, 2009). No party, including the media, is allowed to perpetuate hate speech or incite others to commit a crime through the media and there are legal frameworks through which the media is monitored to prevent such incidence. In most developed democracies such as the UK, the press can however comment on any issue including wrongdoings by politicians and the government. In fact, it is stories about wrongdoings by the state, its agents or politicians that appear to make the headlines for the longest time possible (Jellinek, 2013). Stories especially touching on misuse of government funds of abuse of office by MP and other politicians are highly sought after. The extent of these freedoms is something one takes for granted until they consider the situation in countries where there is no democracy or there exists a pseudo-democracy. For example, in China, which is ruled by the communist party, the freedom of the press very limited and the government has even gone a step further by heavily censoring the internet (Jellinek, 2013). Access to social media sites is highly restricted and controversial topics are often taken off Google and other search engines by government filters. This is engendered by the Ironic fact that one of the most iconic images of the struggle for freedom, the Tiananmen Square Tank Man, has been suppressed and most young Chinese have never even heard of its existence (Leib & He, 2006). Pro-democracy activist have replayed this image in thousands of video clips; Michael Jackson had it in his “Man in Mirror” video and Bon Jovi used them in the “We Weren’t Born to follow”. It appears that on some issues, the world knows more about China than the citizens of China themselves. In his book, Hua, (2012) remarks that after the event in the square, it appeared to vanish entirely from the Chinese media and was almost never mentioned again. While he says this is disturbing, he points out that it is not surprising given that the primary new agency in China is state controlled. It cannot run a story without first getting approval from the government. Consequently, there is a minor criticism of the government that can take place in the Chinese mainstream media. For this and other obvious reasons, there cannot be the slightest semblance of democracy in China since people tend to believe what the government tells them rather than what an objective media would. Any election in China is on citizens using carefully controlled pieces of information that have tailor made to influence their thinking. To a significant extent, the reason it is so easy for governments to manipulate their people is that they already control the information so many citizens may not be aware they are being manipulated. The primary source of information for the public is the press and when it is not independent, the people will remain ignorant; ignorant people are always soft targets for manipulations and in many cases, when the press is not free, that is exactly what happens. In the recent past, headlines have shown that the power of the press should never be taken for granted. The US government was discovered to have illegally obtained phone records of a journalist for Fox news and ruled that James Risen a New York Times reporter should disclose his confidential sources. However, the uproar with which the news was met by proved that the public values the confidentiality and independence of the press. Despite being the most powerful democracy in the world, if the US, free press cannot protect its sources, this democracy will ultimately suffer (Edgecliffe-Johnson, 2013); however, the press got a shot in the arm when the senate voted to approve the free flow of information act. Having a diverse and autonomous media is the key for facilitation of responsible and accountable government. Given the extensive media landscape, the press remains the key conduit for public assessment of the actions of the state and institutions that have directly or indirectly affect public affairs. Pro-democracy and free press commentators hold that it is only in a society where the press is free and allowed to monitor that real democracy can be realized. One of the key political issues that underpin the role of media in the social political landscape is transparency, as long as there is no transparency corruption in public institutions is bound to thrive (Thompson, 2013). While in some cases governments oppose the efforts of the media to investigate into its affairs, the truth is and open press that can carry out independent investigative journalism should be seen as partner by any transparent states (Baker, Bennett & Entman, 2002). Without criticism, the government cannot be held accountable for its action and inaction and this is only possible if the press is operating under its own mandate. In many cases, national broadcasters are used by the government to perpetuate propaganda among the citizenry and keep them in the dark about the ill actions of the government. However, in a transparent democracy, the state should have an objective relationship with the press irrespective of funding. For example, in the UK, the main broadcaster is the BCC, which is partly owned by the government (Thompson, 2006). However, in most cases it has proven a reliable source and does not appear side with the state. Indeed, it often criticizes with just as much alacrity as private media. To show how effective an independent press is for the sake of the country, Nobel Prize Laurent Amartya Sen says that in the recent history, there has never been a substantial famine in any country they has a democratic free press. Any society that has access to public documents and has insight into the decision-making process will be well informed and able to demand that the government takes to account their actions. The lesson from the US democracy and press culture can be applied primarily to emerging democracies that are still trying to recover and get their bearing after decades of autocratic rule. While the US does not always present the best model, its framework is often quite useful and serves as a generic fit. For instance, in the discourse about media independence financial independence also needs to be taken to account. The American model, which relies considerably on adverts, is looked upon with suspicion by many former or currently communist states. However, objectivity can be achieved if they were to build walls between the business function of news and the functional informational purpose. Mandhane (2013) contends that new democracies tend to spawn a crop of anti-dialogical journalists that are so used to government oppressive one-party rule that they confuse their role with that of the opposition. In the end, they may end up perpetually criticizing the government, which he sees as trading one affiliation for another. While not seeking to imply that the US version of democracy of free press is the best there is, it serves as a relatively efficient blueprint for any country that would wish to adopt both democracy and free media, which are inseparable. While there is no doubt that, the free and independent press is necessary to act as a watchdog to government, there emerges the question of who will watch over the media. Understandably, the press does come off as mean spirited especially when it is engaged against the government; however, there need to be ways through which they can be prevented from misusing their power. In the US, this is done through a variety of ways; there are ombudsmen who are in-house critics whose role is to listen to complaints and publish their judgment. On the other hand, there can be citizen’s council, which listen to and pass judgment against the press when they are out of line. While they have no legal mandate, their views are often widely accepted and respected. The most popular and efficient formal means of regulating the press in the US has however been the liberal suit. This allows for citizens who feel they have been negatively portrayed by the press to sue it for considerable sums, this way the press has more motivation to stick to the truth. However, this law will rarely apply to celebrities who the courts deem to have notoriety because they are public figures. Conclusion It is worth noting that in many democratic constitutions, there is no specific requirement for the press to be responsible or accountable. These demands are made of the executive, judiciary and legislative branches of government but not for the media. This engenders the assumption that the people in a free market economy and democracy regulate the press, and the press is expected to self-regulate. In conclusion, there is little doubt about the fact that as long as a nation has a free press, they have a means of monitoring their government, which is ultimately the point of democracy. References Baker, C. E., Bennett, W. L., & Entman, R. M., 2002. Media, markets, and democracy . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Bollinger, L. C., 2009. Uninhibited, Robust, and Wide-Open: A Free Press for a New Century. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Edgecliffe-Johnson, A. 2013. New Yorker reveals Aaron Swartz-inspired system to protect sources. Financial Times, [Online] 15 May. Available at: http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/390e684a-bd7d-11e2-890a-00144feab7de.html [accessed 22 2014] Hua, Y., 2012. China in ten words. New York. Random House LLC. Jellinek , D., 2013. The meaning of free media in a democracy. Journalism, [Online] 9 July. Available at: https://www.journalism.co.uk/news-commentary/-complex-links-between-free-press-and-functioning-democracy-/s6/a553464/[accessed 22 2014] Mandhane, R., 2013. Role of Media in Democracy. Legal Desire, [Online] 16 Sept. Available at: http://legaldesire.com/role-of-media-in-democracy-2/ [accessed 22 2014]. Leib, E., & He, B., 2006. The search for deliberative democracy in China. New York. Palgrave Macmillan. Little, C., 2009. Democracy Depends on a Free Press. Miami Herald, [Online] 16 Sept. Available at: http://www.miamiherald.com/opinion/op-ed/speak-up/article1955056.html [accessed 22 2014]. Thompson, J.B., 2013. Political scandal: Power and visability in the media age. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons. Thompson, C., 2006. Google’s China problem (and China’s Google problem).The New York Times, [Online] 23 April. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/2006/04/23/magazine/23google.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0 [accessed 22 2014]. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Free and Independent Press on Democracy Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words, n.d.)
Free and Independent Press on Democracy Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1854624-why-is-the-existence-of-a-free-and-independent-media-sector-so-important-for-democracy
(Free and Independent Press on Democracy Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words)
Free and Independent Press on Democracy Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1854624-why-is-the-existence-of-a-free-and-independent-media-sector-so-important-for-democracy.
“Free and Independent Press on Democracy Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words”. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1854624-why-is-the-existence-of-a-free-and-independent-media-sector-so-important-for-democracy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Free and Independent Press on Democracy

The Independence in Canada and in the United States

hellip; Other measures taken were the fight for domestic autonomy, tariff autonomy, institutional capacity, foreign representation, and independent treaty-making power (Holloway 127).... Other measures taken were the fight for domestic autonomy, tariff autonomy, institutional capacity, foreign representation, and independent treaty-making power (Holloway 127).... However, after the granting of independence, Canada, as mentioned earlier, was given more power over its legislature and enjoyed the ideals of democracy....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

The Freedom of the Press

This essay “The Freedom of the press” will focus on whether the public should support the freedom of the press.... The freedom of the press entails the right to publish or to print information without any restrictions from the government.... hellip; According to the paper, freedom of the press is a crucial aspect, which should be safeguarded and upheld.... Freedom of the press and the freedom of speech are two interrelated concepts....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Nazism and Free Speech

This is, however, a weak argument as the news that is of importance to the people is what ought to be published in any democracy.... It also reveals that the freedom to question and protest were the most important rights that a person had under a democracy.... Even if the state of things is not perfect in a democracy, as long as the right to protest remained intact, the press of the country could be considered to be free, according to Hess.... This can be seen in the suppression of the power of the press in a country that is under the Nazi regime....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Elements of Democracy in France

democracy entails more than the form of government.... Other components act as indicators of presence or absence of democracy.... hellip; These elements are core for democracy to be achieved.... Elements of democracy in France Other arms of government are the senate and National Assembly, which form the legislature and the Judiciary.... Existence of different arms of government ensures separation of power, which enhances democracy....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

To What Extent It Is Necessary for the Government to Regulate the Press in a Liberal Democracy

independent press informs the community about the events and changes, provides the accountability of the government and prescribes the forum for discussing questions, which have local or national significance.... The states with democratic form of government stimulate the existence of the independent press.... The independent judicial system, civil community, where the legality is followed, and freedom of speech support the independent press....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Analysis of State of Massachusetts on North American Free Trade Agreement

hus, the vote on the North American free Trade Agreement was an almost evenly divisive issue for Democrats senators during the vote in 1993, where 27 democrat senators voted for the NAFTA implementation, while 28 of the Democrat senators voted against its implementation (Earle, 193)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Variables The Internet Users and Democracy Score

This essay discusses the internet, that has been pointed out as a major catalyst towards the killings of democracy and at the same time, promoting the very core values of democracy in the modern world.... hellip; From this paper, it is clear that Internet is where the exchange of ideas about democracy takes place and is usually stocked with a large number of interested parties who through a competitive bidding process get to enjoy the very scarce resource available....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Journalism and Ethics

Nonetheless, the power that the media holds can at times be abused and tainted to the degree that its very core duty of protecting the people's democracy is threatened.... Essentially, the media outlet democracy Now!... Today, democracy Now!... democracy Now!... Reveals the importance of ethical journalism through its insistence on media independence and democracy.... For true democracy to come into effect, there is need for the citizens to gain access to both independent and diverse sources of information and news....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us