StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Is it fair, just and reasonable to allow the police to escape liability from a breach of duty - Dissertation Example

Cite this document
Summary
The study will address the question ‘is it fair, just, and reasonable to allow the police to escape liability from a breach of duty?’ This question is a critical issue that needs to be elucidated as there are divergent views regarding the status of police negligence and police liability…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
Is it fair, just and reasonable to allow the police to escape liability from a breach of duty
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Is it fair, just and reasonable to allow the police to escape liability from a breach of duty"

Download file to see previous pages

This research will begin with the statement that tort is not something new. In fact, the law of tort is a very old legal concept, even older than the notion of crime. In the ancient period, the discourse on law is not on the laws of crime per se; rather it was more on the law of wrongs. By 1300’s, the English common law developed procedural mechanisms that was used to bring an action to court. During this period, writ system was developed and one of the most original writ was the writ of trespass.

However, it should be noted that the writ of trespass was not a demand for right but it was a rectification for wrong done. Then, by 1400’s, sense and appeal to justice was integrated in the actions and responses to cases. By late 1700’s concept of negligence was developed and by 1800’s there was a shift from causation to fault for actions on cases. Meanwhile, the search for principles or theories that would explain further the concept of negligence became a primary concern in tort.

This brief historical tracing of tort highlights the fact that early in the evolution of tort, the idea of remedies for wrongful acts was already perceived as a powerful tool in keeping public order, security, and peace within the society. However, despite the historical progression of tort and a common belief that tort implies compensation for injuries, there is an observed difficulty in coming up with a universal definition for tort. This is because there are different kinds and structures of torts, with different purposes and aims, variegated interests and different kinds of interferences.

11 Working on the premise that tort covers a wide scope, this research will deal with one of the controversial “legal wrong for which the law provides remedy”,12 - police negligence and liability. The police are significant public group in the society that has been mandated by law to protect and preserve the peace. 13. Police are in a unique position as they fulfil their specific function that is mandated by law, which is to protect and keep the peace not just of one person, but also of the entire society.

14 However, this unique function is not a guarantee that police will never commit a civil wrong. 15 In fact, just like other members of the society, they are also susceptible to negligence as they perform their functions. Cases show that police negligence is a reality, but because of ‘public policy immunity’, they have not been held accountable for their negligence. In other words, they enjoy immunity from their negligence to the extent that police immunity from liability is the general rule.

16 However, Osman v UK17 demands a re-appropriation of police immunity from liability. Current experiences question police immunity and as such, mar the logic of the law itself. Since, its logic is the experience of the law. 18 In this scenario, matter of justice and fairness, in lieu of police immunity is raised.19 Tort and Negligence: The Rise of Tort of Negligence The term tort is derived from the Latin word tortus, which means twisted. In French, it means wrong. 20 Tort, in the English tradition, connotes the idea of a “legal wrong for which the law provides remedy”.

21 In this purely technical and legal sense, tort falls under the civil law because “

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Is it fair, just and reasonable to allow the police to escape Dissertation”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1396380-is-it-fair-just-and-reasonable-to-allow-the-police
(Is It Fair, Just and Reasonable to Allow the Police to Escape Dissertation)
https://studentshare.org/law/1396380-is-it-fair-just-and-reasonable-to-allow-the-police.
“Is It Fair, Just and Reasonable to Allow the Police to Escape Dissertation”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1396380-is-it-fair-just-and-reasonable-to-allow-the-police.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is it fair, just and reasonable to allow the police to escape liability from a breach of duty

Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations

An exclusion clause seeks to exclude from a contract some term (such as one imposing a duty of care) that would otherwise be implied; a limitation clause seeks to limit liability for any breach of such a term. The general rule is that the parties are free to determine the terms of their own contract.... Peter Symmons & Co claimed damages from Cook on the grounds that he was in breach of both express and implied terms of the contract namely:Cook had warranted that the car was in excellent condition (an express term);As the car was not of merchantable quality Cook was in breach of s....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Suing for Negligence and Nervous Shock

Ascribing responsibility became easier with the advancement of science as did greater competence in determining causation which made it easy from a pragmatic point of view to establish force.... In order to establish liability in tort, the… Mike must prove that the police have been negligent in performing their duty and he must equally prove that the police owe a duty of care to him.... It should be noted the police negligently pulled Mike back to the extent of having injured himself....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

English Tort Law and Employers Liability Act 1969

hellip; Gracie may be held liable for tort for the broken ankle suffered by Brenda and not the employer, under tort for vicarious liability, because the act in issue did not occur in the course of employment as contemplated in the Salmond Test.... This essay analyzes the English Tort Law....
68 Pages (17000 words) Essay

Tort of Law: Ian vs Who Trades Wins Plc Case

It will also be necessary to consider whether or not Ian can claim damages for breach of duty in respect of pure economic loss.... ??1 In this regard, Ian must establish that WTW and Marcus owed him a duty of care,… was in breach of that duty and that as a result of that breach Ian incurred reasonably foreseeable injury.... Ian's potential liability for c injury to liability will also turn on questions relative to the duty of care and the extent to which that duty can be extended to Peggy and her injury was reasonably foreseeable....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Trusts Operating in a Socially Beneficial Manner

The paper "Trusts Operating in a Socially Beneficial Manner" describes that the provisions of the law have allowed for trustee discretion and flexibility, however, they may also be held liable for breach of their fiduciary duties and the position of trust that they hold.... Moffat clarifies that under English law, charitable trusts need to be registered but other kinds of trusts require only proper constitution and the underlying concept of the trust refers to the “duty or aggregate accumulation of obligations that rest upon a person described as a trustee…....
12 Pages (3000 words) Coursework

Law of Tort: Compensation Culture

rdquo;  But, the threefold test, 'reasonably foreseeable', 'proximity or neighborhood' and 'fair, just and reasonable to impose liability' was firmly established in Caparo Industries Plc v Dickman[3] and it was held that it should not be the case that absolutely anyone hearing something said that was stupid and acted on it can sue.... The author of the "Law of Tort: Compensation Culture" paper approaches the issue with regard to negligence in the duty of care, and special reference to Pure Economic Loss in Torts which is characterized mainly by the indeterminate scope and unlimited liability....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Space Strategies and Legislation

If that is the case, Pain Estates Plc is entitled to claim damages for the breach of such a covenant.... However, as a landlord, Pain Estates Plc should not allow the property to get to a state of disrepair in the course of the lease since there is no assurance that there will be a solution during the terminal dilapidations; in this sense it is laudable that Pain Estates Plc has decided to institute an interim Schedule of Dilapidations.... This paper is an advice to the landlord, regarding their legal obligations, particularly concerning dilapidations, asbestos, Health safety matters of Equity Act, and fire safety issues… While it is clear that the landlord can decide to undertake the repair and later on recover the cost from the tenant, it is very important that Pain Estate strictly follow the legal procedures so the tenant is not granted a relief....
11 Pages (2750 words) Admission/Application Essay

Bradford City Football Stand Fire

Identify the prospective breach of law committed by each of the parties, explaining why each case specifies also breaches that you judge to be most serious.... Even with an improvement notice from HSE, the management is still reluctant to rectify the problems and even argues that the improvement recommended is not reasonably practicable.... However, as a rule, they must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the business owner failed to act as a reasonable employer in all the circumstances and that the injuries were caused as a direct result of this failure....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us