StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Whereas the US Constitution maps out the general direction in which governance should commence, the role and rights of the individual to the state are laid out in even more clarity within the first ten amendments to the Constitution…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
The Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment"

Section/# The Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment Whereas the US Constitution maps out the general direction in which governance should commence, the role and rights of the individual to the state are laid out in even more clarity within the first ten amendments to the Constitution; oftentimes collectively referred to as the Bill of Rights. These amendments have become a key detriment in the formation of law and the ways in which the government and its three branches interact with the citizens over which they preside. As a means of further understanding each of these first ten amendments, this brief analysis will consider their meaning in a greater degree of depth and through such an analysis help to paint a picture for the reader or researcher with regards to the ways in which the growth, definition, and expansion or contraction of the meanings associated with these amendments have helped to shape the legal process that is enjoyed with the United States. Further, the 14th amendment will also be considered and discussed as a means of providing a greater degree of equality, citizenship, and fairness under the Constitution and the law. The most cited of these ten amendments is naturally the first. As a fundamental right of the citizen, the first amendment gives the right to freedom of speech, press, religion, and petition. From a societal perspective, this is the amendment that, perhaps more than any other, allows for the continual growth and development of the American society based upon the premise of the enumerated freedoms. As freedom of religion, press, speech, and petition are guaranteed as a fundamental right which cannot and should not be infringed, the ability of the citizen to express a degree of self determination that would otherwise not be possible under a different code of ethics or laws is actionable (Kayman 324). Naturally, as with all the Bill of Rights and further amendments to the Constitution, each of these is given by means of entrusting the citizen not to break any law in the practice or implementation of these rights and privileges. The second of the ten amendments relates to the right to keep and bear arms. This hotly debated issue comes to the forefront of the political and societal discourse as acts of horrific gun violence bring out the anti-gun and pro-gun forces to a nearly seasonal battle royal in which both camps argue over the true meaning of the second amendment and how it relates to our current cultural reality (Case Law 1). With the exception of some key restraints being placed on the ownership and use of automatic weapons and a few regulations concerning what defines a handgun and what defines a rifle, the interpretation of this amendment has been historically quite liberal. In this way, American society has seen that, as with the other amendments in the Bill of Rights, the judiciary is keen on upholding the original intent, as best they see it, of the framers. Although it receives little attention, the third amendment which is included in the Bill of Rights is nonetheless important. Whereas the colonies experienced great hardship during the Revolutionary War period as well as before with relation to being required to quarter and provide sustenance to British Redcoats, the framers sought to enumerate upon the rights of the populace with regards to being required to provide material support for the military. Accordingly, this amendment secures the rights of the citizen against imposition by the military or the government in both time of peace and time of war with relation to providing quarter for soldiers and/or other military personnel. Socially, this amendment has experienced little growth and/or development due to the fact that the need of the government to require such an imposition of its citizens has been limited. The fourth amendment is infinitely more complex than the others which have heretofore been discussed. This fourth amendment states that the rights of the citizen to be free in their house, person, papers, and effects. The sociological development of this law has experienced a great deal of flux as the introduction of motor vehicles, drivers licenses, social security cards, and other government documentation has made it increasingly more complex for authorities to navigate within the constructs of the fourth amendment without violating it. Further, the tragedy of September 11th, 2001 meant that the process of air travel, inclusive of domestic air travel, was forever changed. Accordingly, key elements of the fourth amendment have been violated by various branches of government as warrantless searches are conducted each and every day within thousands of airports around the country. Of all of the amendments that are in danger of being abrogated, it is the fourth that bears the greatest risk. As law enforcement is increasingly demanding of all individuals to render proper identification, the threat of the erosion of this amendment is most grave. Amendments five, six, seven and eight relate to the criminal prosecution, the right of the accused to a speedy trial, the right of the accused to a trial by jury, and the enumeration on the prohibition of cruel or unusual punishment and/or unreasonably high bail respectively. The Fifth Amendment ties in strongly with the Miranda Rights that have come to be such a hallmark of our justice system. As the accused is not required to be a material witness against himself/herself, the accused is also able to refuse to answer any and all questions as a fundamental right afforded to him/her by the Fifth Amendment to the Constitution. Almost without exception, these 3 amendments have remained virtually unchanged. However, the recent case of Guantanamo Bay detainees has blurred the lines between what the Amendments state and how the government interprets the differences between “enemy combatants” and US citizens. Amendment Nine refers to the fact that the rights enumerated by the amendments to the Constitution should not construed to deprive another citizen of the very rights that they define themselves. Although obvious, this amendment is one of the most important due to the fact that it helps the cohesion and logic of the prior and proceeding rights to maintain themselves within the constructs of the law. Finally Amendment Ten allocates all powers and delegated determinations that have not been expressly defined within the Constitution or the subsequent amendments to be allocated to the States. Naturally, one does not need to think long in order to realize that this Amendment concerns the rights of the states to dissolve themselves from the union as no such provisions have been elsewhere stipulated within the Constitution or the preceding Bill of Rights. However, as the War Between the States proved, no such right was within the purview or jurisdiction of the individual states. Moreover, an additional amendment was added during the presidency of Andrew Johnson which stipulated that no state, or group of states, could seek to dissolve itself/themselves from the Union. From this point forward, the sociologically interpretation of this amendment has been uni-dimensional. Finally, as noted, this paper will discuss the role of the 14th Amendment to the Constitution as a means whereby previously ignored and/or understated precepts of the Constitution were enumerated upon. The history behind such an amendment necessarily dates back to the Supreme Court Case involving Dred Scott vs Sanford of 1857. In this case, the Supreme Court ruled that for purposes of the law, a slave would not be considered as a citizen of the United States but as a type of property. However, upon the conclusion of the Civil War and the North’s ultimate victory, the Fourteenth Amendment was drafted and signed into law (Miah 7). As such, it stated that anyone born in the United States or naturalized is a citizen of such; regardless of race or status. This amendment would go on to serve as the backbone for the eventual Supreme Court case of Brown v Board of Education. As has been noted, each of the amendments bears a significant meaning as to the interpretation of law and society that the United States currently experiences. Although the cliche oftentimes regards freedoms taken for granted, the truth is the almost all of the freedoms that exist within the United States, as compared to other nations, can be ultimately traced back to some provision within the Bill of Rights or the subsequent amendments to the Constitution. In this way, the founders/framers created a layer of protection that helped to limit the powers of the State/Government as it related to their citizens. Although one cannot convincingly claim that such constraints have completely and entirely worked to hedge government in, they have provided the necessary barriers that have allowed the Constitutional republic to survive for as long as it has. Works Cited Case Law. "U.S. Constitutional Amendments." RSS. N.p., 13 Apr. 2012. Web. 10 Dec. 2012. Kayman, Martin A. "The Bill Of Rights: 'Icons' Of Liberty And Law In The Early Twenty-First Century." Law & Humanities 5.2 (2011): 323-348. Academic Search Complete. Web. 10 Dec. 2012. Miah, Malik. "Rolling Back Reconstruction: Attacking The 14Th & 15Th Amendments." Against The Current 27.3 (2012): 2-14. Academic Search Complete. Web. 10 Dec. 2012. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment Essay”, n.d.)
The Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1464817-the-bill-of-rights-and-the-14th-amendment
(The Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment Essay)
The Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1464817-the-bill-of-rights-and-the-14th-amendment.
“The Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1464817-the-bill-of-rights-and-the-14th-amendment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment

Civil War and Reconstruction

Both theoretically and legally by the 13th Amendment of the Constitution slavery was outlawed; empowered by the 14th amendment, people of colors could enter into contracts, business, ownership, etc and by the 15th Amendment they earned the right to vote.... Consequently historical events like Reconstruction, Wade-Davis Bill, Black Codes, Segregation, Jim Crow laws, the 13th amendment to the 15th amendment to the Constitution etc were some steps towards the construction of a race-blind society....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Republican Party

The Republicans supported the Civil rights Act of 1866, which provided that; all individuals in the U.... During the Civil rights Act of 1964, segregation was outlawed through a court order and Democrats took the opportunity to bring in a less educated electorate, which supported segregation (Westwood 38)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Rights and Freedom

Rights and freedom Name: University: Date: Abstract The First Amendment of the US constitution forms part of the bill of rights and guarantees certain freedoms to the US citizens.... hellip; the bill of rights and subsequent amendment notable amendments to U.... the bill of rights and subsequent notable amendments to U.... the bill of rights guarantees the privacy of citizens and grants them the right to a fair judicial trial process....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Study guide for final

The dreams of Garrison came true after the end of Civil War in 1865 and abolition of slavery in US as mentioned in the 13th amendment of the constitution.... Supervisor Name Test Assignment 1 08 December 2013 American History Section I 1.... William Lloyd Garrison was among one of the main leaders of the anti-slavery movement....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Presidential Elections From George Washington to Rutherford Hayes

George Washington (1789 – 1793) took his oath as the 1st president of the United States on April 30, 1789 at the Federal Hall on Wall Street in New York.... Washington served for two terms and selflessly declined to serve the third term.... Washington also administered the policy… He wasn't part of any political parties yet. George Washington (1793 – 1797) issued the Proclamation of Neutrality which acted as the authority for deflecting any engagement between foreign countries....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

US Constitution

Republican Macon's bill No.... He was named the father of his country.... In his reign, there was surfacing of political parties: Jeffersonian against-Federalists (for-French) as well as Hamiltonian Federalists (for-British) (Madison,… Alexander Hamilton-Was born in 1755 in British West Indies/Nevice; an aide to General Washington during the revolutionary wars 1777and first secretary of state-introduced plans for first mint and national bank (Hellen 99)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

The Fourteenth Amendment

Additionally, the fourteenth amendment served to nationalize the federal bill of rights by compelling each state to regard it highly.... the bill sought to eliminate the criminal black codes established by individual states.... the bill sought to eliminate the criminal black codes established by individual states.... The paper "The Fourteenth amendment" underlines the problem when the whites, specifically in the southern states relied on unfair criminal proceedings to intimidate blacks....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

14th Amendment

The 13th Amendment raises some critical questions for the lawmakers, and the 14th amendment was drafted in order to answer these questions of law.... the 14th amendment comprises of 5 sections, they deal with the citizenship, equal protection of law, due process, debt, and power of the Congress to enforce.... A brief commentary of the clauses presented in the 14th amendment along with original is provided as follows....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us