StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent - Thesis Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent " it is clear that generally speaking, one could persuasively argue that the doctrine of judicial precedent is the central postulate of the English legal system.  English Law operates in multilevel…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent"

Download file to see previous pages

“Particular jurisprudence is concerned with the fundamental assumptions of one legal system, whereas general jurisprudence covers a wider field” (Cross and Harris, 1992, p.2). Many legal theorists and commentators have agreed upon the view that the sophistication of the English legal system cannot be understood without grasping the centrality of the doctrine of judicial precedent in it. The doctrine of judicial precedent has undergone profound transformations from Eighteenth-century onwards to the changing world. It is not a static concept but constantly evolving. Hence, the difficulty to grasp the relevance and scope of the doctrine of judicial precedent within the English legal system arises. In other words, since the doctrine of judicial precedent is a dynamic concept in both theory and practice, it always redefines its relationship with the legal system as a whole.

There is a balance of power between the doctrine of precedent and other provisions in the legal system. Therefore, we need to examine some of the important aspects of the English legal system that are closely related to the doctrine of judicial precedent such as the hierarchy of courts, parliament sovereignty, the ideologies of judicial adjudication, and so on to locate the following of precedents correctly. The doctrine of judicial precedent is intrinsically interpretative. Methodologically, a hermeneutic approach would be appropriate to grasp the interpretative nature of precedents and as a doctrine its 'flexible' relationship with the overall legal system. . Certainly, a conjuncture-level analysis would not always necessarily show the centrality of the doctrine of judicial precedent within the English level system.

However, a highest-level abstraction of the English legal system based on its trajectory of evolution and development would show that the doctrine of judicial precedent is at the heart of the English legal system. As an idea in general, precedent is not confined to jurisprudence or legal practice. Usually, all sorts of people resort to experiences to guide their present actions. It is an instant help in resolving complex issues by 'lived in experience'. In addition, reliance on precedent helps the evolution and codification of ideas which otherwise would have been left forgotten in the annals of history.

Thus, looking at the past for precedent is also an act of developing a theoretical approach towards it. While exploring the dynamics of the law of primitive man, Hoebel (1964) points out that the doctrine of judicial precedent is not a sole property of the Anglo-American Common Law System. Rather, "primitive law also builds on precedents, for there too, new decisions rest on old rules of law or norms of custom, and new decisions which are sound tend to supply the foundations of future action" (Hoebel, 1964, p. 28). Historically, it is the reproduction Euro-centric, colonial point of view to argue that the doctrine of judicial precedent seems to be (nearly) absent in all legal systems other than the English legal system.

The idea of precedent is present in almost all the operational legal systems for the simple reason that it cannot be otherwise. 

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent Thesis Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 5000 words”, n.d.)
The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent Thesis Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 5000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1522920-the-doctrine-of-judicial-precedent
(The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent Thesis Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 5000 Words)
The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent Thesis Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 5000 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1522920-the-doctrine-of-judicial-precedent.
“The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent Thesis Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 5000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1522920-the-doctrine-of-judicial-precedent.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent

Statutory Interpretation in Doctrine of Judicial Precedent

How does The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent engage with statutory interpretation?... Statutory interpretation and judicial precedent are the two important sources of law apart from the Parliament that enacts laws.... Introduction Statutory interpretation and judicial precedent are the two important sources of law apart from the Parliament that enacts laws.... judicial precedent judicial precedent is common law system by which a precedent serves as an authority, principle or rule established in a litigation formerly decided....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Doctrine of Precedent

The purpose of this paper is to discuss the doctrine of Precedent which is considered as both a blessing and a curse.... At this point, it is important to state that the doctrine of Precedents usually refer to the cases examined and considered by the Court of Appeal or the House of Lords.... It is important to stress out that the doctrine of Precedents are not concerned as to who won or lost in the case.... Obiter dicta are not binding, however, they may be dealt with as a persuasive authority, wherein the later judges are entitled to read them and be influenced by them, but they are not obliged to follow these parts of judicial pronouncements....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Doctrine of Judicial Precedent

The criminal division is composed of the Magistrates Court and the Crown Court (See Fig.... 1).... The determination of which court handles which case is decided on the kind and gravity of the offense. The Magistrates Court try both civil and criminal cases.... hellip; It can also try either way-cases – cases which can be tried either in the magistrates' courts or in crown courts....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Doctrine of Precedent

rdquo; (doctrine of judicial precedent & its hierarchy of court, 2010).... The paper "the doctrine of Precedent" explains nuances of the lawful rule by which adjudicators are obligated to the admiration of precedents created by the previous judgment.... the doctrine of stare decisis is not always to be relied upon, for the courts find it necessary to overrule cases which have been hastily decided, or contrary to principle.... “It is noted that the doctrine of precedent depends for its operation upon the underlying principle that the courts form a hierarchy with each court standing in a definite position in relation to every other court....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Advantages and Disadvantages of the Doctrine of Precedent

It is a longstanding fact that the doctrine of precedent has been an integral component of… It has been contended by Duxbury that flexibility and stability are both necessary for the common law system (Waddams, 2009, p.... This is despite the fact that precedent does not bind judges to the same extent as statutes.... This requirement has been fulfilled by precedent. The common law legal system is based on precedent, which makes it possible to bring The majority of those who support precedent tend to overlook the justice seeking benefit provided by this concept, and are inclined to praise its practical value (Bader & Cleveland, 2011, p....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

One of the hallmarks of any good decision-making process is consistency: judicial precedent helps to ensure this

Taking into account a similar notion, the essay emphasizes the importance of judicial precedent in developing a hallmark in the decision making process.... In the English law, judicial precedent doctrine is used effectively as an application with regard to stare decisis, which implies that the decision in the legal cases are to be made in accordance with identical decided cases.... In the English law, judicial precedent doctrine plays an important role, with the assistance of which, effective future legal decisions are made on the basis of judgements delivered in the past identical or similar cases....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Explain the doctrine of precedent

the doctrine of precedent, also known as stare decisis, is a judicial policy requiring judges to abide by earlier judicial rulings when making their… Judges can also rely on decisions from courts in other jurisdictions when making judgments.... Judicial precedent can be applied both vertically and horizontally within a judicial system Vertical application of the doctrine of precedent involves inferior courts applying decisions from superior courts in their rulings....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Do Judges Make the Law or Find It

In common law countries, the case law left behind by the judges is used in applying to other cases that relate to the previous ones based on The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent.... It has been argued to a greater extent that The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent is an indirect way in which judges make law.... the doctrine of separation of powers stipulates that each branch of the government should not interfere with the mandate and roles of the other branch and each branch should be allowed to operate independently....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us