StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Poem Compare and Contrast - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The different elements that are a part of poetry create various responses and perspectives that are seen throughout the poem. When comparing the poems “The Manis of the Forest” and “Rain,” it can be seen that there are both similarities and differences which arise. …
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
Poem Compare and Contrast
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Poem Compare and Contrast"

Introduction The different elements that are a part of poetry create various responses and perspectives that are seen throughout the poem. When comparing the poems “The Manis of the Forest” and “Rain,” it can be seen that there are both similarities and differences which arise. The similarities are based on giving the main point to the reader while showing the conditions that are occurring in a specific situation. However, the techniques, use of terminology and the ability to make this known to the reader come from different angles.

This creates the ideologies that are associated with the poetry and the perspective that the poet gives to the viewer. Contrastive Analysis The concepts that are read in “The Manis of the Forst” begin with the idea of being lost as an animal which becomes a pet. This is read through the last two lines, which states “Each thought I have of you now brings on tears / You forest child lost to me for years” (lines 13-14). This is the main point of the poem and is driven by the other techniques in the poem.

The similar meaning is given at the end of the poem in “Rain,” as it moves from the war type situation to the natural. Throughout the poem, the writer describes the khakis, phantoms, noise and flutter that are being dodged. At the end, this instantly changes to “No satellites, no radar, no infra-red / Only the sure sense of their foot / On their land, their trails, their mountains to the sky” (lines 16-18). This is the only time that the land is mentioned and changes the perspective from the unnatural to the natural.

Both poems show the same meaning of going back to the natural element; however, different techniques are used to show this point. The difference in both poems comes from the approach to writing the basic information for the reader. In “Manis of the Forest,” there is a formula which is used to describe the situation. The main concept is written in a sonnet form, which is inclusive of 3 stanzas of 4 lines each and one stanza of two lines. The rhyme scheme is a, b, a, b, c, d, c, d, e, f, e, f, g, g.

This is combined with techniques for description to show the loss of the natural and the idea of being an orphan. The poet does this in a narrative type form, which describes his observations of the mantis. The main point can be seen when the narrator states “You sought for mother now I realize / each time I switched the light to give you food / embrace me with long arms and searching eyes / to save yourself from total orphanhood” (lines 9-12). The narrative description is able to show the unnatural of the light, the orphan like state of the mantis and the response from the narrator.

These descriptions in story like form emphasize the main point of the poem. The techniques in the free form have to take a different role, specifically because there isn’t the constraint of rhyme scheme or stanza to place the main point. The poem, instead of divided by the rhymes and forms are depicted with one description per stanza. In each stanza, there is a description of the situation, actions and the setting, all which show the depiction of the narration. “It was no use pulling ponchos out / They made such noise and flutter / Like quail spooked to low flight by hunters” (lines 7-9).

This is an example of one thought, followed by a metaphor to describe the situation. The stanza then ends and moves to another stanza which carries this same formula. Instead of the ideas being placed into a rhyme or narrative form, it is based on describing a situation in each stanza to prove the main point. Critical Response When looking at both of the poems, it can be seen that there is the need to change the way in which the author writes down the main ideas. Both of the poems send a similar message and theme of moving outside of the natural.

However, the techniques that are used to show this differ, specifically because of the decision to use free form or a specific formula. In the formula based poem, there is a change with description, narrative form and the decision to describe things so it fits inside the stanzas and rhyme scheme. In the free form, this changes with the author having freedom to place one description in one stanza, which moves to the next stanza for the next description. This opens to different elements of narrative, metaphor and poetic responses.

While both are effective, each also contrasts in how the message is given to the reader. The ability to write poetry so that it conveys a specific message can be seen from different formulas and elements. When comparing a free form to a formula based poem, it can be seen that the emphasis of the main point is as effective in each. The universal theme can then be expected to remain the same, no matter what techniques are chosen by the author. However, this also means that different elements and techniques are required to show the meaning of a poem and to allow the reader to get the emphasis of the poem and the main meaning.

To convey a specific message, the author also has to use the different techniques that are able to get the point across about the poem.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Poem Compare and Contrast Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1420726-poem-compare-and-contrast
(Poem Compare and Contrast Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1420726-poem-compare-and-contrast.
“Poem Compare and Contrast Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1420726-poem-compare-and-contrast.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Poem Compare and Contrast

Treatment of Love in the Following Romantic Poem and Extract from a Romantic Poem

As a long narrative poem, the poet has much scope for setting the scene, telling the story and introducing meaningful characters and their personalities or condition, and to work towards a climax in whatever way he chooses.... Any piece of poetry must arouse a personal response in the reader, and with a universal topic like 'love', there is no doubt that both these pieces succeed in eliciting that response....
8 Pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review

Analysis of Poems Assembled with Natural and Elemental References by Emily Dickson

The vivid contrast of earth, or the physical sum of all things, against the backdrop of a disembodied name which is far removed from tangibility, allows the reader to derive an essential meaning based on physical existence and spirituality on a fundamental level.... References to nature and the pieces of the earth which… Choosing poems which are richly assembled with natural and elemental references will together, form a pattern of continuity even in varying authors. The first poem chosen for This piece is fundamentally significant and is named first as it is written in such a way that it capably yet briefly discusses virtually any and all things relevant to life on this earth....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Explicating two poems - compare and contrast

In contrast to each poem on the other, Mitchell's poem is a petite, specific and a concise one which sounds especially optimistic.... In contrast, Riley's poem is a extensive with a comprehensive description of the place where Riley has spent his childhood.... The On the whole, to evaluate and compare poems written by two dissimilar poets on a similar matter can prove to be quite an intricate task.... Mitchell's poem; “The Love will Start with a Word about Children” is a radiant poem that celebrate children and their and prospects....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Compare and contrast both poems

compare and contrast Two Poems.... The main theme in both pieces is the contrast between this very wealthy man who… Both pieces use the same shocking phrase that describes how Richard Cory “put a bullet through his head” (Robinson, line 16; Simon, line 26).... The main theme in both pieces is the contrast between this very wealthy man who lived in great luxury, and the poverty of ordinary people, who could hardly afford enough food to eat, and who envied his lifestyle....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Comparison of William Wordsworth and Galway Kinnell

Kinnell's long poem which is in a book form, The Book of Nightmares, is merely an account of his experiences during the civil rights movements, his protests against the Vietnam War and his overall involvement and contribution.... He was one of the most famous English Romantic poets....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Compare and contrast the movie and poem Howl

The film ‘Howl' is based on the poem ‘Howl' by Ginsberg, but is set in the In this essay, an attempt is being made to compare and contrast the poem ‘Howl' against the film by the same name and analyze the contrasts and similarities found in both these media.... The poem though long drawn out and enduring captures destruction in its many forms.... (Roger Ebert, 2010) The young generation was primarily Ginsberg's audience because they were able to identify themselves with it, since the poem was capable of touching the inner core of their being....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Death in Whitmans and Dickinsons Poetry

The poem under analysis is rather succinct and laconic, yet it reveals the general attitude towards death and its image in the poet's mind.... The poem begins with the moment when death “kindly stopped for” (Dickinson) the narrator.... Being rather different in their ways of expressing their feelings and perceptions, Emily Dickinson and Walt Whitman are yet considered to be the most illustrious American poets of the 19th century – and even in general....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Metaphysical Poems and Cavaliar Poetry

In Andrew Marvell's poem ‘A Dialogue between the Soul and Body', a large part of the stanza might be constituted by a single sentence presenting several thoughts at once: “Which, stretch'd upright, impales me so // That mine own precipice I go; // And warms and moves this needless frame, // (A fever could but do the same)...
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us