StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Is capital punishment still a relevant form of punishment in today's society - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Listen closely to the debate about the capital punishment in the United States and you will discover a disagreement about where the practice is located in a map of American values and practices. In the last century the validity of capital punishment has become a debatable issue…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.3% of users find it useful
Is capital punishment still a relevant form of punishment in todays society
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Is capital punishment still a relevant form of punishment in today's society"

Download file to see previous pages

By contrast, the abolitionists see the impact of executions as a statement of pervasive importance about the relationship between the government and the individual. (James, 33-40) Abolitionists in the United States view capital punishment as a fundamental political issue; proponents usually assert that the question is neither fundamental nor political. As far as the question of relevance of capital punishment still as a form of punishment in today's society is concerned, it is simply refutable.

Though there are many people who support capital punishment, yet they are few and they have not strong justifications to present in its favor. On the other hand, the civilized world has a firm stand and argumentative rebuttal of capital punishment in the contemporary era. While this is just one way in which the disputants talk past each other in the capital punishment debate, this particular disagreement helps to explain other aspects of the capital punishment dispute. . National government and constitutional values have little direct influence on most punishment decisions.

If the availability of death as a criminal punishment were a garden-variety choice of punishment option, state and local power over them would be consistent with an important American tradition. If, on the other hand, one regards capital punishment as a fundamental moral and political question, the national government and constitutional values are the appropriate vehicles for decisions. (Jan, 110-12)The Flaws in Implementation of Capital PunishmentThe proper way of characterizing the capital punishment may be an important question but it is not a difficult one.

Our history, the recent history of other developed nations, and even the importance that the proponents of the penalty attach to it are powerful evidence that the capital punishment is an issue of transcendent importance, one that is principally moral and political. (Zimring, 78-82)There are certain reservations from some corners of public discussions as regards to the unreliable evidences that caused capital punishment but consequently proved false. It is hard to believe how prosecutors can admit evidence from unreliable sources.

In some cases witnesses have later recanted or disavowed their testimonies claiming that they had only made their statements under pressure or coercion from prosecution and law enforcement. These false testimonies proved to be the condemning evidence in many cases. Lastly, most of the people charged in capital cases cannot afford defense attorneys. The appointed defense counsels in several cases have exhibited incompetence. Some of them did not even look for or missed important evidence that proved the innocence of their clients.

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Is capital punishment still a relevant form of punishment in today's Essay”, n.d.)
Is capital punishment still a relevant form of punishment in today's Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525784-is-capital-punishment-still-a-relevant-form-of-punishment-in-todays-society
(Is Capital Punishment Still a Relevant Form of Punishment in today'S Essay)
Is Capital Punishment Still a Relevant Form of Punishment in today'S Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525784-is-capital-punishment-still-a-relevant-form-of-punishment-in-todays-society.
“Is Capital Punishment Still a Relevant Form of Punishment in today'S Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525784-is-capital-punishment-still-a-relevant-form-of-punishment-in-todays-society.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is capital punishment still a relevant form of punishment in today's society

The Federal Sentencing Reform Act of 1984 and Social Control

he US Congress played a slight and indirect role in federal sentencing for about a century or so by vesting into the sentencing judge an unbarred discretion to figure out the appropriate punishment from usually a diverse ambit of potential sentences as been described by law.... That invariably involved judge deciding an extensive punishment of long duration and the parole board contemplating release on the grounds of adequate rehabilitation.... This rendered the judge to be in total control of sentencing and it was up to the judge only to envisage various aspects of sentencing the relevant aggravating and mitigating circumstances and how these all factors jointly contributed to the commissioning of the sentence....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Death Penalty in the USA

There have been conflicting thoughts on the egalitarian thought of punishment.... It has been noted that for the victims family, knowing that the killer of their daughter/son has proven to a form of closure for them.... Some people have said that by allowing the killing of a criminal, it will only teach others that revenge is what capital punishment is all about.... There have been accusatory remarks towards those that believe in capital punishment, implying that it is used as revenge....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Crime Prevention, Disorder, and Community Safety

This would mean that the contemporary society and the politicians who want the people's support are now demanding more punishment for criminals and other offenders (Matthews, 2005).... Moreover, David Garland (2001) also claims that the contemporary society is now witnessing the advent of an era of punitiveness (as cited in Matthews, 2005: 179).... Harsher sentencing and increased use of imprisonment, 'three strikes' and mandatory minimum sentencing laws; 'truth in sentencing' and parole release restrictions; 'no frills' prison laws and 'austere prisons'; retribution in juveniles court and the imprisonment of children; the revival of chain gangs and corporal punishment; boot camps and supermax prisons; the multiplication of capital offenses and executions; community notification laws and pedophile registers; zero tolerance policies and Anti-Social Behavior Orders....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Crime, Justice, and Punishment

procured from society after one's birth.... Justice within a society is not all about being fair but also holds a great deal of importance on being just and timely.... Justice thus holds supreme importance for these brave men as they are the ones who lay the foundation for the society to be a part of the equal rights and hence the fairness fable in general.... The concepts of civil rights and of civil law are both functions of the concept of civil society whereby it is that bubble of private action free of government control....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Evaluate the claim that we should seek to abolish imprisonment

Imprisonment, as a major form of punishment to control increasing rate of crime and establish the rule of law in society, has been acknowledged by social scientists, criminologists, jurists and administrative systems since inception of human civilization.... Imprisonment is widely regarded, perhaps, as the “strongest form of punishment” after death penalty and mostly offered to people accused of culpable offences (Coughlin, 1991, p.... Several orms of punishment are introduced, according to jurisprudential rational, to control such rate of crime and protect the basic rights of common people within a socio-cultural context....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Issues on Criminal Justice in the 18th Century

The essay "Issues on Criminal Justice in the 18th Century" presents the change in the systems of punishment that occurred in the 18th century, what drove those changes, the innovations that were in effect and how the impact of these changes affect the systems of punishment even in the present day.... It was thought that hard labor would be able to reform criminals, making their reintegration into society possible.... rime is a part of culture and society that has existed for as long as we have existed as a civilization....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Way in Which European Countries Develop Their Codes of Punishment

With rehabilitation rates low and repeat offenders high, the course of prosecution and the method of punishment.... In this example, the instability of handing out of punishment can be studied and weighed in regard to the effect this has on victims of crime.... While punishment is considered a debt to society, the victim of a crime, especially a violent crime, finds a need to become a part of that decision, even if it is only in the perception of participation....
22 Pages (5500 words) Annotated Bibliography

Punishment and Modern Society

The author of the "Punishment and Modern society" paper argues that the change of society's stance on the prison system to one of support and belief in the success of these institutions would improve the social dissociation experienced by former inmates as well.... Its evolution over the ages is connected to a number of needs that are required from a successful society and thus it cannot be ignored (Brown, 2009).... The question of whether imprisonment is an acceptable means of society is associated with other social developmental needs as well such as, what are the preferred solutions alternative to imprisonment and whether they are practically applicable to today's modern society....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us