StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Free Will and Personal Responsibility - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
People are given the gift of freewill. But we also know that our culture, education and the values taught to us greatly influence how we make our decisions. In that aspect, can we say that our will is totally free Or is our will always bound be the influences of everything that surrounds us hence we are never free
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful
Free Will and Personal Responsibility
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Free Will and Personal Responsibility"

Download file to see previous pages

To prove the superman theory, they murdered a fourteen year-old boy named Bobby Franks. Also, they committed the murder of Franks to prove that they were intelligent enough to outsmart the police and create the perfect crime. However, because of the negligence of leaving behind Leopold's glasses near the dead body, the police was able to prove that they were the perpetrator of the crime. Ultimately, they had been convicted for the crime that they committed. The defense counsel of Leopold and Loeb presented a closing argument justifying the murder committed against Franks.

The main argument of the closing speech is that Leopold and Loeb's act of murdering Franks was a necessary consequence of their background, their upbringing and the principles of Nietzsche. According to the defense counsel, all these factors drove them to killing another person. The combinations of said factors afforded no other result other than the horrific crime committed. As such, Leopold and Loeb could not be held responsible for their actions. Therefore, they should not be punished for killing Franks.

To support this argument the lawyer presented the three points. First, Loeb's and Leopold's upbringing served as a breeding ground for a twisted sense of morality. Loeb was raised by a governess who pushed him too hard on his studies. It was because of the strictness of the governess that Loeb was swayed into rebellion. And the form of rebellion that he took is to read detective stories that were forbidden to him. Loeb's fascination lead to him to observe that in all these stories, the detective always wins.

The detective always figures out the puzzle to the crime. Because of this, he became challenged. He became captivated and obsessed to formulating the perfect crime - one that may not be solved by the brightest detective. Leopold on the other hand was an intellectual. Because of this, he was accelerated in school. On the downside, he failed to develop this emotional part of his being. He was so smart that he took a liking to Philosophy, particularly the teachings of Nietzsche. And Nietzsche believed that an intelligent man is above the law and morality.

The second thing that the lawyer pointed out is that with the fascination in detective stories, it is but understandable that a highly intellectual person would be challenged to formulate an undetectable crime. They would prove that the detectives do not always win. From the lawyer's point of view, because of this challenge, it was natural that they create the perfect crime. Hence, Loeb cannot be faulted for his creation. The strictness of his governess and the challenge brought by detective stories was to be blamed for his action.

The third point that the lawyer raised for Loeb and Leopold's defense is the teaching of Nietzsche. Nietzsche was strong in his teachings that the intelligent man is not bound by the ordinary rules in morality. Than in fact, the superman is the law by himself. Leopold firmly believe this. And because of which, what else can be the result but a series of acts defying the law and morals The last defense that the lawyer raised was that of insanity. He claimed that who in their right mind would exchange

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Free Will and Personal Responsibility Case Study”, n.d.)
Free Will and Personal Responsibility Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532535-free-will-and-personal-responsibility
(Free Will and Personal Responsibility Case Study)
Free Will and Personal Responsibility Case Study. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532535-free-will-and-personal-responsibility.
“Free Will and Personal Responsibility Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532535-free-will-and-personal-responsibility.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Free Will and Personal Responsibility

What Are The Implications For Social Workers In Combating Re-Offending Among Children And Young People

What are the implications for social workers in combating re-offending among children and young people?... ... his report intends to provide a description of the scenario among the youth and children and the tendency of juvenile delinquents to resort back to offending.... … What are the implications for social workers in combating re-offending among children and young people?...
21 Pages (5250 words) Dissertation

Humanistic and Existential Aspects of Personality

Its aspiration is to bring solid empirical research into areas such as well being, flow, personal strengths, wisdom, creativity, psychological health and characteristics of positive groups and institutions.... On an individual level, the aim is to identify the constituents of the 'good life' and the personal qualities needed to be a good person....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Human Behavior in The Brain on Trial by Eagleman

He says, “Because we did not choose the factors that affected the formation and structure of our brain, the concepts of Free Will and Personal Responsibility begin to sprout question marks” (Eagleman).... He asserts that as we become increasingly aware of the diseases, disorders, and even genetic qualities responsible for inspiring violent and deviant behaviors, our current conception of free will and the equality of people will be outmoded.... Eagleman also goes so far as to say that any assumption of free will is questionable, since our genetic and neurological inheritance is in place from conception, and that inheritance will determine our likelihood of being aggressive, deviant, violent, and criminal....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

What are your academic goals for study in the US

These studies will carry with them the peripheral issues of ethics and social responsibility.... Living and learning with the people of the United States will give me an invaluable personal experience.... Standardizing the world's technological infrastructure will help guarantee the free and unimpeded communication between the people of the world....
2 Pages (500 words) Personal Statement

Ethnic American

But they also agree to the fact that male and the female should share the responsibility of raising a child together and sharing the duties of housework.... We are discriminated as a whole and nobody pays attention to our personal values and they do not even look at the fact whether we are capable of educating ourselves and that we do not posses the drive to rise higher than our immediate circumstances and our willing to work hard to achieve our goal and further improve ourselves....
3 Pages (750 words) Personal Statement

Determinism versus Free Will

As Einstein's position suggested, one might profit from challenging the belief that free will and determinism represent polar opposite extremes of a single dimension.... ight a similar reformulation of the free will-determinism question stimulate new solutions to an antinomy that has perplexed thinkers for more than 25 centuries Before sketching a re-conceptualization of the free will versus determinism issue, this article will offer a working scientist's or a counseling practitioner's specification of the issues--not a philosopher's reformulation of this seemingly everlasting controversy....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Free Market

free Market.... Let your eyes be full of understanding, let your heart be full of love, may you ever remain free from conflicts- this is all that the humanity needs!... The authors of the IASB Conceptual Framework are meeting and will continue to meet till they hopefully complete the allotted task in the year 2010, as envisaged at present....
2 Pages (500 words) Personal Statement

Methodist/Wesleyan Beliefs and Teachings

The author examines the Methodist religion which belonged to the Protestant Christian Fraternity and originated from John Wesley's evangelistic teaching of the scriptures during the 18th century in Britain and spread across the United States and to other countries … The Methodist had deep faith in the conviction that God the Father sent his Son into the world in order to save sinners....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us