StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Ethics, Language and Argument: A Rhetorical Analysis - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In ‘Secrecy and Moral Choice’ Bok explores the complex moral question of whether society should be based on secrecy or if it should be left as an element of personal choice. While this initially appears a simple formulation, upon philosophical investigation one understands…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Ethics, Language and Argument: A Rhetorical Analysis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ethics, Language and Argument: A Rhetorical Analysis"

Download file to see previous pages

essay explores the main points of Bok’s argument, notably his contention that secrecy is a contingent to the very structure of society, and argues the extent that the argument is sound and convincing varies in different degress. In ‘Secrecy and Moral Choice’ four hypothetical societies are put forward, each with varying degrees of transparency, or the lack thereof, of secrecy. The first society only a deity is able to keep secrets; in the second society only you are able to view other people’s secrets; in the third society nobody can keep secrets from people who desire to know them; finally, in the forth society everyone can keep secrets so that they are impenetrable by others.

The article briefly considers the small minority that would prefer to live in one of the hypothetical societies, and then questions whether it would be beneficial to live in a society with a complete lack of secrecy. In this regard it quotes Eckhart who states, “We call him a good man who reveals himself to others, and in so doing, is of use to them” (Bok, pg. 2). However, as the article progresses it argues that secrecy is a fundamental element of both society and personal identity; “it is not inconceivable that the end result of the shift to the third imagined society would be chaos” (Bok, pg. 3). Bok argues both in favor and against varying degrees of secrecy.

In defense of secrecy he puts forward four main points: identity, plans, action, and property. Towards the end of the essay Bock indicates his argument against secrecy, as it can cause character malformations as the individual doesn’t receive the appropriate criticism. Finally, he indicates his own personal approach that includes a hybrid formation of truthfulness and secrecy. To some extent it’s evident that Bok is utilizing the four hypothetical societies as not merely a thought experiment, but as a means of examining the extent that each of the hypothetical societies represents an element of our own

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ethics, Language and Argument: A Rhetorical Analysis Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1568073-ethics-language-and-argument-a-rhetorical-analysis
(Ethics, Language and Argument: A Rhetorical Analysis Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1568073-ethics-language-and-argument-a-rhetorical-analysis.
“Ethics, Language and Argument: A Rhetorical Analysis Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1568073-ethics-language-and-argument-a-rhetorical-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethics, Language and Argument: A Rhetorical Analysis

Persuasive Narrative in Rhetoric

However, there are principles of narrative analysis that help in analyzing a narrative with the purpose of proper understanding.... There are three main principles of narrative analysis.... Some narratives could be ironic, and others rhetorical.... This essay "Persuasive Narrative in Rhetoric" will considerably focus on pathos, logos, ethos, and their individual effect on persuasion in regards to narrative rationale....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Cant We All Just Stop Thinking about the Children by David Penberthy

What the writer has done is that he has created a psychological vantage point as per which he projects himself as an authority on reason by using a very strong language and has degraded the concern about child issues to the point that anybody evincing such a concern stands to be taken for a fool.... Can't We All Just Stop Thinking about the Children by David Penberthy- A Critical analysis The morbidly hilarious article Can't We All Just Stop Thinking About Children by David Penberthy, published in The Punch tends to put forward the argument that the contemporary parents and statutory agencies are way too much concerned about the issues associated with children, who going by the current times marked by excessive stress and shortage of time, should be dedicating their intelligence to more pragmatic issues (Penberthy 2012)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Textual Analysis of Albert Einsteins Why Socialism

The analysis of biological and cultural constitution of a human-being and certain unalterable social conditions advance the author to the probable resolution of the problem.... The objective of the given work is to find out what was Albert Einstein's primary purpose or argument in "Why Socialism", to offer support for the answer and show if and how he was successful or unsuccessful in achieving his goal by utilizing different linguistic techniques among which predominates rhetorical one. … Originally published in the first issue of Monthly Review in May 1949 Albert Einstein's essay "Why Socialism" presents a set of social and political claims....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Rhetorical Analysis

By appealing to the emotionality and sentiments of the… He uses ethos in his arguments to appeal to the morality of the audience, and also makes use of logos to present a logical situation and solution to the issue at hand. The rhetorical Firstly, the exigence, or problem presented is the issue of an abundance of poor children of beggar women present on the streets of Ireland, and the burdens that these children bear upon the countries economy and poverty stricken parents....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Rhetorical Analysis

This makes his rhetorical strategies strong as processes such as auditing, and staff satisfaction has a correlation in the operation and performance of a business to the satisfaction of customer's satisfaction.... However, there is need to examine the accountability of those responsible for process and staffs satisfaction and their outcome to customer's satisfaction in order to determine the effectiveness of Ballou and Heighter argument....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Rhetorical Act: Thinking, Speaking and Writing Critically

This paper "The rhetorical Act: Thinking, Speaking and Writing Critically" discusses the Art of Rhetoric that has been in practice since the time of Plato and Aristotle.... Rhetoric is the ability to be able to make use of the available sources of persuasion that are available in order to win a case....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

A Broad Standardization

What the writer has done is that he has created a psychological vantage point as per which he projects himself as an authority on reason by using a powerful language and has degraded the concern about child issues to the fact that anybody evincing such a situation stands to be taken for a fool.... he writer resorts to an array of rhetorical misplay and logical fallacies to make his point.... Though there is no denying the fact that David Puberty intended the article to be humorous if one also tends to take into consideration the sources in which it got published, the irony is that not only this article comes about as being a wee bit spooky and disturbing, but the writer also resorts to a plethora of rhetorical devices and logical fallacies to accrue interest and support from the readers....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Application of Rhetoric Theory

This report "Application of Rhetoric Theory" discusses the study and analysis of the artifacts.... Despite having been written many years after Weaver's article on the role played by cultural rhetoric in society, the views raised by Weasel advocates the need to apply rhetorical reasoning in society....
10 Pages (2500 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us