StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Critique epidemiologic articles - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The main hypothesis being tested in this research is that intake of a diet high in animal fat and especially fat from the red meat and which is lower in fiber is associated with increased risk of colorectal adenoma and precursors of cancer (Giovannucci, et al, 1994).
The…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Critique epidemiologic research articles
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Critique epidemiologic articles"

Critique epidemiologic research articles Affiliation: I. Objective or Hypothesis A.What are the objectives of the study, or what hypotheses are to be tested?The main hypothesis being tested in this research is that intake of a diet high in animal fat and especially fat from the red meat and which is lower in fiber is associated with increased risk of colorectal adenoma and precursors of cancer (Giovannucci, et al, 1994).B. To what population does the investigator intend to generalize these findings?

The study population is the US male health professionals including dentists, podiatrists, pharmacists, optometrists, osteopaths and veterinarians. II. Design of the StudyA. Is the study descriptive, analytical (cross-sectional, case control, cohort) or experimental?This is a longitudinal study which takes 6 years of following up with the study cohort in order to come up with extensive and conclusive results. B. How was the sample selected? What, if any, selection bias exists? What strategies might minimize such bias?

The researchers selected male health professionals between the ages of 40-75 years and mailed them questionnaires and those who responded formed the base population of the research. There was no selection bias as all the health professionals were fitting the cohort were given a chance to participate through provision of a questionnaire. C. Is there a control or comparison group? What is the source of this group? Is this group appropriate? What group might be more appropriate?The control group included people selected randomly in the Boston area who filled the questionnaires with their dietary intake for 2 weeks.

The group is appropriate because they have different lifestyle from the health professionals and their knowledge of the healthy diets and cancer differs from that of health professionals, in short they are complete opposites. III. Observations A. Are there clear definitions of the terms used, including diagnostic criteria, measurements and outcome?There are no clear definitions of the terms used in the article leaving the readers to guess the meanings of the terms as best as they can. B. Was the method of classification or of measurement consistent for all the subjects relevant to the objectives of the investigation?

Are there possible biases in measurement? If so, what provisions were made to deal with them?The methods of measurement were different for the study group as well as the control group. The researchers administered the diet questionnaires to the control group which were strict n the amount of calories on each specific diet record on a weekly basis for the 2 weeks but none of that was done to the control group. This was made through carrying out a follow-up to the study group after every two years. C. Are the observations valid, reliable or reproducible?

The observations of the study group are reproducible as the research team carried out a follow-up of its study group for 6 years and hence in the end they achieved their conclusive results. They can also be said to be valid as they were carried out in a scientific manner. On whether they are reliable or not, the subject is up for discussion because of the lack of a control group to compare results with for the 6 years. IV. Presentation of FindingsA. Are the findings presented clearly, objectively, and in sufficient detail to enable the readers to make their own judgment?

Yes, the findings are very clearly put and explanation made using simple words so that it can be understood by all readers. With the findings simplified, readers are able to make their own judgment. B. Are the findings internally consistent? That is, do the numbers add up properly? Are the different tables clear and the results consistent among them?The numbers in the different tables add up correctly and indicate consistency. This is easy to deduce because of the clarity of the results even though they cannot easily be understood by layman. V. AnalysisA.

Are the data worthy of statistical analysis? If so, are the methods of statistical analysis appropriate? Is the analysis correctly performed and interpreted?Yes the data requires statistical analysis because they involve quantity in numbers of fat and energy. The analysis used is multivariate which is appropriate considering there are several sets of data being analyzed. The analysis and interpretation even though longer is correct. VI. ConclusionsA. Which conclusions are justified by the findings?

Which are not? Are the conclusions relevant to the questions posed by the investigators?The conclusion justified is that which supports the hypothesis. The conclusion about red meat absorption and the acid content has not been analyzed in the data and hence is not appropriate to be made without research. The first conclusion which supports the hypothesis is relevant. VII. Constructive SuggestionsAssume you are planning an investigation to answer the questions put in the study. If they have not been clearly put by the authors, frame them in an appropriate manner.

Suggest a practical design, criteria for observations, and type of analysis that would provide reliable and valid information relevant to the questions under study.The research question should be: does the increased fat and red meat diet with reduced fiber lead contribute to colon cancer in the US male health professionals? The best design should be experiment with observations being made through video cameras and the analysis should still be multivariate. With clear data, the results can be declared to be valid and reliable.

ReferencesGiovannucci, E., Rimm, E., Stampfer, M., Colditz, G., Ascherio, A. and Willett, W. (May 1st, 1994). “Intake of Fat, Meat, and Fiber in Relation to Risk of Colon Cancer in Men.” Cancer Research, vol. 54, pp. 2390-2397.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critique epidemiologic research articles Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1657404-critique-epidemiologic-research-articles
(Critique Epidemiologic Research Articles Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1657404-critique-epidemiologic-research-articles.
“Critique Epidemiologic Research Articles Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1657404-critique-epidemiologic-research-articles.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critique epidemiologic research articles

Epidemiology

The beginning issue of a cohort study is the notes of wholesome topics with and without exposure to the putative agency or the attribute being studied.... Individuals revealed to the agency under study (index subjects) are pursued over time and their wellbeing rank is discerned and noted throughout the course of the study....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Proposal

Epidemiological Issues

The article "Epidemiological Issues" focuses on the assessment of the incidence of onboard injury among the Sri Lankan flight assistants along with explaining the determinants of onboard injury.... It aims at the evaluation of the article “Incidence and predictors of onboard injuries among Sri Lankan flight attendants”....
7 Pages (1750 words) Article

Critique article

Of, particular importance are the empirical evidences that built the case for the research hypothesis and the research framework.... Literature Review:The section reviewing previous literature on the research subject is practically non-existent.... But the details are not sufficient to establish a gap that the article could fill and develop a research framework accordingly.... ethodology:The methods section did not specify an overarching methodology that could have outlined a clear research framework or effectively defined research concepts....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Lin Article Critique

Critical research analyses of documented research studies facilitate the development of knowledge and understanding of how certain studies were conducted.... This also involves the evaluation of validity and reliability of the… dy as documented as well as other research aspects such as methodologies, design and sampling appropriateness and ethical compliance-just to mention, but a few (Marczyk, DeMatteo & Festinger, 2010).... This paper critically reviews various aspects of a study focused on determining research Critique      Introduction Critical research analyses of documented research studies facilitate the development of knowledge and understanding of how certain studies were conducted....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Article Critique

Question 4: The study of Jehovah Witness can be used for future research on behavioral change within this population group to deriver to the society and culture more information that are not applicable and thus able to curb the ones may cause death to an individual.... Question 1: According to the article on Jehovah's Witnesses' Views on Health Care, the behavior theory that is used is of reasoned action since the theory considers behavior consequences before performing the particular behavior and this is the reason why Jehovah Witnesses… The theory was selected so that the individuals who follow the doctrine will reason beyond the normal life lived in the earth (Donohue and Krasner, 1995)....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Article Critique

Inclusion of students with disabilities has been a topical issue and researchers as well as educators are trying to evaluate benefits and disadvantages (if any) of this approach. What are the research… Koster, Pijl, Nakken and Van Houten (2010) put two research questions.... What are the research questions?... Koster, Pijl, Nakken and Van Houten (2010) put two research questions.... Overall, 590 students (both males and females) of first, second and third grades (including 237 students with mild disabilities) were involved in the research....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Critique Two Articles 0.5 page each

Sample size Critique Two articles [Teacher 27th March Article This article is about effects of promoting health among teens on dietary, physical activity, and substance use knowledge and behaviors for African American adolescents.... This research has been conducted in Eastern cities of the US and hence it is limited to the people of that area.... How to critique A Journal Article....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Meeting of the Minds on WRMSD

This research study “Meeting of the Minds on WRMSD” intends to provide a framework about the importance of creating awareness of the implications of not reporting WRMSI amongst sonographers.... As a result, this purpose of this research is based on the importance of sonographers.... This research proposal there the ore seeks to investigate the consequences associated with sonographers to report WRMSI to their employers....
20 Pages (5000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us