StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Find a newspaper article or scholarly journal article (from 2008 to present date) that illustrates an ethical discussion that involves allocation of health care resources such as challenges that fall within the category of distributive justice. The article by Atul Gawande (2009) in published in the New Yorker raises fundamental issues about the way American citizens receive their health care from their local hospitals and doctors…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.2% of users find it useful
The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker"

Download file to see previous pages

Some scholars suggest that the system has drifted out of control: “Through no planned design or evil intent, our health care system has evolved in ways that better serve a myriad of economic, professional, and political interests than those of patients and families, and the larger public” (Mechanic, 2006, p. ix). Gawande, however, sees a much bleaker picture, and suggests that there are areas in America where doctors and administrators are financially tied into provision, and that this encourages massive amounts of over-treatment, with no benefit to patients.

Gawande’s article describes a huge discrepancy in the per capita costs of medical care in two comparable districts, McAllen and El Paso, Texas, while there is no evidence that the higher cost location (McAllen) offers better care or achieves better results. This gives rise to a serious ethical problem: in El Paso patients have much lower rates of access to all kinds of tests and treatments, while in McAllen, they have much higher rates. The variation is due to doctor behavior, and not down to the demographics of the citizens, since the two regions are very similar.

This is the kind of situation that led to the passing of the 2010 Health Care Reform bill which aims to extend health coverage to from 83% to 95% of the legally resident population. (Tumulty, 2010, p. 1) Unfortunately, however, huge variation in the way that this money is spent will mean that a fair and equal service is not likely to happen. From the point of view of justice, or fairness, such unequal practices cannot be defended, since all American citizens should have equal access to the benefits of our modern technologies.

From a utilitarian point of view, there is a deviation from best practice, since in the McAllen hospitals there is little effort to gain the greatest benefit to patients for the lowest cost. Increasing the amount of testing in order to maximise revenue is the very opposite of ethical behaviour on the part of institutions where doctors earn more for ordering more procedures and tests. Gawande suggests that the problem lies with the structures of delivery, and describes the McAllen healthcare model as “as system that has no brakes” (Gawanda, p. 14). He cites the example of the Mayo clinic, where doctors receive a fixed salary, as a potential solution.

Fewer scans are done, and more discussion between doctors takes place to minimize unnecessary treatments, all of which come with risks as well as benefits, and to try to ensure that patients have what they need, rather than what can be sold to them for profit. There is little incentive to cherry pick patients in this kind of system, and hospitals which follow this style find that overall costs are lower, and quality of care goes up. This analysis takes a refreshing look at the way the whole system is set up, and this gives the reader an overview of things rather than just the view of an economist, or a health professional, or an administrator.

It highlights the error that patients, and some doctors, often make, in thinking that more testing is always good. The point is to do what is the best for the patient, and not what sustains the system. If there was more of this kind of benchmarking across hospitals with comparable patient characteristics, then perhaps more could be done to eliminate wasteful

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker Term Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/nursing/1436572-find-a-newspaper-article-or-scholarly-journal
(The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker Term Paper)
https://studentshare.org/nursing/1436572-find-a-newspaper-article-or-scholarly-journal.
“The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker Term Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/nursing/1436572-find-a-newspaper-article-or-scholarly-journal.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker

Liberal Institutionalist Perspectives

Liberalism is simply one of the philosophies of political science.... It emphasises on the main objective of politics which is individual liberty.... This means that it emphasises on educating people on their rights.... Liberalists on the other hand are people who advocate for all the policies of individual rights....
10 Pages (2500 words) Article

Drucker - New Organizations Article

The new ways of information system generated through the application of computers will reduce the man power requirement.... (1988), the Incoming of the new Organization, Harvard Business Review (January-February)... Drucker is well known for his contributions on management practices and thought....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Freedom vs. Security in the US

According to the annual report of the new York City Police Department (NYCPD), it was stated that people do have a strong desire to gain security by losing a bit of their… However, it has been viewed that in today's context the limitation for gaining security has been violated to an great extent resulting in arising conflicts amidst the government and the civilians (Cohen, “ Edward Snowden: A Modern-Day Daniel Ellsberg, Except for One Key new Article INTRODUCTION The debate relating to the freedom vs....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

I have an article need to be reviewed

The authors have tried to study the institutional changes in European countries, namely Britain, France, and Sweden, to come up with a new explanation for these changes and the… The industrial history of these countries is considered and the nature and direction of the changes is turned towards one common point by taking support from the theories and works of other writers....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Does Charity Remain a Valuable Legal Concept for the UK in 2006 and for the Future

"Does Charity Remain a Valuable Legal Concept for the UK in 2006 and for the Future" paper argues that the introduction and the application of the new Act will help the charities to be better organized, the trustees to have specific roles and increased protection regarding their liability....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Effect of Immigration on New York City

This article “Effect of Immigration on new York City” examines the nature of these recent immigrant flows and their impact on the city's population.... More than any other city in the nation, new York's identity has been shaped by the hundreds of thousands of immigrants who have settled here.... (Martin, 5)The 2000s marked a resurgence in European immigration to new York City, and a decline in the share of Caribbean flows.... The Caribbean comprised 33 percent of the flow of immigrants to the city, but only 12 percent of the flow to the nation in the 2005-2009 periods....
10 Pages (2500 words) Article

Social Worker Administrator

This paper ''Social Worker Administrator'' tells that Individuals' quality of life depends on coping with real life challenges such as conflicts, unemployment, and alike.... Today's life has been characterized by many of these challenges; some require more than just the family's resolution question, but a specialist's help....
13 Pages (3250 words) Article

The Impact of Housing Reforms & the Real Estate Market

The difficult balance that must be managed by the country is between the growing expectations and identity of the new Chinese middle class, the political aspects of planning and control, and the economic drivers that impact land and housing planning and use.... (Gross, 2009) Opposing these strong conservative forces in Chinese society is the push for a more liberalized and globalized economy, encouraged by the government and enthusiastically embraced by the people....
15 Pages (3750 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us