StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Manifest Destiny and the Civil War - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
MANIFEST DESTINY AND THE CIVIL WAR Expansion brought sectional antagonism to the boiling point. Perhaps the most significant social factor at work in the US in the late 1700s, and throughout the 1800s was slavery. This economic and social fact at work within society was considered, though, to be a political issue…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.6% of users find it useful
Manifest Destiny and the Civil War
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Manifest Destiny and the Civil War"

MANIFEST DESTINY AND THE CIVIL WAR Expansion brought sectional antagonism to the boiling point. Perhaps the most significant social factor at work in the US in the late 1700s, and throughout the 1800s was slavery. This economic and social fact at work within society was considered, though, to be a political issue. Legal debates and decisions were largely made to enforce the Constitutional acknowledgement of slavery, not to make rulings about slavery being right or wrong. Political solutions were sought to the question of slavery, rather than legal solutions.

Slavery also became the most significant point of division between the Northern States, and those in the South. By 1787, slavery was recognized in the Constitution (General History of the United Sates Supreme Court, accessed 2011). Slavery was not regulated within States through Congress. Until 1808, only the movement of slaves into States, or between States up to that date, was taxed and hence regulated (US Constitution: Art. I Sec. 9 Para.1). Slavery was, then, accepted as a fact which existed within States, and the federal Government restricted its involvement in the affairs of individual States.

States made their own decisions about whether they were “Free States”, or whether they would allow slavery, and Congress respected those decisions. This meant that as the United States expanded, new States were declared, and in fact could make their own decisions about whether slavery was to be allowed or not. In 1819, Missouri appealed to be included in the Confederation as a slave-owning State. This appeal was met by much resistance from the Northern States – in which Abolitionism was dominant – and the Midwestern States – where economies without slave labor would struggle against the slave-owning State economies.

But Missouri entered the Confederation as a slave-owning State in 1819. By 1847, the Courts of the United States were declaring that the Constitution was ultimate, and that slavery was a political, not a legal issue (Jones v. Van Zandt, 1847: General History of the United Sates Supreme Court, accessed 2011)). It is important to note that the Missouri Compromise – which declared that Congress could exclude slavery from Missouri Territory north of the 36-degree, 30-minute line – had been made invalid when the Kansas-Nebraska Act had been adopted on May 30, 1854, when Congress had intentionally removed itself from legislating slavery issues in territories, and stated its intention as “… not to legislate slavery into any territory or State, nor to exclude it therefrom” ((General History of the United Sates Supreme Court, accessed 2011)).

As such rulings continued States defied the Federal Government. In 1855, Wisconsin declared the fugitive slave laws unconstitutional, while judges who made rulings according to the Constitution were accused of favoring the Southern States for political reasons. By 1854 a Bill was passed to enable the building of a railroad system to cross the continent, and it expressed overtly that regions, and the people themselves, could decide on slavery issues, rather than the Federal Government. By 1856-7, however, Abolitionism in the Northern States was becoming more powerful as a political force, and the feeling was that the South was unacceptably being favored.

Within this context, the case known as The Dred Scott Case began with a lawsuit initiated by Dred Scott, a slave, against the widow of Dr Emerson, the slave owner. This petition was heard in the Missouri Circuit Court, and it was ruled that Scott was not free, despite the fact that his owner had taken him to Illinois, and to an area, now part of Minnesota, where the Northwest Ordinance of 1787, and the Missouri Compromise were in effect. Thus he had traveled to areas in which he would be regarded as a free man, not a slave, and thus had become a free man.

On appeal, in 1850, the same verdict – that Scott was not a free man – was read. And once again, the State Supreme Court, in 1852, ruled similarly, decreeing that Scott was subject to the laws of Missouri, and thus remained a slave. The Dred Scott decision determined whether the Federal Government would take ultimate power over States in the question of slavery, or not. The Supreme Court decided that by February 15th, 1857. Scott, as he was a slave in Missouri, was not a citizen and thus not entitled to sue in a US Court.

The matter of the constitutionality of the Missouri Compromise was also directly ruled upon, on March 6th, 1857. While individual States could give citizenship to whomever they liked, this State citizenship did not have to be recognized by other States, and would certainly not be recognized federally. Black slaves were not recognized as the “sovereign peoples” of the United States, referred to in the Constitution (General History of the United Sates Supreme Court, accessed 2011). Therefore, the Missouri Compromise was not to be recognized at all.

Immediate reaction from Abolitionists was to reject the ruling in its entirety. The validity and impartiality of the US Supreme Court was directly questioned. Sectionalism between Northern and Southern States, and between Abolitionists and anti-Abolitionists, as a result of this ruling, and other factors such as the continued expansion of the US and an increasing desire for slavery in individual States, grew to the point where a Civil War was inevitable. References General History of the United Sates Supreme Court and overview available online at http://www.

supremecourt.gov/ accessed July 5th, 2011 The Constitution of the United States of America: Overview available online at http://www.supremecourt.gov/ accessed July 5th, 2011 Prescribed Text: “The Sectional Debate” from The Unfinished Nation (Chapter 13) Prescribed Text: “The Crisis of the 1850s” from The Unfinished Nation (Chapter 13) Prescribed Text: Map Source: “Slave and Free Territories under the Compromise of 1850” from The Unfinished Nation

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Manifest Destiny and the Civil War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1427356-manifest-destiny-and-the-civil-war
(Manifest Destiny and the Civil War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/other/1427356-manifest-destiny-and-the-civil-war.
“Manifest Destiny and the Civil War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1427356-manifest-destiny-and-the-civil-war.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Manifest Destiny and the Civil War

American Foreign Policy and Manifest Destiny

America was beset by a civil war between the north and the south on the issue of slavery during the mid-19th century (that left the largest toll of lives lost in American history) but the contending forces reunified again.... RUNNING HEAD: AMERICAN FOREIGN POLICY AND manifest destiny American Foreign Policy and manifest destiny School Date American Foreign Policy and manifest destiny Brief Overview of American History North America had been inhabited by people since the Ice Age....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Manifest Destiny & Road to the Civil War & Slavery

Manifest Destiny & Road to the civil war & Slavery Slavery Slavery was one of the biggest social problems that existed in the ancient America.... It was an elongated period in the American history and political sphere that mainly aimed at the labor exploitations.... hellip; The system of slavery had influence on both in the Northern as well as the Southern regions of America but the ideas and interests at which slavery was looked as differed in both regions to a considerable extent....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Manifest Destiny Concept

nbsp; The manifest destiny concept tremendously influenced the United States policy.... To be familiar with the concept of manifest destiny, it is essential to comprehend the desire and need of the United States to expand.... He asserted that it was America's “manifest destiny to spread to the whole continent.... Imperialism was used to facilitate the manifest destiny.... There was a perception that mission and God was the path to manifest destiny....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Manifest Destiny in American History

The history of the blacks in the country, the subsequent civil war, and the relatively successful resistance movement under Martin Luther King Jr has shown that the presence of a 'powerful neighbor' is necessary to stop the degradation of values.... The United States had been formed out of destiny and can still grow as a result of it.... In the essay “manifest destiny in American History” the author discusses the United States, which is a unique country in several respects....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Manifest Destiny Concept in the US

manifest destiny was used by politicians and leaders in the 1800s to give explanations on the United States expansion.... The manifest destiny concept tremendously influenced the United States policy.... To be familiar with the concept of manifest destiny, it is essential to comprehend the desire and need of the United States to expand.... He asserted that it was America's “manifest destiny to spread to the whole continent....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Meaning of Manifest Destiny

The Aftermath of the civil war raised immense suspicion between the two nations.... Polks actions brought about the famous American-Mexican civil war.... The Mexican government responded to the annexation of Texas by confronting America through diplomatic means to the extent that it led to a civil war.... The election of Polk into office brought more manifest destiny The manifest destiny was a doctrine manifested in the 19th century and it involved the expansion of the United States....
1 Pages (250 words) Coursework

Manifest Destiny

The researcher of this study states that in the 19th century, manifest destiny was the American belief that the United States was destined to expand extensively across the North American continent, from the Atlantic seaboard to the Pacific Ocean.... nbsp;The ideology and practice of manifest destiny influenced United States Policy.... hellip; The term manifest destiny integrated the nationalist concepts of Anglo-Saxon superiority with a capitalist expansion of territory....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

American Foreign Policy and Manifest Destiny

America was beset by a civil war between the north and the south on the issue of slavery during the mid-19th century (that left the largest toll of lives lost in American history) but the contending forces reunified again.... This paper "American Foreign Policy and manifest destiny" discusses the following issue: whether or not manifest destiny is still being implemented by the US as policy over other territories and countries.... manifest destiny is a concept that gained popularity in the 19th century expounding on the notion that the United States should expand its territory toward the west of the North American continent (“manifest destiny”, 2008)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us