StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Voltage to Frequency Control vs Vector Control - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Voltage to Frequency Control vs Vector Control" compares Voltage to Frequency control and vector control in their descriptions, applications, advantages, and limitations. Versions of V/F control include the constant, closed-loop, current source, and variable voltage source systems. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.5% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Voltage to Frequency Control vs Vector Control"

Name: Instructor: Course: Date: Comparison between Voltage to Frequency Control and Vector Control INTRODUCTION Various control techniques for induction motors have been effectively implemented, facilitating the motor to be applied in a wide range of applications. Two commonly used techniques include scalar and vector, with the most popular scalar method being the voltage to frequency, also commonly referred to as volts to hertz control. Voltage to frequency (V/F) control assumes that the controlled voltage is sinusoidal, and therefore, adjusts only the frequency without regard for the spatial phase of the corresponding vector parameters. For this reason, this type of control finds wide applications in low-performance industrial drive systems. By contrast, vector control bases its principle of operation on the “Field Orientation Principle” to adjust the magnitude and spatial position of the vector parameters of the induction motors (Trzynadlowski 43). Vector controlled motors are applied in high-performance drive systems in which the instantaneous magnetic field and torque of the motor are controlled, both under momentary and constant operating conditions. This report provides a comparison between V/F control and vector control regarding their descriptions, applications, advantages, and limitations. V/F CONTROL Description A V/F control involves a relationship that remains essential to the operation of induction motors utilizing the concept of flexible frequency control. It bases its principle of operation on the theory that an AC induction motor generates torque due to its rotating field’s flux. As such, the control method aims to control the value of stator voltage in respect to the frequency, in an attempt to keep the flux of the motor’s stator steady and in turn, allow the stator to generate a full load torque. Based on this, Trzynadlowski argues that V/F control involves adjusting the supply frequency in order to regulate the speed of the rotating flux of the stator (43). The moment of rotation thus developed in the induction motor depends entirely on the slip speed – difference in stator and rotor speeds. Under steady conditions, the motor’s air-gap magnetic flux approximates to the relationship,, where represents the phase voltage’s amplitude of the motor, and represents the applied synchronous electrical frequency (Goldberg 33). The following diagram shows operation of a typical V/F control technique. The motor base point describes the characteristics of the V/F controller. Below this point, the induction motor ‘operates overexcited’ due to the steady state, while above the point, it ‘operates underexicited’ due to voltage limit of the DC-bus (Brejl, Princ, & Uhlir) In addition to the constant V/F control, other versions of V/F control include the closed-loop, current source, and variable voltage source systems. Among the three, the closed-loop system is the second, after the constant method, commonly applied V/F control. It applies an analog sensor in its control loop to regulate the actual speed of the motor. Advantages One of the chief benefits of V/F control regards its strength under steady-state conditions. In constant V/F control, the value of an increase in torque is usually 100 ms. As a result, Holtz argues that lack of a closed-loop mechanism, and limitation to stable performance make V/F based drive systems extremely strong (1365). V/F-regulated systems also show robust function even in the very low speed ranges, where vector-controlled systems fail to show robustness. In addition, V/F control is simple to implement, and in turn, allows it to be integrated in extremely complex electronic devices. Its simplicity makes it a cost-effective control technique to use in induction motors for light and low-performance industrial and home applications. Disadvantages V/F control remains inadequate for high demand drive systems, mainly because its principle of control is imprecise. It does not respond well to extreme speed fluctuations, which limits its application to industrial systems that need little servo performance. Applications V/F control is commonly applied in home and industrial appliances not only for its simplicity, but because it also provides a cost-effective way to ensure stability in light and low servo performance appliances. According to Kataoka, Sato, and Bendiadellah, industries find it economically- and technically-feasible to apply V/F-regulated induction motors due to their “novel control system orientations” (456). Common appliances using V/F-controlled motors include pumps, fan drives, grinders, centrifuges, etc. VECTOR CONTROL Description Also called field-oriented control, vector control involves controlling both the phase and magnitude of a vector variable. It decouples the moment of force generating currents supplied to an induction motor and the magnetizing flux and regulates them separately. Rashid argues that the control technique transforms instantaneous currents of the stator to a rotary reference plane parallel to the stator, motor’s rotating element, or air-gap flux vectors, to generate two current components (one for generating flux and the other for torque) (1046). By maintaining the flux component at a fixed known value, the torque of the motor linearly corresponds to the torque element of the current, making vector-controlled induction motors resemble, in operation, an independently energized DC motor drive system. The following block diagram shows how a vector control method operates. From the diagram, motor line currents, ia, ib, and ic are transformed to and in the fixed reference plane, and then to the simultaneously revolving plane d-q currents, ids and iqs. On the other hand, two inverse conversions occur in the controller: from simultaneous d-q plane to the fixed d-q reference plane, and from d+-Q+ to a+, b+, and c+ (Holtz 1369) Based on the above explanation, input command to a vector control comprises of torque or magnetizing flux, with the flux command being chosen depending on the operation conditions in the steady-state horsepower or steady-state moment of force. On the other hand, the output command consists of the 3-phase orientation voltages. Vector control method is implemented by regulating the motor phase currents in accordance with the orientation voltage commands. It is further classified into two: direct and indirect control methods. Direct field-oriented control applies an air-gap flux transducer or Hall Effect sensor to indicate the value of the air gap magnetic flux. In this way, it is able to regulate the flux in order to create an adjustable torque of the motor. Indirect vector control (open loop or closed loop) measures the flux from motor characteristics such as the current and velocity (Toliyat, Niazi, & Godbole). A closed loop field-oriented control applies speed feedback transducer to regulate motor speed and achieve optimum torque over a speed range extending from zero to base speed. On the other hand, an open loop vector control regulates current to the motor instead of the speed and as such, it has a narrower speed range compared to the closed loop method, which limits its ability to create holding torque when the motor is at rest. In addition to these two vector methods, sensorless field-oriented control is another vector control that finds wide application to control induction motors. Rather than relying on sensors to measure the position of the rotor, it applies other motor characteristics to regulate the motor coil position in order to generate the needed moment of force. Advantages Vector control offers an effective method to maintain the continuity of the torque control during the transient states of the motor drive system. This is because in vector control, space vectors of 3-line motor system are adjusted depending on the control algorithm. Moreover, the control method exhibits constant and dynamic performance compared to V/F control method. Another advantage includes enhanced efficiency, making it possible to replace larger drive systems with smaller ones without compromising speed and torque (Toliyat, Niazi, & Godbole) Disadvantages Vector control configurations are extremely complex to implement compared to V/F control configurations. They always require use of current and voltage transducers, and for enhanced performance level, the configurations may call for application of position and speed transducers. All these components make the overall control technique expensive and thus, cost-ineffective for industrial applications (Goldberg 34). Moreover, indirect vector-controlled drive systems make use of precision shaft encoders in order to ensure accuracy of motor operation. This calls for extra electronic components and other requirements, some of which may interfere with the stability required in induction motors. Applications Due to its ability to offer steady state and dynamic performance, vector control is widely used in industrial appliances operating at high-speeds and requiring high servo performance. Vector-controlled motors are commonly applied in generator and turbine drive systems, servos, actuators for robots, etc (Rashid 744). CONCLUSION Voltage to frequency control aims to regulate the value of stator voltage in respect to the frequency, in an attempt to keep the flux of the motor’s stator steady and in turn, allow the stator to generate a full load torque. V/F-regulated systems show operational stability even in the very low speed ranges, where vector-controlled systems fail to show robustness. However, it remains inadequate for high demand drive systems, mainly because its principle of control is imprecise. Common appliances using V/F-controlled motors include pumps, fan drives, grinders, and centrifuges. On the other hand, vector control decouples the moment of force generating currents supplied to an induction motor and the magnetizing flux and regulates them separately. Field-oriented control exhibits constant and dynamic performance compared to V/F control. Nevertheless, it requires use of current and voltage transducers, which makes its implementation and expensive for small or light industrial applications. As such, it is widely used for high servo performance drive systems such as turbines and generators. Works Cited Brejl, Milan, Michael Princ, and Petr Uhlir. “AC Induction Motor Volts per Hertz Control with Speed Closed Loop, Driven by eTPU on MPC5500.” Freescale Semiconductor AN3205 (2006). Web. 24 Dec. 2010. Goldberg, Lee. Green Electronics, Green Bottom Line: Environmentally Responsible Engineering. London, UK: Newness, 2000. Print. Holtz, Joachim. “Sensorless Control of Induction Motor Drives.” Proceedings of the IEEE 90.8 (2002): 1359-1365. Print. Kataoka, T., Y. Sato, A. Bendiabdellah. “A Novel Volts/Hertz Control Method for an Induction Motor to Improve the Torque Characteristics in the Low Speed Range.” Power Electronics and Applications 5 (1993): 455-458. Print. Rashid, M.H. Power Electronics Handbook: Devices, Circuits, and Applications. 2nd ed. San Diego, CA: Academic Press, 2006. Print. Toliyat, Hamid, Peyman Niazi, and Kedar Godbole. Overcoming Vector Control Challenges. Mechatronic-design, 5 Dec. 2007. Web. 25 Dec. 2010. Trzynadlowski, Andrzej. The Field Orientation Principle in Control of Induction Motors. Berlin: Springer, 1994. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Voltage to Frequency Control vs Vector Control Essay, n.d.)
Voltage to Frequency Control vs Vector Control Essay. https://studentshare.org/physics/2045580-comparison-between-quotvoltage-to-frequency-control-and-vector-controlquot
(Voltage to Frequency Control Vs Vector Control Essay)
Voltage to Frequency Control Vs Vector Control Essay. https://studentshare.org/physics/2045580-comparison-between-quotvoltage-to-frequency-control-and-vector-controlquot.
“Voltage to Frequency Control Vs Vector Control Essay”. https://studentshare.org/physics/2045580-comparison-between-quotvoltage-to-frequency-control-and-vector-controlquot.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Voltage to Frequency Control vs Vector Control

Theory of the experiment

The only disadvantage is that it has low frequency.... The aim of the paper “Theory of the experiment” is to build an amplifier; to evaluate the performance of the built amplifier; to learn the functions of its components through testing; to improve my knowledge and skills of an amplifier through conducting 'real' experiments....
8 Pages (2000 words) Lab Report

Electric timer quotation

The chip was powered by applying 9V DC between pin 14 and pin 7 also the waveform of Va, Vb and Vc was recorded also the oscilloscope frequency was measured.... M, the Vc was monitored and the frequency measuredTo improve the tune, the following was done.... To estimate the power delivered to the to the load, the following was done• The loud speaker was replaced with the load resistor R(load)=10R• The waveform of the voltage drop across the R(load)  and Vload was recorded• The top level of Vload, V(top) was measuredTo check how the power affects the amplitude of the load, the following was done• The supply power was reduced from 9V gradually and the corresponding reduction Vtop value was notedTo study the effect of component value on the oscillation the following was done;• For the values of  R=1k, 10k, 620k and 3....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Calculating the Operating Parameters of the DC-DC Boost Converter for Automobile Electronics

Its parameters are the most suitable for the technical assignment since it works within the given frequency range, and the operating frequency will be controlled by a capacitor.... Therefore, the DC-DC converter will help to avoid the possible voltage declines.... The boost converter, that is needed for the current project, is a converter that provides the step-up conversion of the input voltage.... Therefore, the inductor resists the DC changes, and the input voltage is boosted....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Active and Reactive Power Control in Grid-Connected Solar Photovoltaic Systems

This project “Active and Reactive Power control in Grid-Connected Solar Photovoltaic Systems” examines an alternative to solve the voltage stability issues of the system which proved its simplicity with regard to hardware implementation and computational requirements....   The controlling the active and reactive power in grid-connected PV systems will include carrying out a literature review as well as conducting a series of simulations using MATLAB program and Pulse Width Bandwidth to investigate the feasibility of active and reactive power control in grid-connected solar photovoltaic systems....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Frequency Domain Analysis of Control Systems and Time Domain Analysis

This term paper "Frequency Domain Analysis of control Systems and Time Domain Analysis" focuses on explores frequency domain analysis and time domain analysis.... In control systems, control theory is normally used both in the analysis and design of feedback systems.... control system refers to the use of algorithms and feedback in engineered systems.... control system includes such examples as feedback loops in setpoint controllers and even router protocols controlling traffic flow on the internet....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Designing, Implementing and Testing a Timer

However, low frequency and power inefficiency is the main drawback for class A amplifiers.... Class B amplifiers are characterized by the high frequency that degrades the audio signal quality.... "Designing, Implementing and Testing a Timer" paper contains the experiment that aimed to construct an amplifier, appraise the performance of the amplifier, examine the roles of components of the amplifier, and enhances the practical knowledge and technical know-how on how the amplifier works....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Design, Implement and Test a Timer

The frequency expected is 1 kHz but the frequency produced is 618.... The frequency is low and used where the power supply is adequate.... It always amplifies maximum voltage.... "Design, Implement and Test a Timer" paper contains the experiment that was performed under numerous objectives such as; making an amplifier, examining the work and the performance of the amplifier, and testing the functions of the built amplifier's components....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Electrical Measurement and Data Acquisition System

By heating the junction, a small voltage basically appears between the two wires (metals).... This voltage increases monotonically when the temperature is increased through what is called the see beck effect.... Basically, when a quartz crystal is subjected to an external force, there results in a voltage change that is generated across the entire surface.... A D/A  converter converts digital data which is in binary form to an analog form or signal such as current, voltage, or just mere electrical charge....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us