StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ethical Analysis of Hurricane Katrina Disaster - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the report “Ethical Analysis of Hurricane Katrina Disaster” the author criticizes the US government which failed in a few issues. They did not take care of the construction reliability. As well, they did not adequately allocate resources to deal with the consequences of the hurricane…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.5% of users find it useful
Ethical Analysis of Hurricane Katrina Disaster
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ethical Analysis of Hurricane Katrina Disaster"

Ethical Analysis of Hurricane Katrina Disaster Hurricane Katrina can be termed as an example of a case where the government failed at several points. Firstly, they are blamed of faulty construction and could not fund the project adequately before the disaster. Secondly, they could not allocate the funding to deal with the aftermath of the disaster and severely misallocated the resources. In the light of some of these issues, I would like to study the Hurricane Katrina disaster and analyze the ethical aspects of it. In my report, I shall look into the issues and concerns related to the disaster and analyze what has been done to resolve these. Further, I shall also evaluate the efforts by the state and federal government and give an opinion on how effective these measures were from an ethical perspective. There are several ethical issues related to the Katrina disaster which have their own consequences. The foremost issue arising out of it is the allocation of tax funds. In a disaster situation like this, it is the government’s responsibility to come out and help the victims out of the funds they receive from the tax payers. However, it is the duty of the government that the money is spent wisely. The government should ensure that they spend the amount in a way such that a large number of people affected by the disaster can be compensated. They should receive all items of necessity which should help them in getting back to their normal lives. In the relief efforts after the Katrina disaster, this did not seem the case. Several sources have reported about the unnecessary and unfair spending by the governments. A group called Taxpayers for Common sense (Tax Payers for Common Sense) is one such group which has posted about the government contract information and has indicated about what amount is being spent and who is actually receiving the benefits. The statistics revealed by this group are very shocking and alarming. Any regular tax payer would feel amazed and disgruntled to see his hard earned money being wasted in the name of helping people. Some of the expenditures, done in the name of providing relief and welfare to the victims, reported by this website include $25,078 to purchase laptop computers, $92.28 for a knife, $2950 for a wristwatch $1050,000 for computer software, $281,200 for athletic and sports equipment and $2,115,000 for envelopes and papers. These statistics clearly reflect the unethical practices carried out by the government in the name of welfare. Firstly, it is hard to believe that the government would go ahead and pay such high prices for these items. The departments responsible for purchases have either being totally ignorant on what price they should pay, or have purposely ignored them. On the other hand, even if we ignore the prices of these items and just look at the names, it also appears to be another great shock. The items being bought are mostly items of luxury which do not play a great part in a person’s everyday life. Spending on items like athletic and sports equipment, computer software and Pen Activated Computer Tablets are a sheer wastage of important welfare funds. This also indicates that there has been no audit done by any authority to verify whether the items being purchased are of necessity or not. Any tax payer, who gets detached with his hard earned money taken in the name of tax by the government, would want to protest against the unnecessary spending done by the government. The reason why this becomes an ethical issue is because these actions are legal, but are not correct from a social perspective. There is always a limited amount that is allocated towards carrying out the relief efforts. Normally there are a large number of victims in a disaster and the amount has to be spent to provide relief efforts to all of them. Ideally, these funds should be spent in a way that a large number of people can receive help and get back to their normal lives. In cases like these where the amount is being spent to buy useless items and that too for such extravagant prices, the funds will be distributed very unfairly. Only a few people might be able to take advantage of the relief funds and the rest will still be suffering. It is unethical that some people in the society get extraordinary treatment where as others suffer. It is the government’s duty to allocate the amount in a way that it helps out the maximum number of people and does not promote inequality or unfairness. These expenditures are all funded by tax payers. These tax payers are themselves hardworking people who take out a considerable portion of their income to give it to the government. They expect the government would use these funds wisely for the welfare of the people. They want efficient utilization of these funds for maximum welfare of the society. When the relief amount is being spent on such lavish items, it is unfair to the ordinary tax payers. Items like expensive laptops and sports goods, which have been bought at such high prices, normally a taxpayer might not be able to afford them. It would be unfair to him if other people are getting undue benefits out of his hard-earned income. Another ethical concern is related to the property rights approach. Government has no resources of its own and has to acquire them from the people. It is not fair that the taxpayers of California, Oregon and Michigan should be asked to pay for rebuilding New Orleans. When taxpayers of one state are forced to pay for reconstruction in another state, this becomes an ethical issue. As said by Bastiat (Bastiat) in 1840s: “The state is the great fictitious entity by which everyone seeks to live at the expense of everyone else.” If we look at the relief efforts, the federal government was involved in allocating the funds. This is considered to be unethical by many people. Giving a utilitarian argument, they say that the government can never allocate resources in an efficient manner. The private sector is much more efficient in doing everything. Wastage of scarce resources is considered unethical from a social perspective. Undoubtedly, the destruction caused by Hurricane Katrina was immense particularly in the coastal regions where several houses were destroyed by the floods. Although there is no constitutional authority for involving in charitable activities towards relief and rehabilitation of the victims, it is special interest legislation as opposed to something that provides for the general welfare. If someone, at their own risk, wants to live in a flood zone, they should be ready to meet the cost of destruction. If they cannot, they should simple move to another location. People, having enough sense to not live in flood areas, are the ones who are paying for the insurance premiums of those who chose to settle in these areas. In other words, the general public is being forced to subsidize this behavior. It is highly unfair to force the lower and middle income taxpayers to subsidize for pay for reconstructing the homes of millionaires. The houses along the Long Island beach in New York are all multi-million dollar homes which end up being destroyed every few years. The government ends up paying for the damages to these wealthy house owners out of the hard earned money of the poor tax payers in other areas. This unfair treatment towards some people makes it a socially unethical issue. This is where the government should start thinking and realize what they are doing. Yes, relief and rehabilitation is important, but only to people who really need it. Firstly, they should discourage construction along the levees in flood regions. Despite that, even if people want to construct their homes, they should be told to do at their own risk and no compensation should be made in terms of any disaster. In this report I have looked some of the ethical issues rising out of the Hurricane Katrina disaster. The reason which makes them a concern is because some people are being treated unfairly at the expense of some other people. The government should seek to ensure equality and justice in the society and not punish some people in order to giver rewards to some others. Bibliography Bastiat, F. Selected Essays on Political Economy, Foundation for Economics. New York, NY: Irvington-on-Hudson, 1964. McGee, Robert W. "An economic and ethical analysis of the Katrina disaster." IJSE 35,7 (n.d.): 546-557. Tax Payers for Common Sense. 4 December 2009 . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Ethical Analysis of Hurricane Katrina Disaster Research Paper, n.d.)
Ethical Analysis of Hurricane Katrina Disaster Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1730778-ethical-paper
(Ethical Analysis of Hurricane Katrina Disaster Research Paper)
Ethical Analysis of Hurricane Katrina Disaster Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1730778-ethical-paper.
“Ethical Analysis of Hurricane Katrina Disaster Research Paper”. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1730778-ethical-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical Analysis of Hurricane Katrina Disaster

Wal-Mart Business Strategy Analysis

The analysis of the business strategies of Wal-Mart reveals considerable edge for the company in terms of efficiency in handing business operations… In the age on increased business competition, it has become very vital to ensure organizational efficiency.... The present paper "Wal-Mart Business Strategy analysis" shall examine the marketing and business activities of the Wal-Mart....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The American Red Cross

ue to the behavior of the American Red Cross (ARC) following the aftermath of hurricane katrina and 9/11 their reputation with regard to business effects benefits were greatly dented.... A lot of distress arose about ARC in the scenario and since its major role is to give a fast response aid to victims of any disaster, the World Trade Center attack in New York city and the Hurrican Katrina were chief occurrences that were of great effect in the United States....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

The Concept of Public Administration - Lindblom

The concept of public administration and the development that is associated with this particular field of study has also led to different approaches and concepts in mastering the skills required.... Defining the specific approaches that are required to master this field also build… A renowned individual which understood the process of public administration was Charles Lindblom....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Discuss the impact of social classes with hurricane katrina and its aftermath

The storm claimed thousands of lives and caused further damages of more Effects of hurricane katrina on the people in New Orleans New Orleans is susceptible to hurricanes and storms.... "The effects of hurricane katrina on the New Orleans economy.... "New Orleans: Poor residents suffer deepest impact of hurricane katrina.... All these factors… hurricane katrina that struck in 2005 had calamitous and long term effects on New Orleans....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Hidden Facts of Hurricane Katrina

The author of this assignment "The Hidden Facts of hurricane katrina" claims that according to the commission's findings that the preparation for and response to the hurricane was a failure of Initiative.... The government knew that a disaster of the magnitude of Katrina is likely to happen from the exercise conducted by the government in which New Orleans was struck by a stimulated hurricane.... With proper management and efficient disaster control and relief system, the disastrous effects of Katrina could have been avoided....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Wal-Mart Analysis from a CSR Perspective

2), Wal-Mart contributed money and commodities for hurricane katrina relief.... Wal-Mart is a United States multinational business corporation, which was formed in 1962 and later incorporated in 1969; the company runs warehouses and discount department business.... King and Lawley (2012, p....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Investigating Entrepreneurial Opportunities

The idea of this research emerged from the author's interest and fascination in how many companies are involved in setting up swimming pools and water springs and what are the challenges involved in setting up swimming pools and water springs.... hellip; According to the research findings, it can, therefore, be said that the business idea to set up swimming pools is brilliant and there is a great opportunity to execute it....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Hurricane Katrina - the Costliest and the Most Dangerous Disaster That Has Ever Happened in the US

The author of the paper "hurricane katrina - the Costliest and the Most Dangerous Disaster That Has Ever Happened in the US" states that hurricane katrina was a deadly and extremely destructive tropical cyclone that struck the southeastern side of the United States of America.... hellip; hurricane katrina occurred in late August in 2005.... According to the Tropical cyclone report presented by Knabb, Rhome & Brown (2005), hurricane katrina event was extraordinarily tragic and fatal, and it claimed over 1800 lives....
1 Pages (250 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us